Bettaney lawyers plan to challenge jury vetting

The Guardian, 18 April 1984

Lawyers acting for the gaoled MI5 officer Michael Bettaney are considering taking an appeal to the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg to challenge the practice of jury vetting in British courts.

The vetting in Bettaney’s Old Bailey trial was one of a series of special arrangements made on the instructions of the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Lane, to protect national security.

The chairman and vice-chairman of the Bar Council, Mr Michael Wright, QC, and Mr David Calcutt, QC, met Lord Lane on the eve of Bettaney’s trial last week to express their anxiety.

There was particular concern at the fact that neither the defence lawyers nor the prosecution team, led by the Attorney-General, Sir Michael Havers, were allowed to see the most sensitive documents which Bettaney had stored in his home to pass to the KGB.

When the trial opened last Tuesday Lord Lane agreed that if the documents were so sensitive that they could be shown to the jury only in summary form they should be withdrawn from the case. However, there is still concern over the vetting of the jury and the decision to hold virtually all of the five-day trial in camera.

The jury panel were vetted by MI5 and local Special Branch officers in the area of jurors’ homes. There is a dispute between the defence and the prosecution as to whether the vetting involved the exclusion of jurors on the grounds of their political beliefs.

Sarah Burton, one of Bettaney’s lawyers, said yesterday: “We believe that jury vetting is unconstitutional and we are considering going to the European Court to test the point.”

The decision to hold the trial in camera was attacked yesterday by Stuart Bell, the Labour MP to whom Bettaney wrote to complain about the arrangements for his trial. Mr Bell has written to the Attorney-General demanding an ”absolute assurance” that a trial will never again be held in such secrecy.

Mr Bell says in his letter: “There must be some concern that a man has been sentenced to 23 years’ imprisonment after a trial held in secret except for part of the prosecution’s opening remarks and the verdict. There must be concern, too, that the defence were not allowed to put some part of their case in public, and that the country will never know what defence Bettaney ran.”

Other MPs attacked MI5 for recruiting Bettaney and complained that his university links with right-wing groups and his more recent conviction for being drunk and disorderly should have debarred him. Mr Ted Leadbitter, the Labour MP for Hartlepool, and Mr Anthony Beaumont-Dark, Conservative MP for Birmingham Selly Oak, both said that the Prime Minister should hold an inquiry. Mr Alan Beith, the Liberal chief whip, said the case revealed horrifying incompetence in M15 and called for a Commons debate after the Easter recess.