Three officers face charges over shooting

The Guardian, 18 January 1983

The three Scotland Yard officers who were suspended after Friday night’s shooting incident in Kensington face the possibility of being charged this week.

A report on the shooting, in which an innocent man was seriously wounded, is due at the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions today.

It is understood that the internal inquiry by the Yard’s Complaints Investigations Bureau has shown that the first shot was fired by Detective Constable Peter Finch, an officer who had previously encountered David Martin.

Detective Constable Finch is thought to have been present on September 15 last year when Martin was arrested and shot in the shoulder. Martin was subsequently charged with the attempted murder of Police Constable Nick Carr, who was shot in the groin when he went to investigate a burglary on August 5.

The internal inquiry into Friday’s shooting has had to deal with the possibility that some officers failed to comply with the normal guidelines for use of firearms. Officers are taught not to try to shoot out the tyres of a vehicle containing a wanted man.

Mr Steven Waldorf, aged 25, the man injured in the shooting, was still critically ill in St Stephen’s Hospital, Fulham, yesterday. After a successful second operation to stop bleeding from a large abdominal artery, one of his lungs filled with blood and collapsed and had to be drained.

The hospital administrator, Mr Michael Connor, said Mr Waldorf was still on a breathing machine. He was conscious and aware of his surroundings but unable to speak. He had been visited by his girl friend, Miss Sue Phillips, and his parents are staying in the hospital.

The police hunt for David Martin was stepped up yesterday when Commander Frank Cater, head of C8, the Yard’s Central Robbery Squad, was put in charge. He controlled the operation in 1979 which led to the peaceful arrest of an unusually violent criminal, Harry ‘Big H’ MacKenny.

Publication of Martin’s picture has led to a flood of calls from the public, which police have checked. Martin’s solicitor, Mr Anthony Blok, said yesterday that Martin should contact him to make arrangements to give himself up.

Scotland Yard confirmed at the weekend that one of the bullets fired on Friday evening hit the back wheel of the car involved in the incident. It is now believed that this was fired by Detective Constable Finch.

The other two officers who have been suspended are Detective Constable John Jardine and Detective Constable Fred Dean, both attached to the Yard’s criminal intelligence branch, C11. All three officers were questioned on Friday night immediately after the incident and again on Saturday at greater length, after which they were suspended from duty.

The Home Secretary, Mr William Whitelaw, avoided giving details about the shooting when he made a statement to the Commons yesterday. He said the possibility of criminal proceedings limited what he could say. Some Labour MPs were annoyed last night that Mr Whitelaw, who is directly responsible for the Metropolitan Police, had got off the hook on a serious law-and-order issue.

The Shadow Home Secretary, Mr Roy Hattersley, made it clear that he will not be satisfied with anything less than a thorough and independent inquiry. Mr Whitelaw told MPs it was “a most serious, grave and disturbing incident.” He was loudly supported when he added: “Nothing like this must happen again.”

The Home Secretary met members of the Conservative backbench Home Affairs Committee last night. It was emphasised that the meeting was routine, but the shooting incident was one of the issues discussed. Mr Whitelaw escaped any personal criticism. But some Conservative MPs were critical of the police.

Mr Ivan Lawrence, a lawyer as well as an MP, said there was ‘very substantial alarm’ not only that the wrong man was hit but over the possibility that the police would be allowed to use firearms in a public place.

One of the backbench committee members, Mr John Wheeler, said: “There must be proceedings. There is no justification for what happened, and there must be proceedings before a court because the principle of accountability for the conduct of the police is pre-eminent in this issue.”

Mr Whitelaw earlier told MPs that three officers had already been suspended from duty. He had been given an initial report yesterday morning by the Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Sir Kenneth Newman, and this was being sent to the DPP.

He published the Metropolitan Police rules governing use of firearms, which he said were ‘stringent and explicit’. They would be thoroughly examined to see whether lessons could be learned from Friday’s incident. But he gave no commitment about publication of rules governing police authorities outside London.

The rules state that every police officer issued with a weapon must be strictly warned “that it is to be used only in cases of absolute necessity: for example, if he, or the person he is protecting, is attacked by a person with a firearm or other deadly weapon, and he cannot otherwise reasonably protect himself or give protection.” The officer may resort to firearms in these circumstances ‘as a means of defence’.

Mr Whitelaw generally had an easy ride from MPs in contrast to previous occasions when he has been called to answer for such contentious issues as breaches of security at Buckingham Palace.

Some of the Labour anger was directed at Mr Alan Clark, Conservative MP for Plymouth Sutton, for claiming that the passengers in the car which was hit in the shooting were “tainted with criminality” and that the circumstances leading up to the mistaken identity were perfectly justifiable.