Senior officer says detective broke firearms rules

The Guardian, 14 October 1983

The senior police officer whose men are accused of attempting to murder Steven Waldorf told the Old Bailey yesterday that his instructions had been disobeyed and that standing orders on the use of firearms had been ignored when Mr Waldorf was shot.

Detective Superintendent George Ness also said that one of the accused men, Detective Constable Peter Finch, had been right to use his gun to strike David Martin when he was arrested several months before the Waldorf incident.

Detective Constable Finch and Detective Constable John Jardine, both aged 38, are charged with the attempted murder of Mr Waldorf and with wounding him with intent to cause grievous bodily harm. They deny the charges.

Yesterday, the jury heard how plain-clothed officers were following a car through central London on the night of January 14, when, according to the transcript of a conversation recorded from police radios, an officer reported: “We may – stress we may – have the wanted man.”

Mr Ness told the court that he had ordered Detective Constable Finch to go on foot to catch up with the car, a yellow Mini, to establish whether the man in it was the wanted David Martin. “It was quite clear in my mind what I had asked him to do,” said Mr Ness.

The Attorney-General, Sir Michael Havers, told him that Detective Constable Finch had drawn his gun as he got out of his car. “Would that be in accordance with standing orders?” asked Sir Michael. “No,” replied Mr Ness.

“He then went to the side of the Mini and put two bullets through its rear tyre,” said Sir Michael. Would that be in accordance with your orders or with good practice? ” “No,” said Mr Ness.

“The jury has heard evidence that no warning shout was heard,” said Sir Michael. “Should he have called out ‘Police’ or ‘Armed Police’? ” “Yes,” replied Mr Ness. “I think he should.”

Mr Ness was pressed to say whether Detective Constable Finch should have fired into the car which he believed was carrying Martin. “I don’t really know. I can’t answer that,” he said. “You can’t make an assessment in cold, calculated terms of what an officer should or should not do in those circumstance. I wasn’t there.”

Later, he was asked what he had expected Det Con Finch to do. “Knowing Peter Finch, I would have expected that he would have got into a position where he could see whether it was Martin without putting himself in jeopardy and then come back and tell me.”

Mr Michael Corkery QC, for Det Con Finch, told the jury that the officer had twice been commended for bravery – once for arresting a man with a knife and once for arresting a man who drove off with the officer hanging out of his car.

Det Con Finch has been accused of ‘pistol whipping’ Mr Waldorf, and Mr Corkery asked Mr Ness to comment on the officer hitting Martin with a pistol when he arrested him. “That would seem to me to be the right thing to do,” said Mr Ness.