On April 1st 1981, the civil service unions at GCHQ in Cheltenham decided to work to rule as part of their national campaign. This meant that they followed all available security procedures. The result was chaos.
Rigorous security checks at the gates to the base caused a queue of traffic which trailed back to the M5 motorway and started to choke the centre of Cheltenham. The local police complained bitterly; and soon the normal, lax security was restored.
Sources close to the base claim that security there has been in decline for the last two or three years, largely because the number of security staff has been cut in an attempt to save money without jeopardising the base’s main job of gathering intelligence.
In spite of the arrest of Geoffrey Prime in June, and the emphasis that this has placed on the need for security, the sources say that procedures have not changed, and the decline continues. Outside contractors have been working there maintaining equipment – a risk to security which saves some money.
Prime is the first Cheltenham employee to be prosecuted for spying. Alex Lawrie, who worked there for 22 years and who has become an outspoken critic, said: “That means either that security is so good that there have been no others, or that it is so bad that the others have not been found. I must incline towards the latter view.”
Other GCHQ stations have certainly been penetrated by spies. One of them, RAF Sergeant Doug Britten, is still in prison serving a 21-year sentence for spying for the Russians from 1962 to 1968 at listening posts in Cyprus and Britain.
Details of the damage done by Britten were kept secret at his trial, but a man who worked with him at Digby has told the Guardian: “There was the biggest flap ever, just after the Cuban crisis in 1962, because the Russians suddenly changed everything. After a period of years and years when you had been able to tune in knowing the right time and the right frequency, you tuned in and there was nothing there. That was Doug Britten. He had told them exactly what frequencies and call signs and codes we knew about, so they changed the lot.”
Britten was recruited by a Soviet diplomat, Alexander Ivanovitch Borisenko, who approached him in the Kensington Science Museum, introduced himself as “Yuri” and started talking to him about amateur radio, Britten’s hobby.
Yuri started to buy low-grade information from Britten, photographed the payments and then blackmailed him for higher grade material. Britten used a camera, disguised as a cigarette case, to photograph documents at RAF Digby; and beer cans with false bottoms to pass on the negatives.
Unlike Prime, Britten was caught by the internal GCHQ security system which noticed that he was living beyond his means. A report by the Security Commission concluded, perhaps optimistically, that his case reflected no security weakness.
During the period of Britten’s espionage, a corporal with the army signals unit at Teufelsberg in West Germany, Brian Patchett, defected to East Germany taking still more GCHQ secrets with him. Apart from Prime, Britten and Patchett in the GCHQ complex, the Russians have been well served by infiltrators in the American National Security Agency, which is so tight and secretive that it is known colloquially as No Such Agency.
In 1960, two NSA intelligence analysts, Vernon Mitchell and Bill Martin, defected to the Soviet Union where they held a press conference, exposing the NSA’s activities and, in particular, its habitual interception of its allies’ communications. In the backwash of their defection, 26 other NSA employees lost their jobs in ‘a purge of sexual deviants’ inspired by the fact that US security officers believed that the defectors might have been homosexual.
Three years later, in 1963, another NSA employee, a cryptologist named Victor Hamilton, defected to Moscow. Again, the Russians allowed him to publicise details of the NSA’s activities in an interview with the newspaper Izvestia.
At the same time, army sergeant Jack Lunlap, who was a courier at an NSA base, shot himself when he discovered that he was being investigated for living beyond his means.
Internal documents are all classified. Sensitive material at GCHQ is marked “Handle via Comint channels only” — a higher classification than top secret. Even administrative memos are marked “Staff — in confidence.”
(The last few lines of this story have been lost….)