Five women prisoners on hunger strike at Durham Prison

The Guardian, 27 February 1984

Five women in the maximum security wing at Durham Prison were still on hunger strike yesterday in a protest against the unusually austere conditions. The strike started with one inmate 25 days ago.

Their action has revived pressure to close the wing which has been condemned over the years by two government inquiries and by numerous prisoners’ and women’s groups. Senior figures in the home Office Prison Department are known to sympathise privately with the criticism.

The all-party Penal Affairs Group is to discuss the unit at its next meeting. The group’s chairman Robert Kilroy-Silk, Labour MP for Knowley North, said yesterday that he would be writing to the Home Secretary, Leon Brittan to ask for a full statement. “I want to know whether he has any plans to move them to a proper women’s prison,” he said.

The unit was built in 1965 with dog runs, electronic locking devices, closed circuit television surveillance, bullet-proof cubicles for officers and special security procedures The unit was intended to hold particularly dangerous male prisoners.

The effect was to create a regime which was so claustrophobic and mentally oppressive that Lord Mountbatten concluded in his 1966 report on prison security that “no country with a record of civilised behaviour ought to tolerate it.” The 1968 Radzinowicz report said the unit must be regarded as “a temporary and most undesirable expedient.”

The men in the unit rioted, organised hunger strikes and other protests and generated sufficient concern outside to persuade the government in 1971 to close it. The inmates, ranging from London gangsters to multiple child killers, were dispersed to other prisons.

Three years later it was reopened for the women being swept up in police operations against Irish and Arab terrorism. The unit’s critics argue that its conditions have been made even worse.

Security is now tighter than it was when it was used for male prisoners: an extra £10,000 was spent on floodlighting for the main walls and new coils of barbed wire. A special crash barrier was constructed at the main gate. But facilities for prisoners have been dramatically reduced.

Since the rest of the prison is occupied by some 1,000 men, its exercise yard, gym, library, kitchen, hospital, education facilities and leisure areas are closed to the women, who are constantly confined in their unit.

The women exercise in a closed yard overhung with coiled barbed wire and sealed off from the sight of grass or trees. The punishment cell doubles as a hospital.

They have no cooking facilities and are particularly distressed at the need to eat food prepared by men prisoners in the main prison kitchen. They believe it is often fouled by the men and complain that it is invariably cold by the time it reaches their wing.

Unlike long-term inmates of the large men’s prisons, the women in Durham cannot take Open University courses, and other schooling facilities are limited. Their special visiting room is large enough for only three visits at a time and at busy periods, such as Christmas, some visits are cancelled.

The women are locked in their cells from 8 pm until 8 am and spend most of the day making overalls in the prison workshop. One woman said she felt she was “buried alive in a concrete box.”

The underlying irony of the unit is that there are not nearly enough dangerous women to fill it. Only nine women have ever been classified as category A – “whose escape would be highly dangerous”. Four of those have been released; two have been reclassified and transferred; only three remain in the unit.

In order to justify its cost, its remaining cells are filled with some 35 other women prisoners who are not considered dangerous. They seem often to be selected because they are particularly stable and well-behaved.

The woman who started the hunger strike on February 2, Lorraine Greenwood, aged 22, is detained at Her Majesty’s pleasure for murder. She is not category A and wants to be transferred. The Prison Department say she has been ‘cheating’ by eating food from the wing’s canteen. Her friends say this is nonsense, and one woman who visited her recently said yesterday that she was ‘needle thin’.

She was joined on February 16 by Judith Ward, who is serving life for the M62 coach bombing. She is the longest inhabitant of the unit, and has been there for nearly 10 years. Three other women joined on February 20. Some 15 others also refused food for varying lengths of time last week. Their protest is being monitored from outside by a group of ex-prisoners called Women in Prison.

They are pledged to persuading the government to close the unit for good.

 

UPDATE: The hunger strike failed. The wing was finally closed 21 years later, in 2005.