MP calls for fair trial for Bettaney

The Guardian, 24 March 1984

A Labour MP is seeking urgent assurances from the Attorney General that an MI5 officer facing charges under the Official Secrets Act will receive a fair trial.

Mr Stuart Bell, MP for Middlesbrough and vice-chairman of his party’s home affairs committee, is writing to Sir Michael Havers to express his concern that jury vetting for the trial may be being done on a political basis.

Mr Bell also wants the MI5 man to have the normal freedom to present his defence case in full.

Michael Bettaney, aged 33, on April 10 faces six charges under the Official Secrets Act, including three of spying contrary to Section 1. He is the first member of MI5 ever to appear in court.

A pre-trial review, in camera, has already taken place before the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Lane. Directions were given to prosecuting and defence counsel about the manner in which the trial will be conducted.

It was decided that it would be in a camera, apart from a small part of the opening prosecution speech by Sir Michael and the verdict; that certain conditions would apply to the presentation of evidence for reasons of national security; and that the jury would be vetted.

Mr Bell said last night in a statement: “Even though the entire trial as I understand it is to be held in camera, I want to be sure that Bettaney shall be able to bring before the court those documents that will assist him in his defence; that his defence counsel shall be able fully to examine prosecution witnesses; and that witnesses that Bettaney may wish to call shall be allowed to give evidence.

“It is essential that all the rules of evidence be adhered to. I am seeking an early meeting with the Attorney General to ensure that Bettaney is given a fair trial and that no limitations have been imposed that would prevent this from happening.”

Use of the jury vetting system has aroused controversy in the past, but legal authorities have argued that it is especially necessary in cases involving matters such as national security.

The vetting process is understood to involve in-depth investigation by both MI5 and the Special Branch of the political affiliations of potential jurors.