Private investigators ‘buy secrets and commit crimes for the state’

The Observer, 3 February 1985

Scotland Yard is being pressed to investigate allegations that private detectives have been secretly working for government departments and obtaining highly confidential information from official records.

This follows the disclosure last week by The Observer that witnesses at the Sizewell nuclear reactor inquiry had been monitored by a detective agency with links to British intelligence.

Now Scotland Yard’s anti-corruption squad, CIB 2, has been handed a 28-page statement outlining allegations against a number of other private detectives who all belong to the Institute of Professional Investigators.

Two former directors of the institute, who have spoken to The Observer, claim that some of their colleagues

* worked as a secret army for government departments, carrying out surveillance, illegal bugging and break-ins;

*bought and sold personal information from official computers — including highly confidential Special Branch files and unemployment records;

*attended official military intelligence seminars where surveillance techniques were disclosed, even though they had no security clearance.

The institute has some 850 members, including a considerable number of former police and intelligence officers. Apart from these former personnel, The Observer has identified some 30 other IPI members who are currently serving in civilian or military intelligence as well as serving police officers and members of the Post Office Investigation Division which deals with the tapping of live phone calls.

The allegations, which concern a minority of IPI members, have been made by a retired London policeman, Mr Dennis Byrne, who was principal of the institute in 1983, and by a former RAF investigator, Mr Gary Murray, an institute director in 1982. Both men now run their own private agencies.

Their central contention is that police or intelligence officers use private investigators as extra manpower, or to do dirty work, and provide confidential information in return. It is a claim the IPI acknowledges. ”We have no evidence of it,” a spokesman said. But it would be foolish to say it doesn’t happen.’

Mr Murray, whose 28-page statement is now with CIB 2, claims he has worked for the security services. ”I had access to a number of areas that were useful to them. I did one particular job for them and then they came back and engaged me for other work. They paid me a monthly retainer and expenses.

“Initially I thought the work needed to be done, but after a while I realised it was a total waste of taxpayers’ money. They had a money-no-object attitude. I didn’t like some of the things they asked me to do, so I told them to get lost.”

Both Mr Murray and Mr Byrne say that information from Special Branch files has been on sale among IPI members. “If private investigators have the right contacts, the information is there for them to take,” Mr Byrne said last week.

Mr Murray says: “I have sat on a park bench with an operational controller from MI5 and given him the name of a particular individual and said I wanted details on him. He has written it down in his Ministry of Defence notebook and come back to me with what I wanted.”

Mr Murray’s statement names a retired police officer who, he claims, has regularly obtained criminal records from the Police National Computer. The officer, who now runs a private agency, has provided the records to companies wanting to vet employees, according to Mr Murray. He has given CIB 2 detectives transcripts of tape-recorded conversations proving beyond doubt that these records were obtained.

Mr Murray and Mr Byrne also allege that IPI members have obtained confidential records from the Department of Health and Social Security. In a letter to a client – which is in the possession of The Observer – a private detective apologises for failing to trace a target: “I had hoped that unemployment records may have revealed something, but my source has been unable to locate a claim in his name.”

Mr Murray has also told police of a seminar he attended at the air force security school at RAF Newton, Nottingham: “We were given lessons in interviewing, interrogation and surveillance and told that some of what we would hear was sensitive and shouldn’t be repeated,” he said. “But there were people there with no security clearance at all.”

Seminars have also been held for IPI members at the Royal Military Police School in Chichester, where there were firearms and explosives demonstrations. The IPI agrees that the seminars were held. “It’s a matter of opinion whether we were given sensitive information,” a spokesman said.