There is a special air of insincerity about the claim by the former Chief Constable of West Yorkshire, Mr Ronald Gregory, that he has published his account of the hunt for the Yorkshire Ripper because the public has a right to know the truth.
The fact that he is charging a reported £40,000 to provide this right is only the most obvious flaw in his argument. What is worse is that his “world exclusive revelations” are largely identical to old Fleet Street stories, obtained without his approval and attacked by him it the time.
While his officers floundered in the wake of Peter Sutcliffe’s killings, Ronald Gregory and his right-hand men fought a rear-guard action to silence critics of their performance. “They can only undermine the morale of the force,” he complained.
Not even his own men were given the benefit of his knowledge. One senior officer, still in the force, told the Press Association yesterday: “The question everyone should ask Mr Gregory is that, if he is so concerned about the mistakes and lessons, why didn’t he tell us? He didn’t organise a single conference to tell us what went wrong so we would know what to do in the future.”
In the Mail on Sunday, Mr Gregory reveals that different officers interviewed Sutcliffe nine times before his arrest, that he was never considered a prime suspect; that his wife unwittingly gave false alibis for him; that one detective suspected him, and that his suspicions were ignored. It has all been said before and without Mr Gregory’s assistance.
The paper chose to devote its front page to the revelation that a West Yorkshire schoolgirl, Tracey Browne, was attacked by Sutcliffe in August 1975, provided an accurate photofit description of him and failed repeatedly to persuade detectives to accept that her assailant was the Ripper. The story is old and wrong.
The link between Tracey Browne and Sutcliffe was brought out by the Sunday Times in November 1981. They also published the photofit which the Mail on Sunday claims to make public for the first time. And last night Tracey’s father said the family has not suspected a link with the Ripper attacks until November 1980: “There is no way Mr Gregory can say police knew about the connection all along and failed to act.”
Mr Gregory’s greatest confession is that his decision to release the tapes and letters which subsequently proved to be the work of a hoaxer, was the biggest mistake of the five-year inquiry. This was suggested to him before Sutcliffe’s trial, when he said: “It may have been a mistake and it may not.”
In his quest for the truth, Mr Gregory fails to mention that, at the time when the tapes and letters were being so heavily publicised, newspapers dug out the views of experts who had warned Mr Gregory that they were hoaxes. Nor does he recall his own efforts to dismiss those warnings. His claim that the inquiry was denied a computer because of the cost was challenged yesterday by the West Yorkshire Police Authority. His description of Olive Smelt, who survived one of Sutcliffe’s attacks, as a prostitute has persuaded her to try to sue him for libel.
Even his claim, broadcast in the Mail on Sunday’s headlines, that “We catch him at last, then almost let him go” collapses under the weight of the truth. Sutcliffe was caught by officers from the neighbouring South Yorkshire force. On one notable occasion during the Ripper inquiry Mr Gregory did spontaneously show his hand — on the night that Sutcliffe was caught. He held a press conference, at which he said he was “absolutely delighted about developments” and announced the inquiry was being scaled down. The Attorney General censured him, and the Lord Chancellor accused him of provoking newspapers into breaking the laws of contempt.