Jury acquits man who accused London detectives of corruption

The Guardian, 18 January 1983

John Twomey, who was acquitted of armed robbery at the Old Bailey on Saturday after an eight-year battle with Scotland Yard detectives, accuses them of fabricating evidence against him and using him to protect fellow officers from anti-corruption inquiries. He was formally acquitted after a second jury had failed to agree verdicts on the charges against him.

John Twomey’s story goes to the heart of corruption among London detectives and the way it is dealt with. In the trial he claimed that he had been ” fitted up ” to punish him for helping Operation Countryman, which spent four years trying to investigate police corruption in London.

The fact that the jury did not convict him does not necessarily mean that they accepted his claim, but it does suggest, at least, that they were worried by it and could not dismiss it as the unfounded fantasy of a desperate defendant.

The trial judge, in his summing-up, confronted the jury with the implications of a not guilty verdict. He said: “If you accept the defence case, it is a dreadful thought that as the facts of this story developed and as the web of conspiracy was spun every police officer who took part, from the youngest police constable upwards, immediately and without hesitation turned his hand to criminal dishonesty. Every single one.”

In the battle between Mr Twomey and the police, he has been acquitted seven times – for murder, armed robbery and wounding. Six officers have been sus-pended as a result of his allegations: two of them have been sacked and one has been forced to resign.

The police account of the battle is that Mr Twomey is a professional criminal who richly deserves to be behind bars. He claims that he is the victim of a vendetta inspired by his cockiness, his willingness to challenge police evidence, and his co-operation with Countryman’s efforts.

An insight into the strong feelings that divided the two sides is provided by internal Scotland Yard memos produced as evidence in court. They were written by Detective Inspector Terence Babbidge, who was eventually suspended from duty after several unsuccessful prosecutions against Mr Twomey.

He told superior officers in the memos that Mr Twomey was “an evil and dangerous criminal,” and that his solicitor was “a devious and cunning individual who will go to any lengths to secure an acquittal for his clients.”

Mr Babbidge pointed to a series of court cases in which Mr Twomey and his friends and been cleared of charges, and pleaded for action. Mr Babbidge had been involved in bringing some of the failed charges.

In one notable case in October 1977, a man called John Gordon had been cleared of murder after Mr Twomey gave evidence for the defence. Two days after Mr Gordon was cleared, Mr Twomey was arrested and charged with a bank robbery. The case became a showdown over corruption.

Mr Twomey produced a tape-recording on which two detective constables, Paul Rextrew and Michael Ross, could be heard asking a man for £1,500 in exchange for not ‘fitting him up’ with the bank robbery.

Lawyers for Mr Twomey also presented evidence that Mr Rextrew and two other officers – Detective Sergeant John Ross and the same Detective Inspector Terence Babbidge – had plotted to fabricate evidence against Mr Twomey for the bank rob-bery.

The case was taken over by Operation Countryman after no evidence was offered against Mr Twomey in April 1979. The four officers were suspended with two of their colleagues, who were never brought to trial. The four were tried and cleared in March 1982, leaving the matter officially unresolved.

However, Deputy Assistant Comissioner David Powis, in charge of London’s detective operations, has since said on oath that he believes Mr Twomey was innocent of the bank robbery.

Michael and John Ross, who are brothers, have been sacked from the force; Paul Rextrew has resigned; Terence Babbidge has been transferred to the uniform branch.

According to the defence at Mr Twomey’s most recent trial, it was this case and Twomey’s cooperation with Operation Countryman which persuaded other officers to try to charge him with yet more robberies.

Crucially, it is said, Mr Twomey was arrested and charged in the course of the Countryman trial of the four officers. When he appeared to give evidence for Countryman in that trial, he walked into the witness box with an escort of prison officers – a clear signal to the jury, it was said, that he was a criminal who could not be trusted.

That allegation was disputed by the police during the trial which finished on Saturday. They said they had evidence against Mr Twomey in the form of a fingerprint, fibres of his cardigan, and statements from an informer, and, knowing that he was to be a Countryman witness, had arrested him only after seeking clearance from Scotland Yard and the Director of Public Prosecutions.

The defence sketched a web of connections between the four officers who had been charged by Countryman and the detectives who were bringing new charges against Mr Twomey.

His counsel, Mr Michael Mansfield, made the allegation explicit: “They wanted to disable Twomey so that their fellow officers in the Operation Countryman case would have one less hurdle to clear.”

The defence said that Mr Twomey’s friend, Patrick Carpenter, who had also helped Countryman, was also marked to be charged until it was realised that he had been in prison at the time of the robberies.

The police said they had never intended to charge Mr Carpenter. Mr Powis contradicted this by saying he had been told that Mr Carpenter was to be charged. The police in the case said this had been a mistake.

The defence said that a squeezy bottle bearing Mr Twomey’s fingerprints had been stolen from him and planted at the scene of the robbery by the police. The police dismissed this as speculation and denied suggestions that there had been irregularities in the way the squeezy bottle was processed.

The defence said that fibres from one of Mr Twomey’s cardigans had been planted, and added that Twomey had not even owned the cardigan at the time the robbery took place. The prosecution said the suggestion was an unfounded smear.

Mr Twomey has already been tried once on the most recent charges – in March, when the jury was unable to agree on a verdict.