Yard agrees to pay Waldorf compensation as row continues

The Guardian, 21 October 1983

Scotland Yard yesterday confirmed that it was prepared to make a substantial payment in an out-of-court settlement with Steven Waldorf, who was wrongly shot and critically injured by the police in January.

Negotiations are being conducted by solicitors acting for Mr Waldorf and the Yard. Mr Waldorf’s solicitor, Mr Arwyn Hopkins, denied reports that a figure of £1 million had been agreed. “We are still talking,” he said.

Detective Constable Peter Finch and Detective Constable John Jardine were cleared of attempting to murder Mr Waldorf and of wounding him with intent. The jury unanimously agreed that they had acted in reasonable self-defence when they attacked Mr Waldorf in the mistaken belief that he was an armed fugitive, David Martin.

The chairman of the Police Federation, Mr Leslie Curtis, last night attacked MPs and newspapers who have called for the two men to be disciplined. The Yard said that an inquiry was being conducted to establish whether they should be charged.

Mr Curtis added that it was not an offence to breach the Yard’s firearms guidelines since these are advisory, not mandatory. In a speech to the Hampshire branch of the federation, Mr Curtis called for a new look at the guidelines.

He said: “If the only rule that applies to an armed police officer is going to be ‘You’re on your own, and God help you if you make a mistake’, then we have a problem. We have to find something more satisfactory than the existing position.”

Mr Curtis said he hoped that the Home Office would consult the federation in drawing up new guidelines. The Home Office said it would make no decision to consult anyone before studying the final report from the Metropolitan Commissioner, Sir Kenneth Newman.

In its jockeying for position with the Home Office, the federation is using the ultimate threat that it will advise its members to refuse to carry guns. It said yesterday: “Why should our officers put themselves in the position where they could go to prison for life or lose their jobs?

“We want to talk to the Home Office about new guidelines. It may not be possible to find an exact form of words, and if it’s all going to boil down to the question of whether the officer did the right thing, then we are going to have to tell our people to think very carefully before agreeing to carry a firearm.”

Unconfirmed reports yesterday suggested that some London officers had already torn up the pink cards which they carry to show that they are authorised to carry guns. The Press Association claimed that in one police district, 32 of the 35 authorised officers had torn up their cards.

The Yard replied by saying that it had no knowledge of any such district and released figures which purported to show that there was no drop in the number of authorised officers. The figures showed that in January, there were 4,474 authorised officers; 4,667 in March; 4,776 in June; and 4,775 this week.

Asked to explain why the steady rise in the first half of the year had turned into a slight fall, the Yard said: “There is absolutely no trend in the number of authorised shots. It’s neither up nor down at the moment.”