Michael Bettaney, the MI5 officer who tried to spy for the Russians, last night began a 23-year gaol sentence by denouncing the Government as traitors while his lawyers attacked the unprecedented conduct of his trial at the Old Bailey.
Mr Bettaney, aged 34, was convicted on 10 espionage charges. He is understood to have offered the KGB in London a detailed account of MI5’s operation against the Soviet Union, including the names of some of its officers.
During his five-day trial, which was conducted almost entirely in camera, the Crown described how he used his position in MI5’s K Branch, which deals with counter-espionage, to collect highly secret information and to identify a suitable Soviet official to whom to pass it.
He chose Arkady Gouk, who is understood to be a general in the KGB and the head of its British operation, although his official role is as the Soviet Embassy’s security officer, responsible, among other things, for liaising with Scotland Yard. Mr Gouk is still in London, in spite of the disclosure of his name at the Old Bailey.
Mr Bettaney was arrested last September after delivering three letters to Mr Gouk’s home containing ‘sample secrets’ and elaborate directions for dead letter boxes and secret signals. It is understood that he was caught because of a breach in security on the Russian side, which occurred before he could hand over the mass of sensitive material he had gathered in his home in Coulsden, Surrey.
In a statement issued through his lawyers after yesterday’s verdict, Mr Bettaney said that he was not a traitor and was concerned with the rights of the British people. “Their supreme right is to enjoy the full fruits of their toil in peace. This right is indeed being betrayed at home and abroad, openly and in secret, by the government elected to serve the people.”
He accused MI5 of abusing its charter and twisting the definition of subversion in order to investigate legitimate political organisations and trade unions. He also attacked British foreign policy, and “its slavish adherence to the aggressive and maverick policy of the Reagan administration.” The secret services reflected the real goals of British policy, he said.
“By subversive actions and other more sinister and immoral methods which have no place in the conduct of inter-state relations, these special services aim not merely to remove the Soviet Government and Party, but also to destroy the entire fabric of society in the USSR and in other socialist countries.”
He ended his statement by saying that his sentence was out of all proportion to the damage he had allegedly done. “As my last political act, I call on comrades everywhere to renew their determination and redouble their efforts in pursuit of a victory which is historically inevitable.”
The Security Commission, which monitors the performance of the intelligence services, is likely to be asked to examine the case to see whether there were any clues to Mr Bettaney’s development from a working-class, conservative Catholic to a committed Marxist during his nine years in MI5.
The commission may also examine the arrangements for his trial, which were attacked yesterday by his solicitors, Larry Grant and Sarah Burton, and his barristers, Mike Mansfield and Helena Kennedy
In a statement they said that there were areas of public concern in the trial: the vetting of the jury; the decision to hold the trial almost entirely in camera; the leaking of secret and partially inaccurate details of the case to some journalists; and the influence of MI5 on the trial itself: “One is left wondering whether the security service had the ultimate conduct of the case rather than the Attorney-General or the Director of Public Prosecutions.”
The Lord Chief Justice’s ruling that sensitive documents could not be shown to any of the participants in the trial, and that Crown witnesses could not be cross-examined if it meant straying into areas of national security, has been the subject of a complaint to the Bar Council.
It took five hours yesterday for the jury of nine men and three women to convict Mr Bettaney on all 10 charges which he faced under the Official Secrets Act. His counsel, Mr Mansfield, told the court in mitigation that Mr Bettaney had been motivated not by power or money, but by a deep concern about the dangers of nuclear war and the use of unemployment as a political tool.
Asked if he wished to address the court, Mr Bettaney, who stood between two prison officers in the dock, replied: “I have nothing to say.” The Lord Chief Justice, Lord Lane, told him that he understood what was said in mitigation.
“But it was after careful consideration that you made treachery your chosen course of action. It was small thanks to you that the Russians rebuffed your advances, and it was small thanks to you that you were detected before you had succeeded in carrying out your main purpose.”
Lord Lane told him he was puerile, self-opinionated and dangerous: “You would not have hesitated to disclose names to the Russians which almost certainly would have led to the death of more than one person. You would have given every possible help to the Russians to the detriment of this country. You know you have got to be punished, and punished severely.”
Lord Lane sentenced him to 11 years concurrent on five charges, a further 11 years on four more charges, and a further one year on the tenth charge, totalling 23 years. The longest spying sentences were imposed on George Blake, gaoled for 42 years in 1962; and Geoffrey Prime, gaoled for 35 years in 1982.
Last night, the Home Office said that Mr Bettaney would be a Category A prisoner, whose escape is deemed to be a danger to the public, but he would be held at Coldingley Prison, Surrey, because, although it is not a high security prison, it is necessary to keep Mr Bettaney apart from other Category A inmates many of whom would have a political interest in his secrets.