Blindfolded loser in prison parole maze

The Guardian, 18 October 1982

In the Isle of Wight’s top security prison, Albany, Frank Marritt, aged 43, has started his 18th year in prison on a life sentence for murder.

In Whitehall, the Home Secretary’s officials and the Parole Board have just reviewed his case for the fifth time and decided that he should not be released.

Parole decisions are made in private, and the reasons for Mr Marritt’s detention re-main secret. Not even the prisoner was given an explanation or a specific suggestion as to how he may earn release.

In 1977, Marritt and another prisoner took the Parole Board to court to try to find out what they had to do to earn an end to their incarceration. They lost the case. Parole Board secrecy was sanctioned. And Mr Marritt stayed in custody.

He killed his girlfriend, Ada, during a drunken argument in July 1965, just before his 26th birthday. In October 1965, he was gaoled for life at Leeds Assizes for murder. A ‘domestic murderer’ serving life is usually released on licence after eight or nine years. Mr Marritt has served about twice that.

Among the estimated 1,700 lifers in British prisons, he is one of a tiny handful who have served more than 15 years. Most of the others are multiple killers.

The apparent harshness of his sentence has made Mr Marritt the focus of efforts to open up and reform the Parole Board and to draw attention to the way in which the Parole Board and prison boards of visitors can effectively sentence prisoners for non-criminal offences.

A lengthy study of his case was written by Ian Cameron and published this year by Radical Alternatives to Prison and PROP, the prisoners’ reform organisation.

Mr Cameron said: “The principle on which we say he should be released is that he has met the demands which society once reasonably made of him. The system is now destroying him. It is madness.”

Through subterfuge and informal contact, Mr Marritt and his supporters have gleaned a few clues about the Parole Board’s thinking. Mr Cameron said: “It comes down to the fact that he has served two life sentences – one for murder and one for his reaction to being in prison.

“The second life sentence has been imposed for reasons which have never been explained to Frank, at meetings where he was not present, by an institution which does not permit him to be legally represented.”

Mr Marritt’s 17 years in custody have been punctuated by disputes and punishments. From the early years of his sentence, he complained of attacks of panic and anxiety and was issued with tranquilisers to deal with them.

His disputes began in 1972 when the drugs were stopped and he was declared fit for prison work. He refused to work on the grounds that he was still sick and he has been at loggerheads with the prison authorities ever since.

He went up on the roof at Maidstone Prison in January 1978, and of Parkhurst in February and May of 1979. He has spent nearly all of his sentence in solitary confinement because of his persistent refusal to work and as punishment for his protests.

Last month, he went on hunger strike for a week. In a letter smuggled out of Albany, he wrote: “I am continually refused parole because I suffer from a nervous illness. The prison authorities deny this as it would mean they would have to admit they have kept me in almost total solitary confinement since June 1972.”

The Home Office appears to have conceded as much privately in a letter to an MP who took up the case. The letter argues that Mr Marritt is “not psychotic, neither is he currently in need of, or suitable for, any known form of medical treatment.” However, it goes on to describe him as inadequate and neurotic and to refer to his refusal to do prison work. “His present attitude will continue to pose a problem whenever his release on licence is being considered,” it adds.

Mr Marritt argues that any normal man who was locked up for 17 years without a release date would become neurotic and should be treated as such. He says he would work if he were treated and did not feel ill.

When it rejected his application this year, the Parole Board suggested he might be moved to an open prison in September. He is still in Albany. The Prison Department refuse to say whether he is still in solitary confinement, on the grounds that it might encourage other prisoners to use solitary as a publicity gimmick.