An Old Bailey judge yesterday dismissed the charge of attempted murder against Detective Constable Peter Finch, one of the two officers brought to trial as a result of the shooting of Steven Waldorf in a traffic jam in central London in January.
Detective Constable Finch has admitted opening fire on the unarmed Mr Waldorf in the mistaken belief that he was an armed fugitive, David Martin. He has also admitted that he struck the wounded Mr Waldorf over the head with his pistol.
At at the start of yesterday’s hearing, Mr Justice Croom Johnson told the jury that they need not consider the charge of attempted murder. “I have ruled that there is no evidence which has been put before you, or indeed before anybody else, that Peter Finch attempted to murder Steven Waldorf,” he said.
He also told the jury that, at the request of the prosecution, a further charge against Detective Constable Finch of causing grievous bodily harm had been altered to the lesser charge of wounding with intent to cause grievous bodily harm. Det Con Finch now faces two charges of wounding with intent, both of which he denies. His co-defendant, Detective Constable John Jardine, still faces a charge of attempted murder as well as one charge of wounding with intent. He, too, denies the charges.
Yesterday, both men went into the witness box of Number One Court and said that they believed that they had done nothing wrong. In his evidence, Det Con Finch described his complete conviction that he was facing Mr Martin, whom he knew as a highly dangerous man. He said he was already nervous.
Then he saw sudden movements which convinced him that he was about to be shot at. He had tried to shout a warning but “it didn’t come out very well at all, and my voice faltered.” His first two shots had been aimed at the man he thought was Martin, but they had hit the car tyre. It was bad shooting,” he said.
Mr Waldorf had been hit by five bullets and struck across the head with a pistol before Det Con Finch realised his error. “I looked down and I saw his face, and it was not Martin. I felt absolutely terrible.”
Det Con Jardine said that he had seen Mr Waldorf on the ground, rolling around and making groping movements with his hands. “There was only one explanation,” he told the jury. “From what had gone on before, the man had to have a gun.” He had fired three times at Mr Waldorf’s head to incapacitate him.
Cross-examining, Sir Michael Havers, the Attorney-General, who is leading the prosecution, suggested he should have stepped up to Mr Waldorf and held a gun to his head instead of opening fire from a distance. Det Con Jardine replied: “There are no circumstances under which I would approach a man like that, believing what I did about him, with a gun in my hand. If he didn’t have a gun, I would be giving him one. It’s contrary to all that we are taught in firearm training.”
The trial continues today.