Inside the mind of the kaleidoscopic killer

The Guardian, 5 November 1983

Dennis Andrew Nilsen was born on November 23 1945 in the harbour town of Fraserburgh in north east Scotland. He left school when he was 15, spent 11 years in the army as a cook, and joined the police for a year before becoming a clerk with the Manpower Services Commission, where he has worked since May 20 1974.

Somewhere along that ordinary road, Nilsen became an habitual killer of such extraordinary complexity that the police call him “a freak among freaks,” and one psychiatrist said privately: “We can’t classify him. We don’t have the classifications for such a weirdo.”

What singles him out from other multiple killers is the lack of any clear motive, however bizarre. If he had schizophrenic delusions or a hatred for down-and-outs or for gays, he would start to fit a known picture. But not even Nilsen himself seems to understand his motive. “God only knows what thoughts go through my mind when it is captive within a destructive binge,” he told psychiatrists.

He is like a human kaleidoscope – a collection of images, some normal and some freakish, which have been splintered and jumbled together so that every time he moves they grind and clash against each other and turn out a different picture.

There is the ordinary image of the man at work: Corporal Nilsen, cooking for the Queen’s guard at Balmoral or for the detainees at Al Masousa gaol in Aden; Police Constable Nilsen from Willesden Green, so keen that he tried to make arrests when he was off duty; Mr Nilsen the civil servant, handling paper work at the Jobcentre.

That image immediately clashes with the private picture of ‘Des’ Nilsen, the guilt-ridden homosexual who felt like a pervert and a criminal; who claimed that he was married and divorced while he was trying to live with his boyfriends; and who spent more and more time in Soho pubs, picking up ‘rent boys’.

The clash between the two sides of his character drove him from the army in 1972 when he was rejected by a young soldier; and from the police, where his official ‘digs’ made gay life impossible. It made him depressed and withdrawn, but other images in the kaleidoscope are much more disturbing.

In one, he suffers from loneliness which so engulfs him that he kills people to stop them leaving him and then treats the corpse as a friend. He told police that he sometimes left a dead body in a chair while he went to work, “because it is nice to have someone to come home to.”

Psychiatrists found fragments of the image of loneliness in his childhood: the drunken father, Olaf, who abandoned the family when Dennis was three; the adored grandfather, Andrew, who died when Dennis was six, leaving the little boy wandering the streets, looking for him; his mother’s second marriage, when he was eight, which he resented.

His mother, Betty, who still lives in the council house where Nilsen grew up, remembers him being shy and quiet, keeping pet pigeons in an old air-raid shelter, and being distraught when somebody killed them all one day when he was eight.

He left the army in November 1972 with his first homosexual relationships behind him and without friends. In December he joined the police with warrant number 164305. In April of the next year he joined the Campaign for Homosexual Equality and started evening work in a gay bar in Camden. In December he left the force, friendless again.

He had a fight with his elder brother, Olaf, who suspected that he was gay, and broke off all contact with his family. The final fragments of his loneliness fell into place in August 1977, when his adored flatmate, David Gallichan, whom he called ‘Twinkle’, left him without warning; and then in February 1978, when his successor, Steve Martin, left him for another man.

Soho pubs became his source of company, but the young men he took home and drank with had none of his intelligence and few of his interests. “The vast majority of people came and went and there was no further contact,” he said later. “It was a standard routine, having a sort of social binge and in the morning there was just me with an enormous hangover.”

Psychiatrists suggest that after ten months of this lonely bingeing, culminating with a Christmas spent, as usual, alone and without presents, the pent-up pressure of a lifetime of desertions erupted in the first killing. His victim was a teenager he met in his local, the Cricklewood Arms.

He told police he was afraid that the young man was “just another ship passing in the night”, and the pathetic, bizarre image of a killer moved by loneliness runs through the rest of his attacks.

He denied ever having intercourse with any of his victims, and yet all three survivors of attacks who have heen traced by police speak of some sexual element: Douglas Stewart who declined Nilsen’s invitation to join him in bed; Paul Nobbs, who masturbated with him and was strangled as he slept; Carl Stottor, who slept with him and recovered from an attack after Nilsen had cuddled his unconscious, naked body.

He told police of his decision to kill his seventh victim, a starving young vagrant: “I had drunk a considerable quantity of Bacardi, and the piece of music I was listening to finished – Incantations by Rick Wakeman – and I felt exhilarated. I was on some sort of high.” In this ecstatic state, he had killed the boy.

