European court poised to condemn UK phone tapping

The Observer, 29 July 1984

The government faces renewed criticism of its policy on telephone tapping this week when the European Court of Human Rights delivers its judgment in the case of an antiques dealer whose phone was tapped by police.

The court in Strasbourg is expected to condemn British policy as a breach of Article 13 of the European Convention, which guarantees citizens the right to challenge government violations of civil rights; and possibly also of Article 8, which guarantees privacy.

The case, which involves Surrey businessman James Malone, has been working its way through the European courts since July 1979. It has become a focus of criticism about the tapping policy, by which the Home Secretary issues warrants to the police, Customs and Excise, and MI5, without public scrutiny.

In March, the government buckled under pressure from the House of Lords and gave a firm commitment to introduce legislation on tapping in the next session of Parliament. A Home Office spokesman last week said: ‘We are waiting for the Malone judgment so that the court’s observations can be taken into account for the new legislation.’

The Post Office Engineering Union, which has become a joint litigant in the Malone case, has drafted a Private Member’s Bill with the help of the National Council for Civil Liberties. The Bill spells out a possible system for public control of tapping and is intended to focus public attention on the drafting of the government’s own Bill.