Armed police in France have so often shot and killed the wrong people that Parisians have coined a new slang word to describe the incidents. They call them ‘bavures’ – literally, gobs of spit, the equivalent of getting egg on your face in English.
The French now accept bavures as an inevitable part of city life: policemen must carry guns, and so they will use them, and so there will be bavures. Friday night’s shooting in Kensington raises the spectre of the same kind of thing happening in London.
The number of occasions on which firearms are issued to police officers in the capital has been rising steadily over the last decade and reached 6,000 in 1980. There are also dozens of officers permanently armed for royal, diplomatic and other protection duties.
Among the 6,000 occasions on which they were issued in 1980, the weapons were actually used only half-a-dozen times, which could indicate that the police are too ready to arm themselves – or that their restraint is exemplary. In each of the last two years, there were more than 600 occasions when armed criminals fired guns, sometimes against the police.
The issuing of a weapon in London has to be authorised by an inspector, who then has to Inform a chief superintendent. Other forces are more cautious. In the West Midlands, for example, only a chief constable or assistant chief constable can give the authority.
The Met’s guidelines on the use of weapons say: “Every police officer to whom a weapon is issued must be strictly warned that it is to be used only in cases of absolute necessity. If the person he is protecting is attacked by a person with a firearm or other deadly weapon; otherwise to reasonably protect himself or give protection: he may resort to firearms as a means of defence.”
The guidelines also say that officers should shout a warning and call for surrender before shots are fired. If guns are used, the officers involved must submit immediate reports, and an internal inquiry is held.
The inquiry into Friday night’s shooting must face the fact that witnesses inside and outside Stephen Waldorf’s car agree that no warning was shouted. “The first thing we knew was when there were bullets everywhere,” said Sue Stevens, the young woman in the car.
It must also be clear that an unarmed film editor with no history of violence does not amount to the sort of dangerous threat which could justify the use of guns under the Yard’s guidelines.
Apart from these two central apparent breaches of the firearms rules, the officers may also be criticised for misidentifying their target in the first place and for becoming so confused during the incident that they allowed one of the supposedly wanted men in the car to get away.
The inquiry may find that the officers were so determined to ‘nail’ David Martin, who was wanted for trying to murder one of their colleagues, that they deliberately cut corners and ended up shooting the wrong man.
But what is causing even deeper concern is the possibility that, as the French have discovered, the wrong people get shot even if the rules are followed. Opposition MPs have pointed out that even if the police had correctly identified David Martin as the man in the car, it would not have been correct to shoot him unless he was violently resisting arrest. It is apparent that the officers in Kensington did not wait to test their quarry’s mood.
Several incidents have demonstrated that nerves and confusion often overcome training and judgment when guns are being carried.
When a West Midlands gunman used his girl friend, Gail Kinchin, as a shield In 1980, she was hit by three police bullets and later died. And when the police eventually cornered the dangerous Barry Prudom in Malton, Yorkshire, last year, officers thought his suicide shot was directed at them, and a large number of bullets were then fired into his dead body. In both cases, firearms guidelines were being followed.
On the political front, Friday’s incident was grist to the mill of the Greater London Council and the Labour Party in their drive to make the Met more accountable to the public. “The Met’s policy and practice on the use of firearms – as on nearly everything else it does – has never been the subject of public scrutiny, as it ought to be,” said Paul Boateng, chairman of the GLC police committee.
A Conservative MP, Mr John Wheeler, and the National Council for Civil Liberties also raised the question of whether police instructions on firearms are consistent with the law, as defined by court rulings, on the minimum use of force. “It is a cardinal principle of English law that the police will only use the minimum necessary force to effect an arrest,” said Mr Wheeler. “The reported incident appears to be a serious breach of the constitutional position and may mean a breach of the criminal law.”
Patricia Hewitt, general secretary of the NCCL, said: “The incident shows a disturbing similarity to recent events in Northern Ireland where people posing no threat to the security forces were shot dead. The legal position is that lethal force should only be used by the police and the Army when they reasonably believe that their own lives or those of members of the public are at risk.”