The battle of the beanfield, where police ran riot

The Observer, 9 June 1985

This weekend, the twisting country lanes of Wiltshire are witness to a bizarre and very Unenglish scene.

Along the grassy verges underneath the beech trees, riot police sit waiting in their vans, windows darkened and reinforced. On the A303 towards Amesbury, there are road blocks. And around the ancient monument of Stonehenge are rings of a peculiarly unpleasant type of barbed wire known as razor wire.

Just up the road, in Savernake Forest, is the object of this formidable concentration of police power – a group of some 300 hippies, members of the so-called Peace Convoy, whose battered buses and cars are drawn up between the trees and who play rock music around camp fires late into the night.

Between the police and the Convoy stands the unlikely figure of David Michael James Brudenell-Bruce, the 32-year-old Earl of Cardigan, secretary of the Marlborough Conservative Association, old Etonian and now, surprisingly, a passionate defender of the Convoy.

As the owner of Savernake Forest, Lord Cardigan has been drawn into a long and bitter feud between police and hippies which culminated last Saturday in scenes of extraordinary violence. Precisely what happened when 700 police officers in riot gear poured into a bean field at Park House near Cholderton to take on 500 men, women and children, was witnessed at first hand by relatively few outsiders.

The police had ordered Press and public to stay behind their lines. Lord Cardigan was there, with the local Tory chairman, John Moore, and a handful of journalists, including myself and Observer photographer Ben Gibson.

All of us were shocked by what we saw: police tactics which seemed to break new bounds in the scale and intensity of their violence. We saw police throw hammers, stones and other missiles through the windscreens of advancing vehicles; a woman dragged away by her hair; young men beaten over the head with truncheons as they tried to surrender; police using sledgehammers to smash up the interiors of the hippies’ coaches.

Lord Cardigan, who was in the field throughout, said: “One image will probably stay with me for the rest of my life. I saw a policeman hit a woman on the head with his truncheon. Then I looked down and saw she was pregnant, and I thought: ‘My God, I’m watching police who are running amok.'”

The events of last weekend raise a series of disturbing questions. Not just because this was a police operation that apparently slipped out of control, but because the officers involved seemed to be applying a new approach to policing. The Wiltshire officers in charge, like those from the five other rural forces who helped them, have all been on duty at Greenham Common and throughout the miners’ dispute. Their tough and aggressive attitude to the hippies owed more to the picket line than to normal standards of crowd control.

It was hard to discern in the events of last Saturday the doctrine of minimum force that is enshrined for police officers as for any civilian in section three of the 1967 Criminal Law Act: “A person may use such force as is reasonable in the circumstances in the prevention of crime, or in the effecting of, or assisting in, the lawful arrest of offenders…”

That is not to say that the Peace Convoy and its advance towards Stonehenge was in any way a run-of-the-mill affair. The Convoy has been an annual irritant in Wiltshire since the first festival in 1974 when a small group of people who still clung obstinately to the ideals of the 1960s joined together to escape city life by living on the road.

Over the years, the Convoy has expanded, picking up young unemployed punks and Hells Angels, the inadequate and the outcast. They have cultivated an archaic faith in the power of the moon and the trees and, more than anything else, in Stonehenge where the Convoy was born and where they go each year for their pilgrimage. At the summer solstice on June 21, they cross the road from their site to the stones and baptise their babies.

Their public face has been quite different. Absurdly exaggerated press stories have pictured them overdosing on drugs, laying waste to the countryside, terrorising whole towns and beating the police into submission. “Sex-mad junkie outlaws make Hells Angels look like Little Noddy,” as the News of the World put it. (In fact, the Convoy has one strict rule: no hard drugs.)

The Conservative MP for Salisbury, Robert Key, raised the matter in the Commons, where he spoke of hand-grenades, shotguns and armed law-breakers. He called for the army to be brought in. Later, he conceded that he had no direct evidence to support his allegations.

In March, the Convoy were evicted from their winter camp near Salisbury race course. They moved to Fargo Woods within sight of Stonehenge. In April, they were evicted from there. Some of their vehicles were destroyed, and many of them were arrested. They went to the High Court and successfully challenged the eviction. The 1984 festival, which attracted some 30,000 people, then went ahead – the final straw for the Wiltshire establishment.

English Heritage, the society which owns the stones; the National Trust, which owns the surrounding land; and Wiltshire County Council, which owns the highways and verges joined forces to stop the 1985 festival with a series of High Court injunctions.

With the Convoy still scattered around the country in winter camps, the injunctions were granted without the Convoy ever putting their case; and only one of the 83 individuals named in the injunctions had heard what was happening. The Convoy then began to assemble and move towards Wiltshire, breaking the injunctions of which most of them had no knowledge.

Wiltshire police was already one of the small number of forces with stocks of CS gas and plastic bullets. Now, they hired a helicopter, cancelled all leave, arranged for reinforcements from the Ministry of Defence and five other forces, and set about organising the biggest operation in their history.

When I joined the Convoy last week, they seemed only vaguely aware of the reception awaiting them. One of them, called Caroline, said: “The stone-age barrows give off a power which will help us.” Ian, a rune expert, said: “It is a good time for movement. There will be obstacles, but they will be overcome.”

