An Old Bailey jury heard yesterday that the two detectives who shot Steven Waldorf told senior officers after the incident that they had been convinced that they were shooting at an armed and dangerous man, David Martin, and that, although they had seen no gun in his hand, they had been in real fear for their lives.
In the days immediately after the shooting on January 14, senior members of Scotland Yard’s Complaints Investigation Bureau interviewed Detective Constable Peter Finch, aged 38, of Crowley Green, Hertfordshire, and Detective Constable John Jardine, aged 37, of Dawlish Drive, Pinner.
Both deny the attempted murder and wounding of Mr Waldorf with intent to cause him grievous bodily harm. Detective Constable Finch also denies causing Mr Waldorf grievous bodily harm.
Detective Chief Superintendent Neil Dickens interviewed Det Con Finch. The bureau’s head, Commander Mike Taylor, declined to interview him because he had known him for 18 years.
Detective Constable Finch began by giving his view of David Martin whom he had arrested on a charge of attempting to murder a policeman the previous September, the jury were told yesterday.
“I think he is a very dangerous man with no regard for the law or for authority,” he said. “At the time of his arrest, he said that he could have taken a number of officers with him…. He said, upon arrest, while I was struggling with him: ‘I will kill you, I will blow you away.'”
Det Con Finch described how on the morning of January 14, he had been keeping watch on the flat of Miss Suzi Stephens, Mr Martin’s girlfriend, from a room across the road. He had followed when Miss Stephens left the flat and picked up a hired yellow Mini in which she drove off with Mr Waldorf and another friend, Mr Lester Purdy.
Driving through the evening rush hour he had volunteered to go forward on foot to see whether David Martin was in the car. “I drew my gun from the holster. I had a large blue anorak on and I knew I might have difficulty in drawing the weapon if I was confronted by Martin. I knew that if the man was Martin, he would shoot me first before I had time to draw my weapon.”
As he stood by the side of the car, he had become convinced that the man in the front passenger seat was Mr Martin and was alarmed when the car driver said something and looked at him. Det Con Finch insisted in his interview that he called out ‘Armed Police’.
Det Con Finch said: “In perfect circumstances, you can call out words to the effect that you are armed police – ‘stay where you are’, but the only words I could say were ‘Armed police’. I would have continued, but circumstances arose where I felt I had to fire.”
He told Mr Dickens: “I thought he was going to reach for a gun, and I feared for my life. As he did so, I fired a pair of shots, and these went into the rear tyre.”
Mr Dickens asked if he had actually seen a gun. “I did not,” he replied. “It was just his sudden movement which I saw.”
Det Con Finch said he had moved forward to the passenger window. “He was shouting something and still moving so I fired two more pairs of shots towards his left arm at close range… Although the street was not that well lit, I was still convinced that he was Martin.”
He had run around the front of the car to find his target slumped out of the driver’s door on the road. “He was lying face down and he was moving. As I was out of ammunition and Det Con Dean was incapable of firing his gun, I used my gun to strike him a number of times to stop him moving. I then stood back and did a reload and stood over him with my gun outstretched.”
Det Con Finch insisted to Mr Dickens that he had not lost control of himself. “I knew what I was doing at all times,” he said.
In his evidence, Det Con John Jardine said that following the yellow Mini through the traffic, he had heard on the radio that Det Con Finch was going to approach the car on foot to make an identification. He had seen him walk by. “I was astonished to see that he had drawn his gun, and Det Con Dean and I commented to each other about that.”
Det Con Jardine said he had lost sight of Det Con Finch and then suddenly had seen him standing by the Mini firing. “I thought: ‘God, that’s Martin. He’s got a gun and he’s firing.'”
Det Con Jardine had jumped straight out of their Marina van and run forward, drawing his revolver: “I could see the man I believed was Martin… He was rolling about, and his hands and arms appeared to be groping along his body… I was convinced that the man had a gun somewhere very close to him, probably under his body.
“He must have had a gun. Otherwise, no shots would have been fired in the first place. I was desperately afraid that he was going to shoot either me or Det Con Finch who at that time was within Martin’s line of fire.” He had fired a total of three shots.
Det Con Jardine said that he had intended to kill Mr Waldorf, because that was the only way to totally incapacitate him. He added: “I would just like to stress that throughout this incident, I acted totally in good faith and reacted in the only way I possibly could in my assessment of the situation.”
The case contines.
** At the beginning of yesterday’s hearing, the trial judge Mr Justice Croom Johnson, warned the jury that they should pay no attention to an attempted reconstruction of the Waldorf shooting broadcast on News at Ten by ITN on Wednesday night. “An irresponsible show like that is very dangerous,” he said, and asked the Attorney General, Sir Michael Havers, to consider whether ITN should be prosecuted for contempt of court. Sir Michael replied: “It has been drawn to my attention and it is already a matter for exploration.”