A forensic psychiatrist spent two hours at the Old Bailey yesterday explaining why he believes that Dennis Nilsen is suffering from a personality disorder which diminishes his responsibility for his killings.
Dr James MacKeith described Nilsen’s life-long loneliness, his drinking bouts and blackouts, and his obsession with nakedness and unconsciousness which led him to masturbate by the corpses of his victims as “a symbolic goodbye.”
Nilsen was paranoid and unsure of his own identity and desperate for the attention of others, he said. He adopted a grandiose air, the doctor said, which was apparent in his own account of his feelings about his victims before he killed them.
“They would sit down,” he told Dr MacKeith, “and I would talk incessantly like an auctioneer. Outpourings about music, politics, Margaret Thatcher, all completely cynical. If they entered into it, it would be OK. If they were sleeping, they would be dead already, if you like. I would think that they didn’t care about anything and just struggled along from day to day. I was giving them a chance to live.”
Introducing Dr MacKeith’s evidence, Mr Ivan Lawrence QC, counsel for Nilsen, told the jury that they must resist the temptation to think that Nilsen was so vile that it was a waste of time thinking about him.
Nilsen has denied six charges of murder and two of attempted murder. He has pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility, and Mr Lawrence stressed that, whatever the jury’s verdict, Nilsen would be in custody “for a very, very long time”.
Dr MacKeith gave his evidence under nine headings. The first covered Nilsen’s “feeling of aloneness”. He began with his father – “an unreliable person who drank heavily” – who left the family home when his son was three. Nilsen had grown close to his mother’s father, but he died three years later.
“He sought his grandfather out and went looking for him, although at another level, he knew he was dead.” He had resented his mother’s decision to remarry when he was ten and became extremely withdrawn.
He left the army after 11 years in 1972 when he was attracted to a young soldier who did not return his affection.
Dr MacKeith turned to his sexual development and told the court “bizarre stories” which Nilsen had related to him, believing them to be true. Even if they were pure fantasies, they were still important, the doctor said. Both involved being stripped naked, once by a 16-year-old boy and once by a taxi driver, whom he later killed.
Nilsen admitted to him that as a young man he had covered his naked body in powder so that it looked like a corpse and masturbated in front of mirrors. He had also admitted covering his victims’ bodies with powder and looking at them in a mirror.
After leaving the army, Nilsen had embarked on a phase of extremely promiscuous homosexuality. He had been troubled by fantasies of sexually assaulting children and a female relative. Dr MacKeith added in relation to the killings: “Sometimes he felt obliged in the presence of a dead body to masturbate nearby before he could dissect them.”
Nilsen had told him: “It was a symbolic goodbye. It seemed to be an urge. I couldn’t cut them up before I had done it.”
He had started drinking heavily in the army when he was 18 or 19. Memory blackouts followed and, on on occasion, in 1976, he had ‘lost himself’ fof five hours and found himself in a strange part of London. He had been frightened by the experience.
The doctor continued: “He was able to maintain an appearance of normality at work – while at home, since 1978, he was dealing with dreadful problems in relation to the disposal of bodies.”
The same symptom was evident in the fact that those who had survived his attacks commented on his calm, pleasant manner despite his violence and threats of violence.
He said Nilsen spoke of himself as famous, without appreciating that he was notorious. He became grandiose, as when he killed victims who did not listen to his views, and complained that his relatives were being small-minded in refusing to send him photographs of young nephews and nieces.
His “impaired sense of identity” meant thjat he was often like a film director, directing himself as lead actor from a distance. These individual things, along with his lack of remorse and desire not to be considered mad, added up to a severe personality disorder.
The case continues.
** Dennis Nilsen’s efforts to dispose of the 15 young men he has confessed to killing, were described to the court yesterday by Detective Chief Superintendent Geoffrey Chambers, who interviewed him at length.
His first 12 victims were stored under floorboards and then burned periodically at his home in Melrose Avenue.
The body of his first victim, a young Irishman, had lain under the hoards for nine months until he spent one sunny day in August 1979 burning it in the garden “I knew it was a bit risky,” he told police later.
A year passed before his next fire, by which time he had six more bodies to dispose of. Four were dissected and stored in suitcases and carrier bags in a garden shed; one was under the boards; one was in a cupboard under the kitchen sink. “If I had been arrested when I was 65, there might have been thousands of bodies,” he commented to police.
The garden shed attracted a lot of flies and gave off a smell like compost. As summer came, he began to worry that the heat would make matters worse. He built a 5ft pile of wood in wasteland near his garden and early one morning, he dragged the two bodies from the house and concealed them in a hollow in the middle. Then he added the cases and bags from the shed.
Keeping an anxious eye open for neighbours, he worked on until all the remains were on the fire. He threw a car tyre on top to disguise the smell and lit it with lighter fuel.
A year later, In September 1981, he burned five more bodies in the same way before moving to his new flat in Cranley Gardens, where there was nowhere to light a fire and he was forced to use the lavatory to flush away the remains of his victims.
He told police in detail how he put corpses into his bath for dissection and began flushing two-pound pieces of flesh down the lavatory. He had broken up bones and disposed of some of them through the normal refuse collection.
When he was arrested, parts of his last three victims were wrapped in plastic bags or in HMSO Confidential Waste sacks in a tea chest and a wardrobe.