The night that a police fantasy nearly killed an innocent man

The Guardian, 20 October 1983

The simplest and most telling epitaph for the shooting of Steven Waldorf was produced by Detective Constable Peter Finch in the witness box at the Old Bailey on Monday. “I believed I was doing the right thing at the right time,” he said.

On the night of January 14, with Steven Waldorf lying broken and bleeding in the road and the dark shadow of a mighty scandal descending on Scotland Yard, it would have seemed almost insulting for any policeman to claim that there had been anything right about the evening’s events.

But yesterday, an Old Bailey jury agreed that Peter Finch and his co-defendant, John Jardine, had been right to attack their innocent and unarmed target. The key to their decision lies in Mr Finch’s simple statement: it was his beliefs which mattered, more even than the objective truth.

Seen through the eyes of the police, the events in Pembroke Road that night bear almost no relation to reality. Their vision was, on their own account, grossly distorted by an infectious fantasy in which the real persona of Steven Waldorf was shrouded by the phantom of David Martin.

The police were frightened of David Martin: he had shot an unarmed constable in August; and when he was arrested in September he had drawn two guns and then struggled violently even after being shot in the neck. PC Finch in particular had reason to be aware of Martin. He had taken part in the September arrest and had had Martin’s gun pointing at him. He had also taken down a statement from the constable shot by Martin in August.

At their briefing at Paddington Green police station on January 13, Det Supt George Ness had hammered home the message: Martin was dangerous; he was likely to be armed; he would not hesitate to shoot. George Ness was trying to key them up for their own safety. But by the time they found themselves easing their cars through the rush-hour the next evening, discreetly following a suspicious yellow Mini, they were psyched up to the point of breaking.

On the back seat of the Mini, Suzi Stephens, who had been awake for most of the previous night, lay down to snooze. A few yards behind, in his unmarked Marina van, Detective Constable Jardine saw something far more suspicious: “It was my view that Martin could have seen us and said something like ‘Keep down. There’s going to be trouble.'” In fact, at that moment, Martin was miles away, driving down the M4.

Steven Waldorf turned round from the front passenger seat to close his briefcase on the back seat. What DC Jardine saw was a far more threatening sight. “I thought then there was a possibility that there might be guns in the briefcase.”

When Peter Finch set off on foot through the traffic jam a few minutes later to take a closer look at the Mini, he was already starting to live the fantasy: he drew his gun. It was against the rules, but if he was about to come face to face with a man who shot policemen, he was not going to have his gun buried in its holster inside his anorak.

By the side of the Mini, the fantasy took over completely. “I saw a three-quarter profile of Martin. I saw his large nose, his hair and even his high cheek bones. One hundred per cent. I was sure it was him. Absolutely positive.”

Steven Waldorf and the Mini’s driver, Lester Purdey, were talking to each other and turning back to talk to Suzi. Peter Finch thought they were looking at him. “I feared for my life,” he said later. “I thought I was going to be shot.” He crouched down to make a smaller target and raised his gun.

In the fear of the moment, his training started to crumble. There was no loud clear shout of “Armed Police” and no chance offered to surrender. “My voice faltered,” he said. He sent two bullets into the car’s near-side rear tyre. That was against the rules. “It was bad shooting,” he said.

By this time, DC Finch was committed to his blunder. If he had shot at Martin, then Martin would try and shoot back at him. Inside the car, Steven Waldorf heard the bullets hit the tyre. “I turned round, I thought it was a car back firing.”

That extra movement was enough for DC Finch. “I thought he was going for a gun. I thought he was going to shoot me. I thought I was going to be dead.” He fired his four remaining bullets.

A few yards behind, DC Jardine heard the sound of gun fire. Its meaning was obvious to him: “I thought: ‘My God. That’s Martin and he’s got a gun.'” Now each officer’s actions confirmed his colleagues’ belief.

DC John Dean raced to the scene and opened fire. DC Jardine saw him and ran towards the car. Steven Waldorf’s half-conscious body slid out of the driver’s door with his hands clawing at his agonising wounds. DC Jardine saw another meaning in the groping movements.

And so, lying bleeding in the road, the unarmed Steven Waldorf had three more shots aimed at his head. Fortunately, they missed. But he was still moving and to the frightened DC Finch that meant that he was still a threat.

“From my experience of Martin, even though he has been shot he is still a very dangerous man. He was still capable of getting a gun out. I was not going to jump on him. I hit him on the head with my revolver at least three times…”

Moments later, the officers got their first clear look at their victim’s face, and reality was restored. They handed in their guns and went off to be interviewed, and ever since then, they have been trying to explain the most terrifying part of the whole incident – that they really believed that what they had done was right.