Cathy Massiter, the former intelligence officer at the centre of the storm about illegal MI5 surveillance techniques, was told to see a psychiatrist and then forced to retire early when she complained to her superiors about the work she was doing.
Her attempt last week to make her complaints public in a Channel 4 television documentary was stopped by the IBA on legal grounds, although documents in the possession of The Observer reveal that two prominent barristers held that the programme could be defended.
Speaking at a friend’s house where she has been staying, Massiter told The Observer that :
* MI5’s Registry holds illegal files on CND activists, including the chairwoman Mrs Joan Ruddock and two senior officials, while Special Branch has opened files on “thousands of CND members around the country.”
* MI5 broke its own rules on the tapping of telephones and the use of undercover agents to satisfy politicians’ demands for intelligence on the peace movement.
* MI5’s domestic activities expanded hugely in the 1970s to take in new ‘soft’ targets including solicitors, barristers, journalists and pressure groups including Shelter.
Miss Massiter, aged 37, who spent 14 years in MI5, described how her concern came to a head in spring 1981 when she was given the job of investigating the peace movement. Officially, she was supposed to be watching known Communists to check that they were not manipulating peace groups. Unofficially, she was being pressed to gather information on the whole peace movement in breach of MI5’s charter.
According to its rules, MI5’s domestic work should he limited to subversives, defined as those who threaten the safety of the State and seek to undermine parliamentary democracy. Only a minority of CND’s members match this definition.
Mrs Ruddock, who became chairwoman in 1983, did not fit the definition. “It was fully recognised that she had no subversive affiliation, but now she was chairwoman and very prominent in the public eye, they wanted a file opened,” said Ms Massiter.
The problem of finding an official recording category which would fit Mrs Ruddock was solved when she gave an interview to a Soviet journalist based in London. “The journalist was actually a KGB officer,” said Ms Massiter. “Joan Ruddock didn’t know that, but it provided the grounds for recording her as a ‘contact of a hostile intelligence service,’ which was ridiculous.”
On that pretext, the file was opened and filled with press cuttings and Special Branch references to her movements. Two other prominent CND figures were similarly brought into the system of surveillance.
Cathy Ashton, a former executive member, was recorded as a ‘communist sympathiser’ on the ground that she shared a house with a member of the Communist Party. Mr Roger Spiller, a vice-chairman, had a long-standing and false entry in the MI5 Registry to the effect that he had been in the Young Communist League when he was a student. MI5 believed the report was false but used it as a pretext for recording him as a ‘member of a subversive organisation.’
“It was a classic example of the way people go on record,” she said. Ms Massiter was ordered to spread her investigation from CND’s national organisation to its regional structure, and she attended a series of provincial Special Branch conferences at which MI5 officers briefed the police on their needs.
“I think Special Branch were rather confused about what we wanted,” she said. “I’d go to these conferences and get up and say we were only interested in real subversives, then I’d speak to them on the phone and say ‘Well, in fact, we’d like quite a bit more than that’.
“Much of what the police discovered about CND was held locally in Special Branch files. It’s impossible to say how many files they have got on CND members who are not actually subversives, but there are certainly thousands round the country. MI5 itself has two or three hundred files on CND members who are not ‘subversive’ under the definition.”
The decision to tap the telephone of a CND vice-president, Mr John Cox, first mooted in April 1983 and executed in August, worried her even more. “I got a message via my branch director that the deputy director general was prepared to consider favourably an application from me for a telephone check on a suitable CND target – ie a member of the Communist Party who could reasonably be classified as a ‘subversive.'” Mr Cox did not meet the test. “We knew from our coverage of the Communist Party that he was not getting up to anything in CND.”
That weakness was reflected in her official warrant application, which was passed up through the deputy director general to the Home Secretary, Mr Leon Brittan. The application simply said that Mr Cox was a long-term member of the Communist Party and prominent in CND, and that it was desired to investigate his contacts and activities to ascertain whether the Communist Party was manipulating CND in a clandestine way. In August 1983, the Home Secretary signed the warrant.
The results of all this surveillance were circulated through Whitehall by MI5 in a series of ‘Box 500’ reports. Although they were classifed as secret, they were passed to the new information unit, DS19, set up by Mr Michael Heseltine to combat CND. A lengthy briefing paper on CND was specially prepared by MI5 for Mr Heseltine when he took over as Defence Secretary in 1983.
Miss Massiter says she and other officers working on the DSI9 project were worried that this was a breach of the MI5 charter that “no inquiry is to be carried out on behalf of any government department unless you are satisfied that an important public interest bearing on the defence of the realm is at stake.”
The surveillance of the peace movement followed a wider shift by MI5 towards new domestic targets during the 1970s. In London, new ‘desks’ were established. Radical lawyers, including Mr Larry Grant who acted for the CIA whistleblower Mr Philip Agee, were entered into the Registry as ‘Communist sympathisers.’ The housing pressure group Shelter was watched on the grounds that it might be the target of Communist penetration.
There was a new desk to look at ‘subversion in the media.’ MI5 also vetted all graduate trainees who started work at the BBC, as well as any BBC journalist who took a politically sensitive post.
During 1983, Miss Massiter says, she complained about the nature of the work she was being asked to do: to the head of her section; to her assistant director; and finally to the personnel branch. She was told to see a consultant psychiatrist who has been given security clearance to deal with MI5 officers’ personal problems.
“I was complaining that I felt the work we were doing was unnecessary and that we were giving in to persistent political pressure. I did feel fairly emotional about it, but they tried to make my reactions the issue and did nothing at all about my complaints.” She saw the psychiatrist.
“They were obviously not really concerned about my mental health or they wouldn’t have let me carry on working, but the upshot of it all was that it was made very clear that I had to go. I had already decided to resign anyway and had told them so.”
After leaving the service last February she took the unprecedented decision to appear on television to make her concern public. The TV producers, Geoffrey Seed and Claudia Milne, said yesterday : The IBA’s ban was not in the public interest.”