GCHQ chief quits after Prime scandal

The Guardian, 28 July 1983

Sir Brian Tovey, director of the Government Communications Headquarters in Cheltenham, is to take early retirement in the autumn in what is believed to be a reaction to pressure in the wake of the Geoffrey Prime scandal.

Sir Brian’s early departure reflects the low morale at the base and, in particular, the widespread resentment at the proposed introduction of lie-detector tests – a measure which has been pressed on British intelligence by the Americans to prevent another Prime case.

The base is of paramount importance to Western intelligence. Staff there translate and analyse messages which are intercepted by a global network of satellites and eavesdropping stations aimed at the military, commercial and social activities of allies and hostile powers alike.

Geoffrey Prime was gaoled for 35 years last November after admitting that he passed information to the Russians as a GCHQ employee from 1968 to 1977.

After Mr Prime’s arrest, Sir Brian told friends that he was prepared to resign if the government wanted a head to roll. This was seen in Whitehall as an honourable offer which did not have to be accepted since Mr Prime had left GCHQ by the time Sir Brian became director in 1978.

It is the aftermath of the scandal – with its disastrous effect on morale and the security pressure from the Americans, who are intimately linked with GCHQ – which is believed to have persuaded Sir Brian to go at the age of 57, three years before normal retirement age.

The official line yesterday was that Sir Brian wanted to make way for the heir apparent, Mr Peter Marychurch, at present head of organisation and establishment at the base. Mr Marychurch is also 57, and it was said that Sir Brian believed that he deserved an opportunity to become the leader.

Opposition by Sir Brian and other senior British intelligence staff to the lie-detector is well known in Whitehall. It was clearly expressed this month by Sir Robert Armstrong, secretary of the Cabinet and head of Civil Service security.

He told leaders of Civil Service unions that the detector was “an innovation which would be impossible to welcome,” and in a reference to Sir Brian and his senior colleagues told union leaders: “There is enough reluctance around the place quite apart from your own.”

The Americans, who sent a team of intelligence specialists to study security at Cheltenham last winter, have also pressed for the introduction of psychological tests.