With battered old engines roaring, we rode into Wiltshire, flags flying, Bruce Springsteen music playing. Inside the Wiltshire boundary, the police stopped us and moved through the vehicles taking names. Some pointed out that they had no legal right to do this. The police agreed but carried on asking.

The police escorted us into Marlborough and up the steep hill to Savernake Forest, where Lord Cardigan was standing blinking in amazement. “I own the forest,” he said. “The police asked if I minded having a few vehicles. They said there might be 15 of them. There are hundreds.”

There were up to 1,000 people in the forest, playing guitars and cooking on wood fires. Almost everything – language, music, clothes, attitudes – was 20 years out of date.

That night there was talk about whether the police would ‘trash’ them the next day, but there was no council of war. Sid Rawle, the longest-standing member of the Convoy, now in his 40s, balding and long-haired, sat quietly in his caravan, surrounded by five sleeping children. “We have chaos on our side,” he said.

Sid and others had two days earlier submitted to the National Trust a detailed proposal for an alternative site, but there was no answer. That night, there was no attempt by the police, the National Trust, English Heritage, nor the County Council to talk to the Convoy.

The Convoy slept late, and it was early afternoon before a long chain of 140 rumbling, wheezing buses, vans, ambulances and cars started to curl out of the forest, south of Stonehenge. Tucked into the front section was Lord Cardigan, riding a motorcycle with the local Tory chairman, John Moore, on the pillion. “We want to see what is going to happen,” they said.

It was a pleasant ride. Lunch-time drinkers waved from the village pubs; the Convoy stopped to buy crisps and apples. In front and behind, dozens of riot police in reinforced vans rode with us.

Fifteen miles south, just outside the village of Shipton Bellinger, the back six vehicles, in one of which I was travelling, got separated from the rest of the Convoy by a breakdown. A young punk sprinted down the road, yelling: “They’re going to try and take the back vehicles. We heard it on the police radio.”

It was too late. The rural ride was suddenly over as police ran up either side of the vehicles, shouting “Out, out, out,” snatching keys from the ignition and dragging out the occupants. Soon they were packed into police vans and driven north to police cells. I was arrested and then released. I walked on to rejoin the rest of the Convoy, now trapped by police vans blocking the road.

There were shouts and jeers from the Convoy. After a while, a group of officers came forwards and started to break vehicle windows with their truncheons. The Convoy, trapped, swung their vehicles into a field, crashing through a hedge.

For the next four hours, there was ugly stalemate. Some of the Convoy threw sticks and stones at the police. One threw a bottle of petrol. Others got into vehicles and roared towards the police lines before veering away. Most retreated to the middle of the field and worried about what was going to happen. The police mounted several baton charges in a vain attempt to disperse them.

The Convoy started trying to negotiate, offering to abandon the festival and return to Savernake Forest or to leave Wiltshire altogether. The police refused to negotiate and told them they could all surrender or face the consequences.

At ten past seven, the battle began. In the next half hour, whatever their plans and tactics, the police operation became a chaotic whirl of violence. And along the way basic rules of police behaviour were abandoned.

The identification numbers of most officers were concealed by flame-proof overalls, in direct contradiction of Home Office undertakings. The guidance on the use of truncheons – to be used only as a last resort and only on arms and legs of a target – was abandoned .

At one point, I saw a youth inside a bus, surrounded by policemen, trying to give himself up. He climbed out of a broken window and found himself falling on to a sea of policemen who – only a few feet in front of me – were leaning over each other to get in a blow. I saw the young man’s glasses swiped from his face and his front teeth break under the raining blows.

The command structure of the officers appeared to have disintegrated. They entered the field in groups of 10 led by sergeants and inspectors. But during the battle the units became separated from each other and from their senior officers. Above us, a police helicopter, circling overhead, barked down encouragement from a loud-hailer: “You’re doing a great job. This is the way they like it.”

As the police swirled round the field, they picked up anything that came to hand and threw it. Witnesses saw one officer with a handful of stones, lobbing at any coach that came close. Others saw them throw hammers, sticks, shields, helmets and extinguishers.

Cardigan saw a baby lifted out of its cot. “It was covered in glass from head to foot,” he said. John Moore saw police commandeer Convoy vehicles and use them as battering rams: “At one point an inspector told me to leave the field because his boys were getting a bit worked up and I might get hit.”

Photographer Ben Gibson and I saw a boy being led from a bus, his arms wrenched high above his back, blood pouring down his face. Gibson was arrested as he tried to photograph him.

Afterwards, witnesses saw the police gather the Convoy’s vehicles in the field and move through them, smashing windows and breaking possessions. One local woman who drove a young girl back to her Convoy bus said: “Everything inside the bus was broken. Her guitar and her camera were smashed, the posters had been torn off the wall, there was food and clothes all piled up together in the middle of the floor. Even the yoghurts had been stabbed and spilled everywhere. The poor girl just couldn’t stop crying. She kept saying ‘This is my home. They’ve smashed my home’.”

Last night, that girl and some 300 others like her were still in Savernake Forest, still saying that the free festival would be held at Stonehenge for the summer Solstice on 21 June. Outside the forest, the police were waiting, while Lord Cardigan patrolled anxiously between.

Wiltshire Police last week refused to discuss the operation. They said it was ‘sub judice’ because people had been charged and were awaiting trial. But, with pressure building from MPs and local figures, they face prolonged questioning about a battle which is already a milestone in British policing.