Bettaney trial followed a string of MI5 errors

The Guardian, 17 April 1984

Michael Bettaney has provoked a crisis in the Security Service: morale is low; there are serious questions about the organisation’s future; and it seems likely that the director general, who is 61, older than the usual Civil Service retirement age, will soon step down.

The greatest irony of the crisis is that it has been provoked not so much by Mr Bettaney’s disloyalty – which was certainly a blow – as by the unprecedented decision to prosecute him through the courts. To that extent, the crisis has been provoked by the Prime Minster’s determination to ensure that traditional justice would be done.

Mrs Thatcher arrived in Downing Street five years ago with virtually no knowledge or understanding of the intelligence community and proceeded to suffer a series of unpleasant and embarrassing security scandals.

In the autumn of 1979, Anthony Blunt was dragged into the open by the author Andrew Boyle with some outspoken help from Private Eye. The Prime Minister was caught off balance, particularly by his immunity from prosecution. She demanded a full explanation from the then director general, Sir Howard Smith, and then ignored his advice by giving the Commons a far more detailed statement than he wanted.

She reassured the House that she was satisfied with MI5 and its reporting and that there were no more ‘immunities’ to be revealed. A year later, the author Nigel West exposed Leo Long, who had been caught spying and offered an inducement to confess so that he could not be prosecuted. Worse was to follow.

A senior officer in MI5, who had been involved in some of its most sensitive operations, believed he was being cheated out of his pension rights and left the service after a furious row. Soon afterwards, he leaked the story of the suspicion that the former director general, Sir Roger Hollis, had been a KGB agent. The Prime Minister was caught off balance again – apparently not alerted to the unhappy officer’s anger let alone to the nature of his reaction.

Finally, in April 1982, Geoffrey Prime was charged with spying at GCHQ – caught, not by MI5, but by regular CID in Hereford. With the Americans banging the table in the background, the Prime Minister called in MI5’s director general, Sir John Jones, and insisted that new guidelines should be introduced under which he would be bound to report to Downing Street any breach or possible breach of security.

The new guidelines affected one of the most basic tenets of MI5’s existence – that it preserves its political independence and guards its security by telling Downing Street only what it needs to know. The new guidelines widened the ‘need-to-know’ area to protect the Prime Minister from political attacks. Sir John believed he should accept them.

When Mr Bettaney was arrested last September, he became the first significant subject of the new guidelines. Sir John went to Downing Street to report and found the Prime Minister in uncompromising mood: there were to be no immunities, no inducements to confess, no back-door solutions, and so Mr Bettaney became the first MI5 officer to be put in the dock on a spying charge.

It was a demoralising moment for MI5: first, they had nurtured a traitor; and now they had lost the power to decide how he should be dealt with. And in public, too. Service morale was to sink lower as the full implications of the Prime Minister’s decision became clear. In spite of their best efforts to control them, MI5 found that the courts and the prison system were hostile environments for such a secretive agency.

In the courts, MI5 tried desperately to screw down the lid. The defence lawyers were forbidden the sight of crucial documents, including some of those which Mr Bettaney was alleged to have collected, and so they were unable to challenge the Crown’s view of their importance. They were not to be allowed to cross-examine Crown expert witnesses if this involved straying into areas of national security. They would not be allowed to call their own expert witnesses. Prospective jurors would be vetted by MI5 and Special Branch. The hearing would be in camera apart from the beginning of the Crown’s opening. Even the pre-trial hearing was in camera.

The lawyers complained, but the Lord Chief Justice, who was handling the case, would have none of it: Mr Bettaney knew too much and the Prime Minister’s decision had effectively placed such a unique strain on the trial procedure that the rules had collapsed under it.

However, precisely as a result of all these special restrictions, in his cell in Brixton Prison, Mr Bettaney began to react. He debated whether he should refuse to recognise the court and then chose instead to go public about the restrictions on his defence by writing to a Labour MP, Mr Stuart Bell – a unique letter which marked the only known occasion on which an MI5 officer has sat down and given a clear contemporary account of MI5 at work.

In one crucial passage, he explained the service’s approach to checking the background of potential jurors and so gave a unique insight into the breadth of MI5’s target area. “These checks are supplemented by in-depth discreet inquiries by the Special Branch amongst a person’s colleagues, workmates, neighbours and friends, with the aim of compiling a dossier on the person’s political and social attitudes, his standing in the community, and so forth.”

The Security Service’s horror did not end with its perception of the security risks involved in the legal process. The prison system was another nightrnare. In Brixton, Mr Bettaney was held with Mr Tommy Quigley, accused of IRA bombings.

Now convicted, Mr Bettaney must be held in the ‘dispersal system’ of seven top-security prisons designed to contain prisoners whose escape would be a danger to society. The system contains 63 people convicted of IRA bombings and some dozen Middle Eastern terrorists, all of whom would be interested to tell their organisations about MI5’s tactics for dealing with them.

Mr Bettaney is, in a sense, more dangerous now that the Prime Minister has pushed him into the courts and the prisons than ever he was when he was trying to pass material to the Russians.