Scotland Yard apologises for shooting ‘victim of mistaken identity’

The Guardian, 17 January 1983

Scotland Yard last night formally apologised for an incident in Kensington, London, On Friday night when armed officers shot an innocent man, apparently as he tried to crawl out of his car to escape from them.

The injured man, Mr Steven Waldorf, aged 25, was in a critical condition in St Stephens Hospital, Fulham, last night after a four-hour operation on bullet wounds in his abdomen.

Three detective constables have been suspended from duty while the Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Sir Kenneth Newman, personally oversees an internal inquiry led by the head of the Complaints Investigation Bureau, Commander Mike Taylor. Thirty witnesses have been traced, and a preliminary report is due to be delivered to the Home Office this morning.

The Home Secretary, Mr William Whitelaw, is expected to make a statement this afternoon in the House of Commons about the shooting, which has provoked furious criticism of Scotland Yard, its new commissioner, and its increasing use of firearms.

In a statement last night Scotland Yard said: “The Metropolitan Police deeply regret that anyone should have been injured as a result of police activities.” It described the shooting as “a tragic case of mistaken identity.”

Mr Waldorf was shot by a squad of armed officers who were looking for David Martin, a 35-year-old London man charged with attempted murder after shooting a police man in the groin last August. He escaped from Marlborough street magistrate’s court on Christmas Eve.

Mr Waldorf was sitting in the front passenger seat of a yellow Mini which was being driven by his friend, Lester Purdy, in Pembroke Road, Kensington, on Friday at about 6 pm. Miss Sue Stephens was in the back seat.

As the car stood still in the rush-hour traffic police opened fire. Shooting from the pavement, they hit Mr Waldorf. Mr Purdy threw open the driver’s door and ran off. Mr Waldorf seems to have tried to follow him, but was hit again as he crawled across the front seat, and again as he lay in the road.

Scotland Yard say that Sue Stephens, whose back was grazed by a bullet, was known to be a friend of David Martin. “Having regard to the background, the officers were armed. When the car stopped in heavy traffic an officer sought to identify Martin, and shots were fired,” their statement said.

A spokesman confirmed that one shot from a police .38 Smith and Wesson had hit one of the car’s back tyres, but would not comment on reports that that this shot had been fired to immobilise the car, and was mistaken by other officers as gunfire coming from inside the vehicle.

In today’s Daily Mail, Miss Stephens is quoted as saying that when the police realised they had shot the wrong man they changed from being “exultant, really hysterical about the shooting.”

“I said: ‘You’ve made a terrible mistake…’  A voice shouted: ‘Who is it, Susie? Who have we shot?’ Suddenly, it was like everyone was backing off. At first they had looked really hyped up — nervous but satisfied they’d done a good job. Then it was just horror and fright.”

Of the shooting she said: “It seemed to be going on forever. Then suddenly it stopped.”

She was pulled from the car, she said, and saw Mr Waldorf. “He was hanging out of the car… two policemen still had their guns on him. One shouted to the others, ‘Is he dead?’ and the first one answered, ‘No, his hands are still moving.’ Then they began to laugh. It was really hysterical laughter. I said: ‘You’ve, made a terrible mistake. Terrible,’ and one answered: ‘What the hell do you mean? That’s your boyfriend we’ve just got, isn’t it?’

“I turned on him and said: ‘You think it’s David Martin don’t you?’ and he replied: ‘Who else could it be?’ So I looked him straight in the eye and said, ‘Well, turn him over and look at his face ‘.”

Mr Waldorf was on a breathing machine in the intensive care unit yesterday, conscious but unable to speak to his parents at the bedside. His operation on Friday night was for abdominal injuries, including damage to his liver.

A solicitor representing Mr Waldorf, his family, and Mr Purdy said that the family did not want to say anything yet. A formal complaint about the police action was being considered.

The row which grew over the weekend centres on the fact that nearly a fifth of Metropolitan Police officers are trained to use guns, which are issued around 6,000 times a year under guidelines which are substantially kept secret.

The Commons debate is likely to be led by Mr Roy Hattersley, the Shadow Home Secretary, who said yesterday that the incident, raised fundamental questions about police procedure. “It causes the greatest concern about both the methods of identification of suspects and the basis on which decisions are taken to open fire on targets which appear to offer no threat to life or personal safety,” he said. “Underlying these questions is the general issue of the control of the Metropolitan Police, a subject of increasing national concern.”

Mr Eldon Griffiths, Conservative MP for Bury St Edmunds and parliamentary adviser to the Police Federation, said that the rules on guns were crystal clear, and no new system could guard against human error. Police used more guns because criminals did the same, and criminals did so because they no longer faced the death penalty if they killed someone.

Mr Paul Boateng, chairman of the police committee of the Greater London Council, which wants to replace the Home Secretary as London’s police authority by elected representatives, said yesterday that the policy and procedures for police use of firearms had never been publicly debated and scrutinised, as they should be.

The inquiry into the conduct on Friday of the suspended officers, two of them from the central criminal intelligence squad and one from the local division, will lead to a report being sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions.