Dennis Nilsen is suffering from a severe personality disorder which has no name, but which includes paranoid, schizoid, hysterical and sociopathic tendencies, an Old Bailey jury was told yesterday.
Dr James MacKeith, a forensic psychiatrist called by the defence, told the jury that Nilsen, who has confessed to killing 15 young men, was “consistently inconsistent.” He could appear quite normal for much of the time and yet attack his victims without judgement or self-control.
Nilsen has denied six charges of murder and two of attempted murder. He has pleaded guilty to manslaughter on grounds of diminished responsibility.
The jury was shown a letter which Nilsen had written from Brixton Prison, under the title ‘Mental Condition’. “I have felt, since my teenage days, that I am a creative psycopath,” he wrote, adding that when he was under pressure or drunk, dormant feelings were released. “I can’t look back, only forward,” he added. “I deserve to be punished.”
Dismembering and disposing of the bodies had been risky, he wrote. “In a strange way, I think it became a part of the wish to be caught. I was at a tense breaking point, waiting to be caught so that I could be released from guilt.”
He went on to describe his affection for his last victim, Stephen Sinclair. “I would like to have had a long social and sexual relationship with him.” He said he had washed Mr Sinclair’s body, laid it out, and imagined himself lying next to it on a mortuary slab.
Mr Alan Green, prosecuting, suggested to Dr MacKeith that there were clear signs of self-control in Nilsen’s behaviour: he was intelligent, cunning, quick-witted and resourceful. He had hoodwinked police who were dealing with a report of one of his attempted murders. “I think he hoodwinked himself,” replied Dr MacKelth.
Mr Green said that, even in the moment of the attack, Nilsen was still in control of himself. Strangling the student Paul Nobbs, he had had what he called a change of heart.
A second defence psychiatrist, Dr Patrick Gallwey, agreed that Nilsen was paranoid and schizoid, but added that he believed he also suffered from a disorder which he described as “the false self.”
Dr Gallwey said: “He has an area of his life in which he behaves perfectly normally. Alongside that he is having to keep at bay these disturbances which are part and parcel of a schizoid and paranoid personality. “He is under constant strain between the normal area and the disturbed area. Although they are in equilibrium, it is potentially a very, very unstable one.”
The trial continues today.