Robert Mugabe’s plans to make Zimbabwe a free, peaceful, socialist African state have crumbled in the face of external pressure and internal dissent. The slaughter of innocent villages in Matabeleland is only the most bloody symptom of a Government clampdown which has seen thousands detained without trial, opponents tortured, the press muzzled, the courts defied and trade unions brought to heel.
At the root of the crisis lies the Mugabe government’s failure to limit the power of the wealthy white landowners and the multinational companies who still run the economy and who, by their very existence, have frustrated the ambitions of the black majority.
The rebellion of armed ‘dissidents’ in Matabeleland is a direct challenge to the government’s whole posture – its Shona domination; its failure to redistribute wealth, particularly the land; and its compliance with Western free enterprise.
The government’s response has been equally direct – a deliberate and determined campaign to wipe out the dissidents, to liquidate Joshua Nkomo’s Zapu party which is accused of directing them, and to cause such terror among ordinary civilians that their popular support will wither. Mugabe and his ministers have denied this. They have blamed proven atrocities on dissidents and dismissed unproven allegations as the distortions of a biased and sensationalist foreign press and Zapu propaganda.
But their denials are undermined by the sheer weight and consistency of the evidence from Matabeleland and by the fact that Government supporters privately admit that the killings are taking place and argue that they are politically necessary. Much of this evidence comes from refugees, some of whom have made miraculous escapes.
One man, for instance, survived after being shot and left for dead by a Fifth Brigade firing squad. He told his story in a safe house in Bulawayo. The Fifth Brigade came to his village outside the town of Lupane on February 11. They rounded up the villagers, selected 11 of them for execution and marched them into the bush art gunpoint.
“There was an old man. After a while, he began to fall behind. He was stumbling. The soldiers told him to lie down on his belly. There was a woman in the group. They gave her an axe and told her to cut off his head. She refused and so they stripped her and beat her and beat her and then they gave her the axe again. She tried to cut off the old man’s head, but she just chipped the back of his neck and he started bleeding.
“So they beat her again. She was bruised and bleeding. Then she took the axe and she cut off the old man’s head. They left her there. I suppose she is dead. They made the other nine march on.”
Deeper in the bush, the nine villagers were lined up. The soldiers stood back and shot them down. The survivor fell with the rest, wounded in the chest, and lay there until nightfall when he started to drag himself through the bush. With the help of friends, he reached Bulawayo, where he took refuge while his wounds were treated.
He says that the man who was standing beside him in the firing line was Geoffrey Malaba, president of the Matabeleland division of the small farmers association. Mr Malaba is listed as missing.
The Mugabe government should know what is going on. Ministers have been besieged by churchmen, doctors, aid agencies and diplomats who have submitted reports and dossiers to support their claims. The evidence which has been presented includes detailed case histories, photographs, statements by witnesses, locations of corpses and a list of some 200 named individuals who are known to have died during the first two weeks of the campaign.
The allegations come together to reveal a strategy which has its own appalling logic. It starts from the premise that the stability of independent Zimbabwe was seriously threatened by the activity of dissidents and compounded by the threat of South African involvement.
In 1982, 3,700 soldiers deserted the national army with their weapons. Most were ex-Zipra, supporters of Joshua Nkomo. There were armed attacks on numerous stores, ranches, buses and barracks. An estimated $235,000 was stolen. Farmers and government employees were killed. Six foreign tourists were kidnapped. Enormous arms caches were found. Captured dissidents allegedly confessed that they were acting on instructions from People’s Command run by two of Nkomo’s MPs on his orders.
In August, five South African soldiers were killed and two captured by government troops in Masvingo Province. By the end of the year, dissident activity had resisted the efforts of the local police and of ordinary national army troops. The Fifth Brigade – 5,000 ex-guerrillas specially trained by the North Koreans – were sent in.
Their job was two-fold: to identify and deal with active or potential dissidents and to cut off their support among the villagers of Matabeleland. Even though ministers, army officers, and Mugabe himself may not have foreseen the full extent of it, the Brigade’s brutal tactics unfolded directly from those orders.
