Punished at court: the spy who was not a spy

The Guardian, 30 November 1982

Rhona Ritchie, a rising star of the British Embassy in Tel Aviv, yesterday admitted that she had been passing confidential information to her lover, who was a diplomat at the Egyptian Embassy.

Miss Ritchie, aged 30, was given a nine-month suspended sentence at the Old Bailey for a breach of the Official Secrets Act, which was described by the Attorney General, Sir Michael Havers, as more foolish than wicked.

The court was told that Miss Ritchie passed six telegrams to Refaat el Ansary while she was working as second secretary in Chancery at the British Embassy between July 1981 and March 1982. All the telegrams were marked ‘confidential’.

The most important – and the only one to figure in the indictment at yesterday’s hearing – was sent last November 26 by the then Foreign Secretary, Lord Carrington, to the then American Secretary of State, Mr Alexander Haig.

It concerned the British Government’s willingness to take part in the multi-national force in Sinai. Copies of the telegram, which opened with the words ‘Dear Al’, were sent to a number of British embassies, including Tel Aviv.

Sir Michael told the court: “This sort of information would never have been made public. It contains matters which would have to be freely known to Mr Haig as being Lord Carrington’s views, but which were obviously better not known to the world at large.”

The other telegrams also covered the multi-national force, but Sir Michael did not quarrel with Miss Ritchie’s claim to the police that the information contained in them was destined to become public.

She said in a statement: “I was only prepared to let him see copies of final texts which I thought he could get from other sources. I realised that this was a breach of the rules, but I never felt that I had given him anything which he would not in any case find out from other sources.”

Mr George Carman, QC, defending, told the court that Miss Ritchie had not believed that she was breaking the law and had pleaded guilty only because her state of mind was not recognised legally as an issue.

He said: “Although she may on occasion have had doubts about some of the information, this young woman mistakenly made a serious error of judgement in believing that the Egyptian diplomat concerned was someone who could be trusted, and that nothing she was disclosing was in any way damaging to the interests of the British Government.”

Sir Michael countered: “The mischief lay in the very fact of a breach of confidentiality, and the inevitable doubts about our trustworthiness and security which the discovery of her conduct must have given rise to. Those governments with whom we enjoy harmonious relationships have a right to expect that confidential exchange will remain confidential.”

It is understood that Miss Ritchie was questioned after Israeli intelligence alerted the Foreign Office in London to her relationship with Mr Ansary, although friends in Tel Aviv say that the couple made no secret of their friendship.

Miss Ritchie met Mr Ansary in London in 1979 when she was working on the Hong Kong desk of the Foreign Office after giving up a career as a lecturer in law at Glasgow University to become a late entrant into the Civil Service. When she was sent to Tel Aviv he followed.

The couple were seen together often in cafes and restaurants, and attracted the attention of Tel Aviv gossip-writers, one of whom, Mira Avrech, invited them to her parties. Miss Ritchie founded a diplomats’ club, while Mr Ansary sat on the club’s com-mittee.

Mr Ansary is now first’ secretary with the Egyptian Embassy in Vienna.

Two Labour MPs yesterday attacked the handling of Miss Ritahie’s case. Mr John McWilliam, MP for Blaydon, said that it showed the weakness of Section Two of the Official Secrets Act, under which she was charged. “Under this section, if she had told anyone the ambassador’s menu for dinner, she could have been done for it,” he said.

Mr Donald Anderson, MP for Swansea East, said: “This is a very sad case. It damages the individual but not national security.”