Prison governors speak out against hanging

The Guardian, 11 July 1983

Prison governors have broken ranks with other law enforcement groups by sending an outspoken open letter to the Home Secretary decrying the use of prisons for executions, threatening resignations if their opposition is not heeded, and calling for a new approach to the detention of dangerous prisoners.

The letter to Mr Leon Brittan reflects intense feeling among the 600 governors and assistant governors in England and Wales. It was written by the chairman of their branch of the Society of Civil and Public Servants, Mr Brendon O’Friel, after a series of meetings around the country.

Mr O’Friel forecasts dire results if hanging is restored: “Staff relationships will deteriorate, prisoner reaction will escalate, and force will become more widely used,” he says. “The effort and energy diverted into organising and managing capital punishment will be lost from the other crises besetting the service. We believe such changes would move the prison service back. towards the Dark Ages.”

The governors know that their action may cause friction with the Prison Officers’ Association, which has vociferously supported restoration of the death penalty. Some governors are critical of the Association of Chief Police Officers which they believe to have stayed quiet to avoid annoying the pro-hanging Police Federation.

The letter reminds Mr Brittan of the emotional effect of hangings on prisons. “The effect of holding a condemned prisoner was felt long before sentence was pronounced as any person committed for trial on a capital offence was immediately identified by both prisoners and staff as special.

“A doomsday clock began to tick from the first committal, on through the trial, the verdict, the appeal and finally to the execution itself. Chiming prison clocks were actually silenced as the execution approached. Considerable precautions were taken to prevent suicide.”

Governors were responsible for visiting the condemned prisoner each day and conveying the results of appeals while organising the execution by testing equipment and posting notices outside the prison gate.

“On the morning of the execution the governor, the chaplain, the medical officer and the chief officer, together with the Under Sheriff and the coroner, entered the execution shed. Prison officers escorted the condemned person on to the gallows and were next to him when he dropped. Other prison staff were responsible for taking down the body and for its burial within the prison walls.

“The execution dominated the life of the prison for a considerable period. The extent of the reaction of the rest of the prisoners depended on their view of the condemned person’s crime: child murderers attracted less sympathy than others.

“Generally tensions grew, verbal and physical aggression became more commonplace, rising to a crescendo the night before the execution.”

Mr O’Friel says that many governors – particularly those who have joined since abolition – believe capital punishment to be incompatible with the aims of the prison service. “We would anticipate some resignations from the service,” he says.

Some governors are known to have already contacted Mr O’Friel to say that they would resign if asked to supervise executions.

The governors believe that the prison population is now more difficult to deal with than in the days before abolition and the danger of demonstrations and hostage-taking is greater.

“We hold some clever agitators at war with our society, who would undoubtedly use executions as a convenient and very potent focus for discontent.”

Relationships between prisoners and staff would fracture so that force was more often necessary; staff might face reprisals; demonstrations outside prisons would be bigger and more active than in the old days of hanging.

The governors bluntly refuse to countenance prisons as places of execution. The letter says: “If capital punishment is to be restored we will want executions to be excluded from prisons. Our strong professional opinion is that it would be quite wrong for the prison service to take up this task. Other locations must be sought.”

They concede privately that, although doctors, the police or the military might he asked to conduct executions, they are unlikely to agree. “We know that very well,” said one governor. “But why should we do it? We find the procedure repugnant. We think other groups should have to think about how they would feel, then they will understand why we are refusing.”

They point out that leaders of the Prison Officers Association have supported hanging but remained equivocal about the location of executions.

Last week the POA said: “There is nothing to stop the government from setting aside a place of execution.”

The governors are angry at the drift of opinion towards capital punishment because they have been trying to launch new schemes for detaining dangerous offenders, many of whom would escape the gallows on grounds of diminished responsibility.

They draw Mr Brittan’s attention to this in the final paragraph of their letter: “We need to give greater priority to developing suitable methods and accommodation to contain these people. We hope you will never underestimate the burden that this group of prisoners imposes on prison governors and their staff and that you will continue to seek to provide the financial and staff resources to enable us to adequately deal with these prisoners.”