Bishop joins unique campaign to close Holloway wing

The Observer, 31 March 1985

A bishop called on the Home Office yesterday to close down the psychiatric wing at Holloway women’s prison, describing it as ‘a nightmarish place’ where inmates were ‘hounded into the final corner.’

The Rt Rev. Jim Thompson, Bishop of Stepney, has been visiting women in Holloway prison, north London, for seven years.

He is supporting a unique campaign, to be launched tomorrow, in which all major prison reform groups are uniting behind MIND and the National Council for Civil Liberties to demand the wing’s closure.

Known officially as Cl, the wing holds a floating population of 40 women, deemed mentally disturbed. They are kept in solitary confinement for up to 24 hours a day, often without books or any form of distraction. Many are tranquilised.

The Observer disclosed six months ago that there had been a series of attempted suicides and outbreaks of self-mutilation in the wing. Similar incidents are still being reported.

The bishop said he had no doubt that conditions there worsened the women’s mental health. “The real damage is caused by the fact that they take people who are feeling isolated, suicidal – and then for reasons of security or staffing, make them much more isolated. It is the worst possible thing for such a person.

“On the occasions that I have been on the wing, it has made a very, very big impact on me. The eyes are the thing I remember. I can still see one particular woman I met down there who had done terrible damage to herself, to her arms and wrists. She was like a caged beast, totally bewildered, totally violent to herself, wanting to finish with life.

“It gave me a nightmarish feeling. It has to do with the total depersonalising of an individual for security reasons. Like ‘One Flew Over the Cuckoos Nest’, people hounded into the final corner. I wondered: ‘What on earth has happened to these people? Doesn’t anyone care any more about these people?'”

The MIND/NCCL campaign is drawing support from Nacro, the Howard League for Penal Reform, the National Association of Probation Officers, the Prison Reform Trust and Women In Prison. Its aim is to close the wing and to persuade the Prison Department and National Health Service to provide adequate places in prisons and hospitals for mentally disturbed prisoners.

Holloway’s future is being reviewed by a special committee, and it is understood that the Prison Department has decided in principle to close the wing. However, its failure to announce a closure date has caused widespread concern.

Prison sources report that there have been renewed bouts of attempted hangings and self-mutilations. The department says that staff shortages make it difficult to keep figures. One woman suffering from Huntingdon’s Chorea spent three months on the wing awaiting trial before being transferred to a hospice to die.

Mr Larry Gostin, NCCL general secretary, who visited the wing last month, said: “This place is so inhuman and so cruel that you have to set aside politics and fancy thinking and just say: ‘It can’t go on.’ The wing is as bad as Rampton Hospital was when it was going through its worst period.

“If the public could see what it’s like in there, they would never tolerate it. If you found animals in London Zoo being treated that way, there would be an outcry across the country. You just can’t treat human beings that way.”