Zimbabwe’s slide into crisis is a story of tragic confusion — like a man in a hall of mirrors who attacks his own distorted reflection, cuts his hand on the broken mirror, and sees the injury as proof that he really was under attack.
Government supporters insist that Joshua Nkomo’s ZAPU Party has been conspiring with international mining companies, South Africa, Botswana, and Zambia to overthrow the elected Harare government by armed force.
Nkomo’s supporters say they are the victims of a campaign of political and tribal repression which has now become an attempt to liquidate them politically and exterminate them as a people.
As the two sides have drifted further into bitter paranoia, they have started to act on their fears, even though many of them are unfounded. As a result, the grievances are now real, and so is the fight.
The future of Zimbabwe turns now on the strength of the so-called ‘dissidents’ in Matabeleland. The next few months will show whether they have been pulverised into defeat, with Nkomo powerless in exile; or whether they have been inflamed into a new armed struggle with Nkomo as their political focus.
The seeds of the paranoia go back through thousands of years of tribal rivalry, in which the Ndebele in the south oppressed the weaker Shona in the north. In generation after generation, the seeds have been replanted as old vendettas are settled.
One prominent Ndebele told me: “Even when we were at school, when we were planning to do something naughty or to make a protest against a particular teacher, the first one to tell on you was always a Shona.” The Shona, of course, tell the story the other way round.
As the movement for independence gathered momentum, the old distrust rankled. In 1983, Nkomo’s new ZAPU party split as Ndhinge Sithole broke away with a predominantly Shona group who became ZANU. During the years of detention, Robert Mugabe emerged as its leader.
An uneasy union between the two groups as the Patriotic Front helped to win the war and then collapsed before the post-independence elections in April 1980. Candidates and campaigners were killed; voters were harassed. Each side threatened to return to the bush if they lost: each side say they only made the threat because the other side made it first.
Mugabe’s ZANU swept the board at the election, winning 57 seats with the sup-port of the numerically-greater Shona. Nkomo’s ZAPU was left with 20 seats, concentrated in Matabeleland.
Mugabe strove to neutralise the tension by inviting Nkomo into the government. Nkomo accepted the position of Home Affairs minister, but many of his supporters – particularly the militant former members of the armed wing, ZIPRA – had no doubt that they would be betrayed.
The hall of mirrors began to work its tricks, and soon the dissidents emerged. Villagers had supported guerrillas to get a share of the white-owned land. The guerrillas, many of them trained in Socialist countries, saw it as the main purpose of peace.
“It was about land hunger,” said a senior ZAPU official. “We expected fair distribution of this land. People in the country were eager to jump at the white farmers’ land. This didn’t take shape. People got very disheartened. A person in Matabeleland thinks this kind of thing is intended to suppress Ndebeles. They didn’t understand that the problem was the same in Mashonaland.”
Disaffection spread. Ndebeles complained that Shonas were being drafted into the most influential jobs in their area; that they didn’t have a university in Bulawayo; that they had no new schools or hospitals; that their war veterans were being abandoned.
On the political front, the pot started to boil when Nkomo was demoted to a Cabinet job without portfolio in January 1981. It boiled over again a year later when the government located some of ZIPRA’s stolen arms on farms owned by them.
Nkomo and other ZAPU ministers were sacked from the Cabinet. Two thousand ex-ZIPRA fighters were reported to have deserted from the army with their weapons. Local ZAPU councillors were detained. Worst of all, the government seized ZAPU’s properties.
These were not just political properties: there were chains of co-operative farms all over Matabeleland, purchased by ZAPU to try to satisfy their land hunger without government help. Garages, hotels, motels, shops, and a snake park for tourists were all seized. The government said the businesses were there to finance a guerrilla coup. ZAPU and the thousands of their supporters who were employed in the businesses, saw it as a capitalist regime smashing their Socialist ambitions.
Through these two years of economic, military, and political struggle, dissident activity had been slowly growing. Some were just criminals without political aims: their only skills were learned in the war. When they felt let down by the new regime, they took up their guns and started robbing stores and buses as a way of life.
Seeing the danger, ZAPU tried to crack down on them. Then local businessmen, white farmers and obstructive ZAPU officials started to be killed by the ‘dissidents’. ZAPU said the murders were committed by government troops posing as dissidents. Their commitment wavered.
Quite separate from the criminal dissidents were those with political aims. One veteran ZIPRA guerrilla, Nkomo Jahulani, went back into the bush straight after the election. ZIPRA sent out a unit, who had fought with him, to rack him down. They killed him.
Here, too, as disaffection spread, ZIPRA Iost confidence in the regime. They revived their old contacts with the Russians and started to make military contingency plans. One of ZIPRA’s most powerful militants, Dumiso Dabengwa, who was a member of the National Army, had written to the chairman of the KGB asking for support within weeks of the election.
After the arms caches were found in February 1982, Dabengwa was arrested with another ZIPRA commander, Lookout Masuku, and four ZAPU leaders. The arrests raised paranoia on both sides. The trial is still going on.
In the last few months, Zimbabwe has seen the Fifth Brigade slaughtering ZAPU supporters and their families; Nkomo detained and now fleeings; hundreds of his followers thrown into prisons; tribal tension unbearably inflamed. Out in the bush, the ZIPRA deserters have been reinforced by those who have fled from the Fifth Brigade.
The mirrors are all broken. The enemies have stepped out into the open. Zimbabwe can only wait to see if the real battle will now begin.