Intelligence services in Britain believe they have traced 36 terrorist suspects who have taken refuge in the Irish Republic to escape being brought back to trial by the Royal Ulster Constabulary and mainland police.
In every case, security sources say, there is sufficient evidence to justify an application for their extradition. But the discreet moves that were being made towards eventually securing their return have been halted by last week’s furore over the ‘blowing’ of the attempt to extradite Evelyn Glenholmes.
The leak has caused considerable bad feeling in Dublin where it was seen as an attempt by Scotland Yard to force the Republic’s hand and a security breach which had the disastrous effect of tipping off Glenholmes. It has ruptured links between police in London and Dublin.
A senior Scotland Yard officer told The Observer: “As far as Glenholmes is concerned it’s two years’ work wasted. But the more worrying thing is the harm which has been done in the short term to the relationship between ourselves and the police in the Republic.
“In dealing with the police force of another country, we have to rely totally on their goodwill, their keenness to follow up things we ask them for. Everyone has been messed up by the Glenholmes business and if they blame us for it then we can’t expect them to have much enthusiasm for jobs we give them when they’ve got plenty of work of their own.”
It is not the first time that Glenholmes has had a lucky escape. Last September she was named by an RUC supergrass, Robert Lean, as a member of the women’s wing of the Provisional IRA. News of her arrest was sent to Scotland Yard, where Anti Terrorist Squad officers had already marked her down as a suspect for the Christmas 1981 bombings in London.
At that stage, they had only one inconclusive piece of evidence, the statement of a man who had been running a London ‘poste-restante’ agency. He believed he could identify Glenholmes as a courier who picked up letters, which, it was established, had been sent from IRA leaders to the London bombing team. It was not enough to charge her.
On 19 October, she was released in Belfast after Lean publicly retracted his evidence. Seven days later the Anti Terrorist Squad produced the extra information which would have enabled them to charge her. By then it was too late.
Glenholmes joined the shifting population of suspects lying low in the Republic, swollen last autumn by up to 18 of the convicted IRA men who broke out of the Maze prison.
Scotland Yard’s best chance of retrieving suspects hiding in the south has historically been to wait for them to cross the border and to hope that RUC surveillance will spot them. The IRA’s former operational head, Brian Keenan, is serving 18 years in Prison after being arrested in Belfast.
Senior officers say the links between the Yard and the RUC are good. However, the links between the RUC and the Irish police, the Garda, are known to be appalling. Relations between the RUC head, Sir John Hermon, and his opposite number in the republic, Lawrence Wren, have been frigid since the incident in September 1982 when the RUC arrested a man who was due to go to Dublin to give evidence against the brother-in-law of the then Justice Minister.
At the operational level, the traditional co-operation of police on each side of the border has been troubled by the unorthodox tactics of specialist units in the north. The Director of Public Prosecutions is considering allegations that intelligence officers crossed illegally into the south to kill an IRA commander, John Francis Green, and on another occasion to kidnap two suspects.
The ructions between Belfast and Dublin police have made it even more important for Scotland Yard to open up a direct link from London to Dublin. For years, the route of extradition was blocked by the Irish courts, which ruled that, if a defendant could show that his purpose in commiting an offense was political, he could not be extradited.
There was sporadic cooperation on intelligence, which was not helped by the fact that Irish republican terrorism was the responsibility of the Special Branch in England, of MI5 in Northern Ireland and of MI6 in the Republic, three agencies which have a record of jealous non-cooperation.
The Yard’s frustration at the use of the Republic as a safe haven was exemplified in May 1983 when police leaked details of two suspects, John Downie and Sean O’Callaghan, and blamed them for the London park bombings of June 1982. The object of the exercise was to neutralise the two men by blowing their cover as a second best to arresting them.
The Yard’s only other option in these years of stalemate was to use the Irish Criminal Law (Jurisdiction) Act of 1976 to let the Dublin courts try defendants for offences committed in England.
Logistical difficulties and suspicion of the Irish courts has meant the law has been used only five times. The 1982 trial of Gerard Tuite in Dublin, when he was jailed for 10 years, was seen by the Yard as a particularly frustrating experience.
The long stalemate started to break down in December 1982 when the Irish Supreme Court heard the case of the INLA leader Dominic McGlinchie, considerably tightened the definition of ‘political offence’ and ordered his extradition.
That signal from the courts was picked up in London, and the Yard began building its own cases to try to exploit the ‘McGlinchey precedent.’ At the beginning of September, at a crucial conference in London, the Attorney General, the Director of Public Prosecutions and the head of the Anti Terrorist Squad agreed to prepare papers for a series of extradition attempts. One of these was Glenholmes.
The plans were drawn up with great caution. In an unusual move, journalists from Fleet Street newspapers, including The Observer and The Sunday Times, were briefed in general terms about what was happening on the understanding that nothing would be printed. It was stressed then that premature publication would infuriate Dublin and alert the targets in the Republic.
On 21 October The Sunday Times published a story saying the Yard was preparing to extradite John Downie. It did no damage as his whereabouts were already well known and, as Dublin and London agreed, he was not being considered for extradition. The Yard pressed on with its plans.
On 2 November the Director of Public Prosecutions formally applied for a warrant to extradite Glenholmes. On 5 November officers flew from London to Dublin with the warrant.
The next day the Irish police pointed out two errors in the warrant. It is understood that the warrant had been issued by a London stipendiary magistrate, who has no jurisdiction for such a warrant; and also that a crucial signature had not been witnessed by a commissioner of oaths. The errors were corrected that day.
On 6 November the Garda started a surveillance operation to locate Glenholmes, but she was not at her usual home in Dundalk. That was not surprising as she had been warned in the summer that the Yard was interested in her after her name was put to an IRA suspect during interrogation in London.
On 7 November, the Garda search continued while the Irish Attorney General, Peter Sutherland, gave the go-ahead for her arrest when she was found. On Friday The Sunday Times told the Yard it was considering publishing the story.
Both the Yard and the Attorney General insist that they asked the paper not to publish. The Irish Prime Minister says his government was considering how to react when it was told that publication was going ahead. The Sunday Times is equally insistent that no one told it not to publish.
The effect of publication was immediate. “Absolutely damaging in terms of security,” according to the Irish Prime Minister. The Yard must now wait to see how damaging it has been in terms of police co-operation against the menace of terrorism.