Hugh Hambleton: a real spy surrounded by fantasy

The Guardian, 8 December 1982

On June 23 this year, Professor Hugh Hambleton made a serious error of judgment: he boarded a plane at Montreal airport and flew to London, straight into the arms of the British Special Branch. That error, which has now cost him 10 years of liberty, is a clue to his whole way of life. Hambleton, in the words of one of his oldest friends, Dr Lloyd De Lamater, “lives in a world of myths and fantasies.”

The myths and fantasies persuaded him to dabble in the world of intelligence in the first place – first for the West and then for the KGB. They also persuaded him to ignore clear warnings that he would be charged if he came to Britain.

Hambleton’s family belongs to the liberal intelligentsia of Ottawa—his father, George, was a political journalist; his mother, Bessie, was a government economist. He grew up with diplomats and politicians all around him. Friends now speculate that he never lost the urge to belong to the world of the power-brokers which he saw as a child.

When the second world war broke out, he gave up his studies in aeronautical engineering at Vancouver to join the Free French Forces. It may be that the real world of De Gaulle’s forces in North Africa did not live up to his myths and fantasies. He was stationed with them for just one month, in October 1944, but he spent the rest of his life claiming to have been with them for far longer, spying and cracking coded messages and interrogating prisoners.

He also used to claim that he had later been attached to Canadian and American intelligence units working with the French resistance behind German lines. In fact, as military records show, he spent six months working on “the investigation of political intelligence ” – desk work.

After the war he found a job with the Canadian National Film Board – hardly a position from which to change the world. But his sister, Josephine, was a secretary in the Chilean embassy in Ottawa. Through her, he found his way into the diplomatic circuit of cocktail parties and black tie balls. He claims now that it was at this time that he was approached by a Soviet cultural attache from the embassy in Ottawa, whose name was Vladimir Borodin. “He was always talking about dead letter boxes and things,” he told the Old Bailey last week. But there is no record of a Vladimir Borodin ever being attached to the Russian embassy.

Borodin is a relatively recent addition to Hambleton’s colourful account of his life. He used to claim that his first contact with the KGB had come ten years later, in 1962, when he was approached by one Pedro Garcia, a Spanish Communist, in a bookshop in Paris.  Hambleton now admits that Garcia was a figment of his imagination. Borodin may have come from the same source.

But at some stage in the 1950s he managed to make his fantasies come true. Working for NATO’s economic secretariat in Paris, he started passing top secret documents to KGB officers in meetings at metro stations.

Although he worked as an economist, he had access to military information which formed part of the background for annual reviews of the economic performance of member states. He had, for example, details of the weaknesses and deficiencies of French and British forces at the time. In 1961, he left NATO possibly because he feared he was about to be unmasked by a defector who had changed sides in Belgium, possibly because he was genuinely frightened by what he was doing, as he now claims.

He spent the next 18 years as an academic, first at the LSE and then at Laval University in Quebec, teaching, writing, occasionally working abroad for the Canadian International Development Agency and regularly meeting KGB contacts. Hambleton’s own account includes his extraordinary tale of being smuggled into Moscow to meet the then head of KGB, Yuri Andropov. Security sources believe the story, citing it an example of the level which he had achieved as an ‘agent of influence’ rather than as a conventional spy.

It is a matter of record that he was in touch with the KGB during this period. His contact in Quebec was Rudi Herrmann, apparently a freelance photographer and film director but really a KGB colonel. Unfortunately for Hambleton, Herrmann was ‘turned’ by the FBI in 1977 and spent two years as a double agent. The FBI tipped off the Royal Canadian Mounted Police security service who started a surveillance operation on the economics professor, code named Operation Red Pepper. On November 4, 1979 they moved in and arrested him.

Searching his home, they found the tools of a spy: ‘invisible writing’ paper, one-time code pads, and the sophisticated ‘tonal converter’ which translated high-pitched whines on his radio into sequences of numbers which formed the key to a code. Hambleton was interviewed 13 times by the RCMP, who submitted a series of reports to their Ministry of Justice. On April 25 1979, it was decided that there was insufficient evidence to prosecute him.

The decision reflected the Canadians’ lack of confidence in their Official Secrets Act which has seen a series of embarrassing acquittals and also the inherent difficulty of finding hard evidence on which to prosecute a secret agent. In his interviews, Hambleton was admitting that he had met Russian agents like Herrmann but insisting that he had never passed over a secret.

All would have been well for him, had he not agreed despite the advice of his family to cooperate with the RCMP after he had been granted an immunity from prosecution by the Canadian authorities. During almost daily interviews with Inspector Frank Pratt of the RCMP security service in 1980, Hambleton could not resist disclosing his activities in Paris nearly 20 years earlier. The substance of his confessions was relayed to other Western intelligence agencies. The Canadians were ham-strung by their own immunity deal, but the British had no such inhibition.

Inspector Pratt warned him that he would probably be charged if he set foot in Britain. Still he came, repeated his confession to the Special Branch in London and, as Lloyd De Lamater said yesterday, “he may have been convicted on his own myths.”