The acquittal of the two London detectives charged after the shooting of Steven Waldorf provoked a threat last night of a ‘gun strike’ from the Police Federation and a statement by a senior Scotland Yard officer that there was no guarantee that innocent people would not be shot by police.
Mr Geoffrey Dear, Scotland Yard’s assistant commissioner for training and personnel, said: “I should like to say that there is a guarantee that it will never happen again but I would not be so bold.”
Police would do their best, Mr Dear went on, but there was ‘no ready-made panacea on a shelf’ to take down to prevent another incident like the shooting which led to detective constables John Jardine and Peter Finch being charged with attempted murder and wounding with intent.
They were acquitted on all charges at the Old Bailey yesterday but are still suspended awaiting a Scotland Yard decision on whether they will face disciplinary proceedings.
Federation leaders are talking of advising their 120,000 members in England and Wales to refuse to carry firearms because they are furious that the two detectives were prosecuted. They believe armed officers should have a form of legal protection or indemnity from prosecution.
A senior federation figure told the Guardian: “We are bitterly angry at the way this has been handled. There is absolutely no protection for policemen using firearms and there’s a strong feeling up and down the ranks of ‘Well to hell with it. We don’t have to be armed in the first place so why should we take these risks?’
“If you think there’s someone out there with a gun aimed at you, you have got a choice – shoot or be shot. The frightening thing is that it has been coming for years, and there will undoubtedly be more Waldorfs. Either the Home Secretary gives us some protection in law or we say enough is enough.”
The Old Bailey jury took less than two hours to accept the two detectives’ pleas that they acted in reasonable self-defence when they attacked the unarmed Steven Waldorf in the mistaken belief that he was the armed fugitive, David Martin.
Mr Waldorf’s family is pressing for compensation for the attack last January but accepted yesterday’s verdict. “I don’t feel vindictive,” his mother, Mrs Beryl Waldorf, said. “Steven is being very philosophical about the whole thing, very brave.”
At her home in Barnet, Herts, she said: “We feel pleased for the detectives and their families because they must have been living a nightmare.” She said her son was staying with friends and was talking to a Sunday newspaper reporter. When he gave evidence at the trial, Mr. Waldorf said he was being paid £20,000 by the News of the World.
Mr Dear told a Scotland Yard press conference that the acquittals did not diminish the Yard’s deep regret over the incident. “I am not surprised that Mr Waldorf is suing us,” he said. “If I were in his position I would be doing exactly the same thing.”
He said a decision about disciplinary proceedings against the two officers and against Det Con John Dean, who was also suspended after the shooting, would be taken within a week. Mr Dear went on: “Naturally I am delighted that the two officers have been acquitted but I am very concerned that the general public will see the acquittals as some sort of carte blanche to us to go and do the same sort of thing again. We do not see it in those terms.”
He acknowledged the resentment of some armed officers who want protection against legal action before using guns in future. “A legal indemnity for them is an attractive option, but I would not go down that road. Our police always have and always will operate on the basis that an officer is answerable to the law.”
Det Con John Newman, the chairman of the Police Federation’s London branch, last night called for restrictions on the ownership of firearms. In a speech to his branch in the presence of the Home Secretary, Mr Leon Brittan, and the Metropolitan Commissioner, Sir Kenneth Newman, he said: “As a force and as a federation we do not want to be armed. We have imported enough from America without the addition of gunfight at the Hammersmith Palais or High Noon Sudbury version.”
He said the police should be given the power to make random checks on the homes of gun owners and to seize weapons which were not securely locked away. The federation’s national committee is due to meet on Monday and will discuss the trial and the carrying of firearms.
Det Con Finch and Det Con Jardine were both charged with attempting to murder Mr Waldorf, a film editor, after firing on him as he sat with two friends in a traffic jam in Earls Court, London, on January 14. The jury heard during the six-day trial that they and another officer fired a total of 14 shots into a Mini, hitting Mr Waldorf with five and critically injuring him. As he lay wounded in the road, Det Con Finch struck him over the head with his pistol.
The charge of attempted murder against Det Con Finch was dropped when the judge, Mr Justice Croom-Johnson, ruled that there was no evidence that could be put to a jury.
Det Con Jardine told interviewing officers after the shooting that he had intended to kill the man he was shooting at but he pleaded that he was justified in this. The two men made similar pleas of justification against charges that they wounded Mr Waldorf with intent to cause him grievous bodily harm.