But the picture which these images provide of a tormented man killing in an alcoholic haze are confused still further by Nilsen’s other faces. There is an arrogant, cruel side to him which kills because people get on his nerves, a grim intolerance which has turned people against him since he was at school.

He gave psychiatrists a terrifying description of his attitude to the people he took back to his flat: “They would sit down. I would talk incessantly like an auctioneer. Outpourings about music, politics, Margaret Thatcher etc. All completely cynical. If they entered into it, they would be OK. If they were sleeping, they would be dead already. It was the ultimate reply to apathy.”

Alongside this arrogance and cruelty was another quite contradictory image, which his mother dwells on: “He was always concerned with poor people and, even when he was a little boy, he used to play with the ones who were very poor. He used to come in from school with birds with broken wings and ask me for a box with some cotton wool.”

This side of him survived to make him a tireless official of the Civil and Public Services Association, one of the activists who organised the picket of Garners steak houses in 1979. And he was often genuinely helpful to young down-and-outs, giving them food and a roof and leaving them quite untouched and unharmed.

In a letter to police he speculated on his motive. “It may be a perverted overkill of my need to help people – victims who I decide to release quickly from the slings and arrows of their outrageous fortune, pain and suffering.”

One final, fractured image has helped to form the picture – the calm, efficient, well-organised automaton who kills his victims and disposes of their rotting bodies with the air of an over-worked civil servant going about his duties.

This was the man who lost track of how many bodies he had stored under his floor-boards and told police “I didn’t do a stock check”; who worried about catching diseases from the corpses and asked: “What can you do? You have got to take the risk. I couldn’t ask anyone else to do it.” It was just a task which had to be completed.

Faced with the nuisance of John Howlett slipping uninvited into his bed and going to sleep, he decided to kill him. Faced with the problem of Malcolm Barlow collapsing from epilepsy and the effects of alcohol in his flat, he decided that it would be troublesome to call an ambulance, and so he killed him to make matters simpler.

When bodies started to rot and smell under the floorboards, he brought them up, dissected them, and wrapped the remains into plastic bags with air fresheners. “The smell was grossly unpleasant, and in some places there were colonies of maggots,” he recalled. But he got on with the job.

None of the images alone explains his behaviour, but each colours and intensifies the other. Together, they slot and click into each other, sometimes producing the harmless ‘Des’ and at other times the irrational killer. The picture is always erratic and unstable. Nilsen took dozens of people back to his flat and never laid a hand on most of them.

He met the epileptic Malcolm Barlow in the street outside his house and got him an ambulance. When Barlow returned a day later, looking for a meal, Nilsen tried to turn him away. But later in the evening, the picture changed – perhaps the drink or the music, or some necrophiliac fantasy, or the irritation of Barlow’s collapse, or all of these things – and he strangled him.

When he killed his last victim, Stephen Sinclair, in February 1983, there was the loneliness that sent him looking for company; the fantasy of sex with him – he admitted masturbating by the corpse; the pity for a homeless young junkie; and the drunken ecstasy: “I can remember power and images, and I know I must have killed him.”

He killed Kenneth Ockenden because he was disillusioned at the prospect of his leaving, angry at his monopolosing his stereo headphones, aroused at the prospect of his body, and very drunk.

John Howlett was a drinking companion whom he had met and left unharmed on previous evenings before the night in March 1982 when the picture changed. Angry and drunk, he strangled and drowned him telling the corpse: “It’s about time you went.”

There was the same erratic mixture of motives in his treatment of the corpses. Often they were a source of pleasure as objects for masturbation and as a means of expressing his cruel arrogance – leaving bags of intestines at a bus stop and in a park where unsuspecting pedestrians would find them.

They also frightened him, and he had trouble persuading himself that he would not be haunted by their ghosts. He brought his clinical efficiency to bear: “The victim is the dirty platter after the feast, and the washing up is a clinically ordinary task,” he wrote in prison.

Even during his trial the kaleidoscope was turning and throwing him into confusion, so that while he insisted for the most part that he was sane and wanted to go to prison, he allowed his lawyers to fight for him to go to a special hospital, which he feared. He expects to be locked up for the rest of his life.

UPDATE: Nilsen’s expectation was correct. Thirty four years later, he was still in prison when he died in May 2018, aged 72.