Nilsen’s murders, in his own words to police

The Guardian, 25 October 1983

A bespectacled civil servant from North London sat silently in the dock at the Old Bailey yesterday while a Crown barrister described how he had killed at least 15 people and attempted to kill seven more.

Dennis Andrew Nilsen, aged 37, who worked for the Manpower Services Commission in Kentish Town, confessed to police after his arrest in February that he had committed the killings and disposed of the corpses by carving them up and burning them or flushing them down the lavatory.

Mr Alan Green, prosecuting told the jury that they would have to decide whether Nilsen was guilty of murder, as the Crown alleges; or of manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility, as the defence pleads.

Mr Green opened the Crown’s case by telling the jury of Nilsen’s arrest on February 9 this year. Nilsen and other tenants of the house in Cranley Gardens, Muswell Hill, where he lived, had complained to the agents for their landlord that the drains were blocked. “The defendant himself wrote them an indignant letter on February 8, complaining that the drains were blocked and that there was an unpleasant smell about the house,” said Mr Green.

A plumber from Dyno-Rod bad called on the evening of February 8 and found the drain blocked with flesh. He told all the tenants, including Nilsen, who suggested that someone might have been flushing uneaten Kentucky Fried Chicken down the loo.

The plumber had been worried and had returned the next day with his manager. To their surprise, they found that most but not all of the flesh was now gone. This was because during the night Nilsen had gone down from his top-floor flat to the street, lifted the manhole cover and removed as much flesh as he could fine.

The police were called. They established that that the remaining flesh and bones in the drain were human and then waited for the occupant of the top flat to return from work. At 5.40, Nilsen walked into the house to be confronted by Detective Chief Inspector Peter Jay.

“I have come about your drains,” said Mr Jay.

“Since when have police officers been interested in blocked drains?” asked Nilsen.

“Come upstairs to your flat and I will tell you,” replied the detective.

On the way upstairs, Mr Jay had introduced the two junior officers with him. “Are they health inspectors?” asked Nilsen.

In the flat, Mr Jay cautioned him and told him: “The reason why I’m interested in your drains is that they were blocked with human remains.”

“Oh, good grief, how awful,” said Nilsen.

“Don’t mess about. Where’s the rest of the body?” asked Mr Jay.

“In two plastic bags in the wardrobe next door,” said Nilsen.

They had then set off for the police station. During the journey one of the officers had asked him: “Are we talking about one body or two?”

Nilsen replied: “Sixteen. I will tell you everything.”

Mr Green told the jury that police interviewed Nilsen nine times over the following days and recorded his account of each of the killings.

Nilsen told them that he first killed towards the end of December 1978. His victim was a young man in his late teens with a southern Irish accent, who has never been identified. He explained that a young man who had been sharing his flat had left, and a burglar had broken in while he was away, so he was feeling lonely and miserable.

He told police that he went to a pub and drank a great deal of Guinness. “He talked to a lot of people,” said Mr Green. “But everyone else seemed to be with someone or in a group. Then he got into conversation with a young Irishman.”

The pub shut and the two men went back to the flat which Nilsen then occupied at 195 Melrose Avenue, Cricklewood. “We had a damned good old drink,” Nilsen later told police. “I remember thinking he would probably be going soon – another ship passing in the night. In the morning, he was lying on the bed fully clothed. I was on the other bed. He was dead. I came to the conclusion that I had killed him.”

Asked how he believed he had killed the young man, Nilsen told police that his tie was round the corpse’s neck. “I think I started off with about 15 ties,” he added. “Now I’ve only got one left, and that’s a clip-on.”

He described how he wrapped the body in polythene bags and put it under the floorboards in the flat, where it stayed until he burned it in his garden in August 1979. “That was the end of a sorry period,” he told police.

Four months after the burning, on December 3 1979, he met his second victim, a 23-year-old Canadian called Kenneth Ockenden, who, Mr Green said, was unlike the other victims in that he had money and was not a down-and-out.

Mr Ockenden had been listening to a record through Nilsen’s headphones. “I thought: ‘Bloody good guest.’ I thought he would be here all night. I turned the television up loud. Well after midnight, I remember I was dragging him across the floor with the flex from the headphones round his neck. I was saying ‘Let me listen to the music as well.'” He did not remember killing him.

He put on the headphones and started drinking – “It got me away from what was going on” – and fell asleep with the music playing. Later, he smashed the record, tore up Mr Ockenden’s money and put his fully-clothed body under the floorboards.

He told police that five months later, on May 17 1980, he met his youngest victim, 16-year-old Martin Duffey, a catering student from Birkenhead, took him back to Melrose Avenue and then, as he put it to the police, found him dead on the floor the next morning. “I don’t remember any violence at all. I woke up the next morning and there was Duffey dead on the floor. He had my tie round his neck.” He put him under the boards.

Later the bodies of Mr Ockenden and Mr Duffey had started to smell. So, he told police, he had brought them up from under the floor, dissected them, put the pieces into suitcases and carrier bags and stored them in a shed in the garden. “I monitored the situation. I sometimes sprayed in there once a day.”