Killing ‘dissidents’ is not enough. For the long term, their support must be eradicated. So, the brigade send men into villages, posing as dissidents and asking for food. Then they go back and kill the people who helped them. Here, too, they can look for ‘clues’.
An old man went to visit his relatives in Dakamela village. He took some cigarettes for them from the town. He was stopped at a roadblock, accused of smuggling cigarettes for dissidents and shot in the head.
Where supporters cannot be identified, they can still be terrorised. Many refugees say they were forbidden to bury their dead – the corpses lie there as a warning to them all. Random beatings and public torture teach the same lesson.
A missionary was visiting a village. He saw soldiers beating a woman who lived in a house where, according to the soldiers’ list, dissidents had once lived. The missionary tried to intervene and was cracked round the head with a rifle butt.
While publicly denying that the atrocities have occurred, government ministers are privately replying to diplomatic pressure by promising that the Fifth Brigade will not be allowed to repeat the exercise. Under pressure from the Church and aid agencies, they sent Brigadier Garver, a former Zanla leader who is now in charge of National Army operations, to tell the Fifth to be less brutal. The brigade’s commanding officer, Peter Shiri, was recalled to Harare to hear the same message.
One grotesque exchange in the Assembly on February 3 was particularly revealing. Joshua Nkomo was on his feet claiming that the Fifth Brigade had raped ‘masses of teachers’ near the town of Tsholotsho. The Deputy Minister for Education, Joseph Culverwell, leaped to the brigade’s defence. “That is not true,” he shouted, “You are talking about masses. That is not true. There were about six. That is not a mass.”
In Mplio hospital, Bulawayo, the brigade has mounted armed guards on wounded dissidents. But last week, there were 56 other casualties of the operation who had no guard – a tacit admission that they are officially registered as innocent.
In addition to the use of the Fifth Brigade, the government adopted one further tactic which has appalled observers. In December, they cut off all food and drought relief to Matabeleland where malnutrition was already spreading after two years without rain. The government argues that it had to stop the relief because the dissidents were stealing the food and burning the vehicles. Few accept that explanation. In Matabeleland, it is seen as an act of cynical blackmail.
Relief has now been resumed in two of the six districts covered by the security operation. Ministers said they did this after seeing local people eating grass. In the other four districts, relief is still banned, though reports of starvation are just as compelling there.
It is impossible to say how many have died in the operation. Estimates vary between 1,500 and 8,000. Since the Fifth Brigade do not file the normal ‘sit reps’, it is possible that not even the government knows the exact figure.
Now they are waiting to see the results of their strategy. Again the public pose belies the private talk. Despite ministerial declarations that the campaign has been a success, there is real fear in government circles in Harare that instead of solving the dissident problem, they have inflamed it.
The Fifth Brigade confronted ex-Zipra guerrillas in Matabeleland with a simple choice: stay and be killed, or run. Many of those who ran had weapons. Last week, some of them reappeared to kill and kidnap white farmers.
In a final ironic twist, the South Africans are playing for time. There is no sign that they have committed their men to the field and, two weeks ago, in an apparent attempt to curry favour with Mugabe, they offered to hand over a group of 30 dissidents from their territory to the Zimbabwe security forces.
Mugabe thus faces a double-edged disaster: the campaign has been a catastrophe in moral terms and now also threatens to be a failure as a strategy. Some of his liberal supporters cling to the hope that he has somehow managed not to be involved. It is a thin hope.
In the last three years, Mugabe has pulled more and more power into his office. The Ministers for Security and Defence, who organised the campaign, answer directly to him instead of to the Cabinet. The Central Intelligence Organisation, which compiled the lists, is run by his office.
His own words seem to many to implicate him. In a speech on dissidents to the Zimbabwe assembly last July, he warned: “Some of the measures we shall take are measures which will be extra-legal… An eye for an eye and an ear for an ear may not be adequate in our circumstances. We might very well demand two ears for one ear and two eyes for one eye.”