Prisons used as ‘dumping ground’ for Sutcliffe and others with mentally illness

The Guardian, 11 October 1982

Psychiatrists are subjecting the Home Office to a barrage of criticism over the treatment of Peter Sutcliffe, the Yorkshire Ripper, who they say is being unjustly sacrificed to public opinion.

The immediate issue is whether Sutcliffe, aged 36, should be transferred from prison to a special hospital – probably Park Lane in Liverpool – under Section 72 of the Mental Health Act.

But underlying that is the belief that high-security prisons have become a dumping ground for the criminally insane, who are sent there because the present structure of jury trial is an unreliable and erratic way of dealing with them.

At Sutcliffe’s trial last May, psychiatrists failed to persuade the jury of their diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia. It was suggested that he had fooled them. Now they argue that their diagnosis has been confirmed by his behaviour in Parkhurst Prison on the Isle of Wight.

Sutcliffe has complained to doctors that one of his victims, Emily Jackson, has visited him in his cell. He said he could see her and smell her perfume. One psychiatrist described it as “a text book hallucination.”

He has also complained of visions in the prison workshop, and the Parkhurst chaplain agreed to conduct an exorcism there. But the doctors say that the current evidence of his schizophrenia goes beyond his own account of hallucinations.

Prison sources say he is increasingly obsessed with his conversations with God, so that he is often irrational and incoherent. He recently objected to his lawyers and doctors, saying that they had no right deal with him because they were agnostics.

He says his divine mission to kill prostitutes is now finished and maintains that he did nothing wrong since he always acted with God’s blessing. He has suggested an appeal to the House of Lords, but his lawyers have been told he is not mentally fit to instruct them.

Dr Hugo Milne, whose evidence at the Sutcliffe trial was repeatedly attacked by the prosecution, said last week that the development of his symptoms was “par for the course.”

He said: “When I saw him before the appeal in May, I was quite prepared to accept that I had been wrong. But he is still exactly the same. There was no evidence to suggest that he was malingering at any time that I saw him. You couldn’t possibly malinger for such a long time.”

Psychiatrists were astonished at what happened in the trial last May. Four of them had examined Sutcliffe, two for the defence and two for the Crown. All four agreed that he was a schizophrenic, who was guilty of manslaughter with diminished responsibility, and that he should be sent to a secure hospital, rather than a prison, for the rest of his life.

In March, the prosecution suggested on their own initiative that this course should be followed. They seemed satisfied that the trial judge, Mr Justice Boreham, agreed. But on the first day of the trial, the judge unexpectedly rejected the deal and ruled that Sutcliffe should be tried for murder.

Dr Milne said: “As a doctor, I found it hard to understand how the Crown, who had tested and accepted the medical evidence, could then discard that evidence and say it was idiotic and cross-examine their own experts on that basis.

“The other hypocritical thing was that having discarded their expert evidence and persuaded the jury that Sutcliffe was sane, the Crown then called one of the same experts to tell the judge that Sutcliffe was insane and schizophrenic so that he could be properly sentenced.”

Dr Milne says the jury were at an immediate disadvantage because the prosecution were arguing their case with theory from a students’ introduction to psychiatry. The jurors may also have been influenced by the fact that they were not told that a manslaughter verdict could still mean that Sutcliffe spent the rest of his life in custody.

The sheer scale of the offences may also have been a problem, he believes” “It’s easier to see somebody as being sick when they have killed one or two people. Public opinion will accept that. But if it goes on and on to more and more killings, then they think he can’t be sick – he must be evil.

“The whole trial was a charade for public opinion. The man couldn’t be hung – which was what everyone was screaming and shouting about – so he had to be found guilty of something. We’re talking here about majority public opinion, not what you might call ‘thinking opinion’.”

Dr Milne and other forensic psychiatirists now argue that the case shows the weakness of manslaughter as a plea, because it often means that doctors must persuade a lay jury of highly technical points. “It would be more logical for the jury to decide whether a defendant was guilty of killing as such and bring in the expert evidence at the sentencing stage. We knew Sutcliffe had killed these people. All we were interested in was his disposal.”

After the trial, the defence had the choice of appealing or pressing the Home Office for a Section 72 order. They chose to appeal and failed to persuade the court to consider the new evidence of Sutcliffe’s behaviour since conviction.

Dr Milne said: “If he hadn’t been appealing and if I had been asked to see him independently before the appeal, I would have had no hesitation in transferring him under Section 72 at that time. But the Court of Appeal was not interested.”

Dr Milne believes that the restricted prison surroundings are causing Sutcliffe’s condition to deteriorate: “There is no doubt that his basic illness will never burn out, and he can ever he discharged. He knows that – and has done all along. But in a hospital he could be observed and treated, and his condition could improve somewhat.”

His transfer may also improve relations between forensic psychiatrists and the Home Office. “I believe that the whole case has reversed the relationship between law and medicine,” said Dr Milne. “We are back to the old situation where medicine communicates with law, and law communicates with medicine – and the law only accepts that which it wishes.”

UPDATE: In March 1984, nearly three years after Sutcliffe was jailed for murder, the Home Office finally acknowledged that he really was schizophrenic and transferred him to Broadmoor secure hospital. By that time, he had been stabbed in the face by another inmate at Parkhurst Prison. In hospital, he was the victim of three further serious assaults by inmates, one of whom succeeded in blinding him in one eye. In August 2016, it was decided that his mental condition had improved significantly, and he was transferred from hospital back to prison.