Oxford philosopher Sir Stuart Hampshire was allowed to conduct an official in-depth review of the GCHQ eavesdropping network at Cheltenham even though the Security Service, MI5, was simultaneously investigating an allegation that he was a Russian spy.
Although Sir Stuart was eventually completely cleared, the incident – in 1965 – is regarded in the intelligence community as one of their most embarrassing security gaffes. It has been deliberately concealed: British intelligence officers were explicitly ordered not to mention it to American intelligence who discovered the truth only last month. Downing Street was also kept in the dark.
Its disclosure comes at a particularly delicate moment for the Government – on the eve of the appeal hearing on the attempt to ban trade unions at GCHQ – and is likely to lead to accusations of double standards.
The Government has already been under pressure after allegations on Granada TV’s World in Action that more than 40 people – most of them in Whitehall – were investigated as possible Soviet agents in the 1960s.
Sir Stuart’s appointment to conduct the review was apparently arranged with minimum attention to security. The first Wilson government was worried about the cost of GCHQ, then running at about £100 million a year.
The then Cabinet Secretary, Lord Trend, wanted a suitable ‘outsider’ to see whether GCHQ was giving value for money and after consulting the head of MI6, Sir Dick White, he chose Sir Stuart.
According to British intelligence, Sir Stuart was not positively vetted. His wartime work in the Radio Security Service, which monitored the radio links of Nazi spies, was seen as an ideal qualification, and his long-standing friendship with senior intelligence figures was considered ample proof of his loyalty.
He was duly invited to spend nine months in GCHQ with unrestricted access to its secrets and a further six weeks in its US counterpart, the National Security Agency, NSA, a fact which was later to cause particular embarrassment.
NSA’s former depty head, Dr Lewis Tordella, told The Observer last week: “No attempt was made by us to vet him. It was not needed. If GCHQ send someone to NSA, NSA accept his bona fides.”
At the time of his appointment, Sir Stuart’s file in the MI5 registry contained two items which should have led to vigorous inquiry if the vetting procedure had been activated.
He was recorded as a friend of Guy Burgess with whom he had worked in the private office of Hector McNeil when McNeil was Under Secretary at the Foreign Office in 1945.
Hampshire was also recorded as an alleged Russian spy on the word of Goronwy Rees, a member of the Blunt/Burgess circle and himself under suspicion.
The two items might have lain dormant in the file had it not been for the immunity deal struck by MI5 with Anthony Blunt in April 1964. In the course of subsequent interviews, Blunt mentioned Goronwy Rees and said that he had always feared that Rees would expose him as a spy.
Rees was re-interviewed and told MI5 that he had already told them everything he knew after the defection of Burgess and Maclean in 1951. He said be had named five suspects at that time : Guy Burgess, Anthony Blunt, Guy Liddell, Robert Zaehner (all now dead), and Stuart Hampshire.
In the autumn of 1964, MI5 set about examining Rees’s list. They knew already that Burgess and Blunt were guilty and that Liddell – a former deputy head of MI5 – was probably guilty of nothing worse than naivety. They concentrated first on Robert Zaehner, who had worked in intelligence in the Middle East and had become Professor of Eastern Religions at Oxford.
After a lengthy inquiry, they decided that Zaehner was completely innocent, a victim of Goronwy Rees’s unreliable imagination. It was the summer of 1965 before they began to look at the allegation against Sir Stuart and by that time he was already inside GCHQ.
“It was one hell of a sensitive matter,” according to one source. “The attitude was that this was the last thing we wanted. If he had turned out to be a spy, the consequences for everybody could have been absolutely disastrous. It would have have wrecked Anglo-American co-operation on intelligence.”
While Sir Stuart continued his review, the officers challenged Blunt about him. Blunt told them that Sir Stuart had been a friend and that he was innocent. He recalled that he had taken him to a dinner in Paris hosted by James Kingman, the Russian spy, to vet him as a possible recruit for the British Communist Party.
Blunt insisted that this was in 1934, before he had started talent-spotting for the KGB. MI5 checked with another of the dinner guests and concluded that the dinner was in I938 – a time when Blunt was, on his own admission, busily recruiting spies.
Sir Stuart completed his review of GCHQ in 1966. “His report was brilliant,” according to one senior intelligence figure, “a great analytical performance.”
It advised a number of economy measures including British withdrawal from an extremely costly new programme of American satellites and the scrapping of a scheme for British spy planes to fly over the United Kingdom in search of hostile radio activity.
The counter-espionage officers pressed on with their attempts to open an inquiry and in March 1969 they were authorised to interview Sir Stuart. He recalled the Klugman dinner in Paris and also volunteered the information that in 1938 in London, Guy Burgess had made what seemed, in retrospect, to have been an attempt to recruit him.
The inquiry continued. The MI5 officers were told that during a lunch party at Sir Isaiah Berlin’s home in Oxford just after Burgess’s defection, when guests were speculating about where Burgess had gone, Sir Stuart told them: “Guy’s gone to Moscow.”
In 1970, Sir Stuart was interviewed again,and asked to explain why he had never reported Burgess’s approach either when he was working in the Foreign Office with him in 1945 or after the defection in 1951 when MI5’s leaders – some of whom were close friends of Sir Stuart – had been desperately searching for the truth about Burgess.
Sir Stuart said that at the time he had not seen the recruitment approach for what it was and had never thought of the Paris dinner with, Klugman as its precursor.
In 1971, when MI5 drew up a summary list of active cases, Sir Stuart’s name was at first included. The director-general, Sir Martin Furnival-Jones, ordered a review of the case and, on the advice of the service’s legal department, Sir Stuart was entirely exonerated and his name scratched from the list.
That decision did not end the worries of MI5, whose leaders realised that the Americans would not understand why they had never been told of the inquiry into Sir Stuart, even though its result had been negative. A complete blackout was imposed on the incident and when officers attended a top-level meeting of Western intelligence agencies, codenamed Cazab, they were reminded to avoid at all costs making any mention of it.
In Oxford last week, where he has just retired as Warden of Wadham College, Sir Stuart told The Observer that GCHQ had been very security-conscious during his review: “The security precautions were formidable. I really don’t know whether I was positively vetted. I assume they wrote to my friends and asked if I was OK. I can’t remember exactly what was done but I do know that very strict precautions were taken.”
He said he told MI5 everything he knew about Burgess and Blunt during his interviews in 1969 and 1970. “You have to understand that at that time (the 1930s) discussing whether we wanted to work for the Communist cause was quite a common thing for the intelligentsia. Those of us who were logical positivists argued against the Marxists.”
Sir Stuart said that Burgess’s approach to him had been muddled and had amounted to a plea to take a more Marxist line in literary criticism. “He may have said something about working for peace, but I’m pretty sure he didn’t mention the Comintern. I thought it was just Guy going on.
“It was only in retrospect that I thought it might have been something more sinister. At the time, it was impossible to think that Guy might have been a spy: he was always drunk. I also took it that Anthony Blunt could not have been dangerous because he was an overt Marxist. The idea that one might suddenly have gone round to MI5 years later is absurd.”