“Killings had no normal motive” – psychiatrist

The Guardian, 29 October 1983

Dennis Nilsen clung to normality “like a man drowning in nightmares” before succumbing to periods of fantasy when he would kill people as if they were mere objects, a psychiatrist told an Old Bailey jury yesterday.

Dr Patrick Gallwey, the second psychiatrist called by the defence in Nilsen’s trial, said the killings had no normal motive and Nilsen himself seemed wrongly to believe that they had been caused by his heavy drinking.

Dr Gallwey told the jury that Nilsen’s personality had started to crumble when he cut himself off from his family in 1973. “He then had a real, real need for a relationship to hold him together,” he said. The ensuing period of homosexual promiscuity had not provided it. “He felt that hope had dwindled of a proper relationship.”

Nilsen had turned instead to his work for the Manpower Services Commission and for his Civil Service union and also to, a combination of music and strong drink. “He was clinging on like a man drowning in his own nightmares.”

The sudden departure of his flatmate had made matters worse. “The world of his imagination, which turns out to be horrific, captured him more and more,” said Dr Gallwey, so that on occasions his personality broke down completely.

Dr Gallwey told the jury that it was probably in such episodes of breakdown that Nilsen set about the dismembering and disposing of the bodies of his victims. Sometimes during these periods, Nilsen’s behaviour was best described as “craziness.”

Dr Gallwey clashed angrily with Mr Alan Green, prosecuting, and complained to the judge, Mr Justice Croom-Johnson, that he objected to the way in which Mr Green was interpreting some of his evidence.

He told Mr Green that although Nilsen may have known intellectually what he was doing when he killed, he had no emotional recognition of it. “He was behaving like a machine,” he added.

He agreed with the judge that Nilsen could be described as a cold-blooded killer, but said: “He is a cold-blooded killer who is not responsible for his acts.”

Nilsen has admitted to police that he killed 15 or 16 people. At the Old Bailey he has denied six charges of murder and two of attempted murder and pleaded guilty to manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility.

The trial continues on Monday.