Witness to police shooting contradicts official story

The Observer, 17 June 1984

The internal Scotland Yard inquiry into the police shooting of two unarmed men at a north London post office last week is faced with a clash of evidence between the police and the only independent witness.

Two Flying Squad sergeants shot and seriously injured two men during the shooting on Thursday morning. It is the first time a Metropolitan police officer has fired a gun at a suspect since the mistaken shooting of Stephen Waldorf, 17 months ago in January 1983.

One of the men, Danny Carey, aged 25, is reported to be paralysed from the waist down; the other, Alf Ficken, 42, is ‘satisfactory’. According to Scotland Yard sources, the shooting happened after a violent hand-to-hand struggle in a back room behind the post office, during which one man shouted ‘Kill the — — ‘ to his friend, who then reached into a bag. Believing that the man was going to pull out a gun, the sources say, both officers drew their own weapons and fired a total of three shots, wounding both men.

The only other person on the scene was Mrs Marjorie Simmons, a clerical officer at the post office. She says that as soon as she and the two officers saw the intruders, she turned and ran from the room. Her account differs from the police version in two important respects.

Mrs Simmons says she heard the first shot before she had got out of the room, which appears to conflict with the officers’ description of a violent hand-to-hand struggle prior to the first shot. She also says she does not remember anybody shouting a threat to kill. ‘I never heard anything being said,’ she told The Observer.

In one important detail, Mrs Simmons and the police appear to agree: in the heat of the moment, the officers were unable to comply with Home Office guidelines according to which they should clearly shout ‘armed police’ before firing. The Police Federation has complained that the guidelines are unrealistic.

The internal Scotland Yard inquiry into the shooting is being led by the Deputy Commissioner, Albert Laugharne, who is expected to send a report to the Director of Public Prosecutions. The law for police officers using firearms is the same as for any other citizen: under the 1967 Criminal Law Act, the officers must show that their action amounted to the use of ‘reasonable force in the circumstances.’

In the last ten years, London police have fired only 70 shots in operations, injuring eight people. Only in the case of Stephen Waldorf did the DPP decide that it should be left to a jury to determine whether the force used was reasonable. Mr Waldorf was later paid £120,000 compensation in an out-of-court settlement.