Chard wins a new appeal and a chance to change the law

The Guardian, 24 June 1983

The Law Lords yesterday agreed to hear a new appeal by Alan Chard who was released on parole after a police informer had told the Guardian that he had given false evidence.

Mr Chard, aged 48, of Stratford, east London, was gaoled for 15 years in November 1975 for conspiring to rob banks, as a result of one of Scotland Yard’s biggest supergrass operations. His sentence was cut to 12 years on appeal in March 1977.

Yesterday’s decision was welcomed in legal circles as a chance to clarify the Appeal Court’s role in alleged miscarriages of justice.

After the Guardian article, in March 1981, the Home Secretary referred Mr Chard’s case back to the Appeal Court with a request that the judges reconsider his whole case, not just the evidence of the informer, Peter Wilding, who had admitted perjury. But when the case came to court in November 1982, Lord Justice O’Connor ruled that it had to concentrate on Wilding alone. Wilding again changed his story, stood by his original evidence, and Mr Chard’s appeal was turned down.

Yesterday’s decision by Lord Scarman, Lord Fraser and Lord Templeman means that Mr Chards’ lawyers will have a chance to persuade the Law Lords that all the evidence in the case should be reviewed, including alibis and contradictions in the police account of events. When Peter Wilding supplied a statement to the Guardian, saying that he had lied under pressure from police and other supergrasses, he cast doubt on the reliability of dozens of other convictions secured in the same police operation. Mr Chard was released on early parole soon after the article appeared.