Police strategy at Orgreave coking plant – scene of last week’s pitched battle – has settled into something approaching a ritual.
The police occupy the northern end of the road running in front of the plant, sealing the miners off to the south with a cordon at least seven men deep. Behind them are six officers on horseback and the riot-trained Police Support Units with their long shields and visored helmets. To the south-east on the brow of the hill are six more mounted officers.
The miners gather at the south end soon after dawn, dozing until the local milkman makes his daily call, then moving north towards the main gate, playing football, swapping notes about roadblocks, joshing the police by talking to them and punctuating each sentence with crackling noises like a police radio.
Thus far, the atmosphere is relatively light-hearted. But all that changes as soon as the movement of coke lorries is spotted. Pushing and fighting begins. Assistant Chief Constable Tony Clement, who patrols just behind the main cordon calls out “Take prisoners!” and the cordon parts – “like the Red Sea,” said one miner – to let through the more lightly armed PSUs with their round, perspex shields and their truncheons.
If there is a heavy build-up of miners, the cordon parts again to let the horses through. Sometimes mounted police also swing down in a pincer movement from the brow of the hill. Their arrival is usually enough to scatter the crowd.
It is sights like this – the charges and counter-charges, the deadly fusillade of bricks, broken glass and other missiles from the picket lines, and the ensuing injuries – that have caused most public outcry.
But perhaps more disturbing in the long term is the growing resentment among the mining community about police tactics in the villages around the pits. It is an unprecedented situation: up to 20,000 officers from all 43 forces in England and Wales travelling across the country to patrol the communities and their pits. There have been nearly 3,500 arrests. The costs so far are estimated at £70 million.
For the police, it is the first time they have been asked to control a major dispute without any clear legal foundation. There are guidelines to the 1982 Employment Act, but no law. The government’s position is that picketing is a matter for the civil courts.
The question now is whether the police, facing the problem of mass pickets, are not only making their own law but breaking the normal rules that govern their own conduct. It was a point made forcibly by an officer who stopped a miner and a local union official as they were leaving the mass picket at Orgreave last week. When the miner demanded to know what law gave the officer the right to stop him going home, the officer pointed at his blue uniform and said: “This law.”
Mr Peter Wright, Chief Constable of South Yorkshire, would not go that far but he did admit to us last week that some tactics were “a matter of practice, not law.”
One of the most common complaints from miners is that they have been photographed against their will after arrest – hitherto a rare practice by police. Mr Wright confirmed that the photographs are standard policy on the picket lines and that some miners have objected. Was there a law entitling police to photograph forcibly? “There is the law of bringing people to court,” he replied. “We have a problem of identification.” But was there a specific law? “Not that I can think of,” he said.
Another basic police tactic has been to allow only six pickets at each site. Miners and their lawyers complain that the criminal law recognises the right to picket peacefully and imposes no such restrictions. They point out that at most pits there has been no violence at all, yet when they argue with police about the limit of numbers they are arrested for obstruction or breaching the peace.
Mr Wright agreed that the limit was imposed by his officers. “It’s not a matter of law,’ he said. “It’s a practice.” He cited the guidelines to the 1982 Employment Act which suggest a limit of six pickets but agreed that this was a matter of civil, not criminal law. “Six is a nice round number,” he said.
Some 3,000 miners who have been arrested during the dispute have been released by magistrates on condition that they stay away from property belonging to the National Coal Board and electricity and steel plants, and that they take no further part in the strike. The result has been that, if these men continue to picket, they are liable to imprisonment for breaching their bail conditions even though they have not been convicted of a criminal offence.
NUM lawyers intend to challenge the basis of this in the High Court, citing, in particular, the House of Commons debate on the introduction of bail conditions in 1967, during which the Under-Secretary of State at the Home Office made it clear that “there should be no question of imposing special conditions as a matter of course.”
The use of road blocks has already been challenged by the Kent miners in a hearing which did not settle the central issue of the legality of the police action. The Yorkshire NUM hopes to bring a new action.
The administrative side of the operation is also a matter of dispute, particularly the use of the National Reporting Centre at Scotland Yard which was activated on 17 March to liaise between forces and is seen by some critics as a considerable step towards a national police force.
What is undeniable is that behind these charges there is a steady deterioration in relations between the police and the mining communities. At a packed meeting in Eckington, in north-east Derbyshire, on Friday night, witness after witness stood up to recount stories of alleged police brutality and harassment.
Those cases will have to be tested in court, but their effect on the audience was to turn the meeting into an angry protest. “Are we to walk around with our heads down like mice?” one man shouted. “Or can we walk out on Friday evenings like proud men, like we are?”
Outside later, two constables were patrolling the town. One said: “You should come round here with us one night and see how many people we say goodnight to, and they just walk by with their heads down.”