Revealed: new home for the phone-tapping which European court condemns

The Observer, 5 August 1984

Britain’s secret telephone tapping operation, condemned by the European Court of Human Rights last week as an invasion of privacy, has moved into new headquarters in an attempt to avoid public scrutiny.

The Observer has traced it to the top two floors of Chantrey House, a red-brick, five-storey Victorian block in Eccleston Street, near London’s Victoria Station. It works 24 hours a day behind a screen of closed Venetian blinds.

The secrecy surrounding the operation reflects acute sensitivity over the legality of the work, and the European court judgement has increased anxiety in the intelligence community that there may be a clampdown. “Some of what we do is very nearly illegal,” according to one source, “and some of it is quite definitely illegal.”

The court found that Britain was in breach of article eight of the European Convention on Human Rights, which guarantees the privacy of citizens. The Government is committed to bringing in new legislation to control tapping in the autumn and has said it will take the court’s ruling into account.

Intelligence sources fear that the new law will intrude on inch of their eavesdropping work. The most vulnerable operation, code-named ‘Azure’ by MI5, involves staff from its ‘A’ branch breaking and entering private homes to plant listening devices. They work as a backup to British Telecom engineers.

The role of the engineers, hand-picked and positively vetted, is to enter telephone exchanges to place taps on lines and to enter private homes under the guise of repairing telephones, to install listening devices. If the device is placed inside a telephone, to intercept both conversations in the room and phone calls, it is supposed to be covered by a Home Office warrant.

Another source said: “There has been an argument raging for years about whether the British Telecom people are breaking the law if they put a bug in your room somewhere, as opposed to in your telephone. The general feeling is that it isn’t quite illegal and that it’s up to the owner of the room to make sure the engineer doesn’t do it.”

Equally sensitive is the issue of whether the official warrant system is being abused. The most recent official figures record that in 1979 the Home Secretary authorised 411 telephone taps, but members of the intelligence community say the system is easily manipulated. Warrants can be transferred from one target to another; a warrant for an individual can be used to tap the offices of his organisation; a warrant for an organisation’s HQ can be used to tap all of its members.

“Most of the phone taps are done in a terrible hurry, and the thing is to know the boys in British Telecom and say: ‘Look, we need this done, Can you help?'”

There is concern also over the choice of targets. One security source told us that all the area officers of the National Union of Mineworkers have been tapped during the current dispute, and a GCHQ expert is reported to have visited Sheffield, where the NUM has its headquarters, in the early stages of the dispute.

The main function of Chantrey House is believed to be the central one of recording the material from all the taps and bugs on voice-activated tape recorders and passing the tapes to the ‘clients’ – MI5, the Police and Customs and Excise.

The operation, known as Tinkerbell, used to be based in Ebury Bridge Road, Chelsea. After its location was disclosed by the New Statesman in February 1980 it was moved to Chantrey House where it has been kept a closely-guarded secret.

A plaque outside describes the building as the training centre for British Telecom’s London region. In fact, this is the function of only the first three floors, which are cut off from the upper floors where Tinkerbell Two is housed.

At the side of the building, padlocked wrought-iron gates are drawn across a driveway where blue and green MI5 vans enter the building to pick up tapes.