Three months later, in August 1980, Billy Sutherland, an itinerant 25-year-old from Edinburgh, met Mr Nilsen in a pub near Piccadilly Circus and went back to his house for a drink. “We had a great binge, and I killed Billy Sutherland. I remember having a tie round his neck and pulling the tie. I don’t recall him struggling but I think he must have.”

The body had been with him in the flat for several days before he put it under the boards. At this point in the interview, police asked him how many bodies he kept under the floor at one time. “I don’t know,” he replied. “I didn’t do a stock check or anything. It was a bit of a jumble.”

His fifth victim, an unidentified man of Mexican appearance in his twenties, died about a month later after following Nilsen out of a pub and starting a conversation.

Soon afterwards his sixth victim, an unidentified man with an Irish accent, was under the boards. “I put him under straight away, before rigor mortis set in. Then I dismembered him in the kitchen and put the remains in a suitcase in the garden shed.”

The seventh victim, Mr Green said, “was perhaps the most pathetic.” In Mr Nilsen’s words, he was “an emaciated young man – pale, hollow cheeks, withdrawn, grossly undernourished and wearing a long ragged trench coat and ridiculously large trousers. He had a carrier bag with bits and pieces in it. He was a vagrant type.”

His eighth victim a hippy in his twenties – had followed soon after the bonfire, and then had come the ninth, whose body he had dissected.

His tenth victim died early in 1981. Nilsen said he found the body in the morning and put him under the floor boards. “That was that: floor boards back, carpet replaced and off to work.”

His eleventh victim was a skinhead, who boasted of his toughness and agreed to Nilsen’s suggestion that they should have a competition to see who could drink the most whisky. “Eventually, he flaked out in the armchair where he was sitting, and I remember thinking he wasn’t very hard. I removed my tie and put it round his neck and strangled him. I went off to bed: the end of the day, the end of the drinking, the end of a person.”

He found his twelfth victim, Malcolm Barlow, aged 23, sitting on a wall in Melrose Avenue one morning in September 1981, recovering from an epileptic fit. Nilsen told police how he took the young man to his house and called an ambulance which took him to hospital. The next day, he returned from work to find Mr Barlow waiting for him on his doorstep.

He agreed reluctantly to give him a drink. Possibly because of the pills he had been taking in hospital, Mr Barlow slumped into unconsciousness. “At that moment, I had a problem and I dealt with it. I didn’t want to deal with an ambulanceman asking silly questions like ‘Why did you let him have a drink ?'” He told police that he strangled Barlow with his hands.

That autumn, he was given £1,000 by his landlord to leave his flat in Melrose Avenue, which was to be renovated. Before leaving, he burned the five bodies he had been storing, throwing rubber tyres on the fire to disguise the smell.

Two months later, in November 1981, he tried to kill a London University student, Paul Nobbs, after having sex with him. In March of the next year, he killed a man called John Howlett. His death, said Mr Green, was the most chilling of all.

After the two men had been drinking together in the flat, Mr Howlett had got into Nilsen’s bed and fallen asleep. “I didn’t feel like getting into the bed with him in it,” said Nilsen, so he went back into the sitting room and pulled a leather upholstery strap from one of the chairs.

In the bedroom, he strangled Mr Howlett, then found he was still breathing; strangled him again without success; and again only to find that his heart was still beating. In desperation, he dragged the unconscious man into his bathroom, filled the bath with cold water and held his head under water for four or five minutes until he was dead

In September 1982, he met Graham Allan, aged 28, from Glasgow, in Shaftesbury Avenue, took him home and gave him an omelette. During the meal, Mr Allan had slumped forward unconscious from fatigue and drink.

Nilsen said he killed him. “I remember going forward, and he was dead. I don’t know whether the omelette killed him, but in going forward I intended to kill him and an omelette doesn’t leave red marks on a neck.”

His final victim, Stephen Sinclair, aged 20, was described as a heavy drinker who took drugs and lived in squats. In Nilsen’s flat, he ate and drank while Nilsen listened to the rock opera Tommy on the stereo.

“I had listened to the whole of Tommy. God knows what time it was. I can’t re-member anything else until I woke up the next day. He was still in the armchair and dead. On the floor was a piece of string with a tie attached to it. I cannot re-member what happened. All I can remember is the music and the images, the pressure and the lights. Music and images always move me to tears.”

The trial continues today.

** Douglas Stewart aged 29, told the court how he had called police in November 1980 and complained to them that Dennis Nilsen had tried to kill him in his flat in Melrose Avenue. At this stage, the court has heard, only eight of Nilsen’s fifteen victims had died.

Mr Stewart said he had an invitation to the flat after closing time. During the night, something had told him to wake up: “He (Nilsen) was leaning over me with his knee on my chest and he had my tie round my neck. I tried to fight him off.”

He subsequently managed to escape from the flat and run down the road to a telephone box. Two policemen came in answer to his call and took him back to the flat, where Nilsen told them that they had been having a lover’s quarrel. “That made me very angry,” Mr Stewart told the court.

He arranged for police to contact him the next day at his brother’s house, but they had not done so. Mr Green told the jury that police had tried on several occasions, but the brother had been unable to make contact with Mr Stewart.