Government silences GCHQ whistleblower

The Observer, 5 August 1984

The government has succeeded in suppressing publication of a book by a former GCHQ employee alleging widespread corruption, incompetence and lax security in the top secret eavesdropping network.

The book, by Mr Jock Kane, a radio officer at GCHQ from 1946 to 1973, was to be published last June, but last March it was seized by Special Branch officials, and Mr Kane was prevented by a High Court injunction from pressing ahead with publication.

Mr Kane, aged 60, keen to fight the injunction, recruited the National Council for Civil Liberties to represent him. The Government replied by sending the Special Branch, who interviewed him for seven hours.

They threatened to prosecute him under the Official Secrets. Act and stalled in the courts until Mr Kane’s legal aid was withdrawn. That was a crippling blow which has left him without funds and unable to pay for a hearing to challenge the injunction against him.

Attempts to raise the necessary £10,000 have failed so far, and last week Mr Kane admitted defeat: “There is no way I can afford to pay for all this legal work,” he said. “My hands are tied now.”

Mr Larry Gostin, the NCCL’s general secretary, described the situation as “a monstrous injustice.”

He said: “This is the first time the Government has tried to put a total ban on a book on grounds of national security. They got the injunction without Jock Kane putting his case and now it looks as though he never.”

The Government says it has obtained the injunction against the book because it threatens current intelligence operations, and because Mr Kane has signed undertakings under the Official Secrets Act not to disclose anything from his career in GCHQ.

Mr Kane and the NCCL insist that the book does not threaten national security in any way and that it is devoted to old operations which have already been publicly disclosed. They say the Government’s real motive is to avoid the politically embarrassing consequences of Mr Kane’s story.

The terms of the High Court injunction make it illegal to reproduce passages from the book, and they prevent Mr Kane and his lawyers from describing them, but Observer inquiries have established from other sources the content of the passages to which the Government objects.