The Home Office, the Director of Public Prosecutions, the Attorney-General and the Deputy Commissioner of Scotland Yard were all dragged into the crossfire over police corruption by Granada Television’s World in Action programme last night.
The programme reviewed the progress of the four-year Operation Countryman inquiry into police corruption and contained the first full interview with the original leader of Countryman, Mr Arthur Hambleton, who was Chief Constable of Dorset before he retired in March 1980.
Mr Hambleton said he was sure there was some truth in the flood of allegations received by his team about London detectives planning robberies, extorting money from criminals and stealing reward money. He then retracted his oft quoted statement that Countryman had not been blocked, and accused Mr Patrick Kavanagh, the Deputy Commissioner, and Sir Thomas Hetherington, the Director of Public Prosecutions, of being untruthful about it. He said: “Frankly, Countryman was obstructed.”
Scotland Yard said later that the programme was misleading and factually wrong in many cases. A Metropolitan Police statement said: ” It is extraordinary that a former chief constable should say that he issued a statement from the Dorset headquarters which he knew to be untrue, and that in itself hardly adds to his credibility . . .”
The former Chief Constable of Devon and Cornwall, Mr John Alderson, some of whose men worked for Countryman, said that he believed the inquiry had been run down because it became a political embarrassment. He had spoken to the Home Secretary, Mr William Whitelaw, about it. “I got the impression that Countryman was not popular with the Home Office,” he said.
The former Chief Constable of Cumbria, and ex-Inspector of Constabulary, Mr Frank Williamson, said he had spent two days with the present Metropolitan Police Commissioner, Sir David McNee, warning him of about 20 senior officers who could not be trusted, but that he feared Sir David had then been misled by bad advice from others.
Mr Hambleton, Mr Alderson and Mr Williamson all agreed that London detectives were still corrupt. Mr Hambleton said : “It cannot flourish without the knowledge and public assistance of senior officers.” Mr Alderson said that corruption had become a way of life for some detectives. Their view was reinforced by Mr Alf Sheppard, the London criminal who acted as middle man between a team of robbers and the two London detectives gaoled two weeks ago, Chief Inspector Philip Cuthbert and Sergeant John Goldbourn.
He said that corrupt officers had become so greedy that crime was becoming unprofitable. “If you looked at it sensibly, all you were doing was working for the police to give them a lion’s share of what you were getting.” He described how Chief Inspector Cuthbert had offered to set up robberies and to keep other police away from the area; and had then escorted the robbers with their haul and their guns out of the vicinity. “He was virtually, in his words, handing me the keys to the city,” said Mr Sheppard.
He said that when he started to help Countryman, he had been approached by two Flying Squad officers with what he took to be a warning not to help the inquiry. He had not been surprised, even though Cuthbert and Goldbourn were not in the Flying Squad.
Mr Hambleton described the crucial struggle between Countryman and the Yard on December 7 1979 which resulted in Mr Hambleton issuing a statement to the effect that Countryman had not been obstructed in any way. Last night he publicly retracted that statement.
He said: “I approved that statement which I knew to he untrue in part, but I did it to try and keep the operation together. That was my priority, because the relations between the DPP and the Yard and me had got so bad that the investigation was in jeopardy.”
Mr Hambleton said that the statement was released after a meeting at which Mr Kavanagh had agreed that there had been obstruction from the then head of the Flying Squad, Commander Donald Neesham, who had been transferred as a result.
Asked what he thought of statements by Mr Kavanagh and the DPP that there had been no complaints of obstruction; and that neither obstruction nor Commander Neesham had been discussed at that meeting, Mr Hambleton said: “They are just not true.”
The account of Mr Kavanagh and the DPP was supported in the House of Commons at the time by the Attorney General, Sir Michael Havers, who said that he had looked into the matter with the greatest care and that there was no truth in the suggestion that senior officers had blocked the inquiry.
** Scotland Yard said last night that the World in Action programme was misleading and factually wrong in many cases.
A Metropolitan Police statement said: “It is extraordinary that a former chief constable should say that he issued a statement from the Dorset headquarters which he knew to be untrue and that in itself hardly adds to his credibility.
“Firstly, it is quite wrong to cay that the inquiry into Metropolitan officers ended when Mr Hambleton resigned. The independence of the inquiry was preserved by Sir Peter Matthews, the Chief Constable of Surrey, agreeing to take command.
“That was 18 months after the start of the inquiry which had not then produced any results, because of general concern with lack of progress. Sir Peter delegated inquiries which had no connection with Countryman’s terms of reference to the Complaints Investigation Bureau.
“This allowed the Countryman team to concentrate on the matters they had been appointed to investigate. Sir Peter has not reported any obstruction. Mr Alderson has had no direct contact with the inquiry.”
The Yard statement said one of the officers quoted had retired from the police service in 1972 and was not familiar with the current position within the Metropolitan Police. All of its most senior officers had since changed, some more than once.
The statement added: “There is no condoning of corruption in the Metropolitan Police, but gossip from criminals who have much to gain by discrediting, is not evidence, as every experienced policeman knows. Fair play applies as much to policemen as it does to the rest of the public, and to condemn a class on uncorroborated allegations is less than natural justice.”
Labour MP Mr Dale Campbell-Savours last night sent a telegram to Mr John Biffen, the Leader of the House of Commons, demanding the immediate recall of Parliament over the World In Action allegations.
Mr Dale Campbell-Savours, MP for Workington, said: “I do not usually go running around asking for the recall of Parliament, but the allegations made in this programme make it imperative that MPs debate this issue. All MPs will be incensed by what they saw and heard last night about obstructions placed in the way of the Countryman inquiry.” The programme contained claims that directly contradicted ministers’ statements to the House, he said.
Mr David Winnick, Labour MP for Walsall North. called on the Home Secretary to make an immediate statement and not to wait until Parliament returns in mid-October. Mr Winnick said: “Mr Whitelaw should make a statement as quickly as possible after the remarks of the former head of Countryman in this programme.
“It would clearly be against the public interest and the police force itself if these re-marks and the other allegations over corruption and obstruction of Countryman were to remain unanswered until the Commons returns.
“This matter must surely be the most serious facing the Home Secretary. He should realise this and understand the public disquiet and state what action he now intends to take to deal with these most serious allegations.”
The chairman of the Greater London Council’s Police Committee, Mr Paul Boateng, last night called for an independent inquiry into the Metropolitan Police. “Corruption will always flourish in an atmosphere of secrecy and lack of accountability,” he said.
The Police Federation chairman, Mr Jim Jardine, said: “I think it’s a scurrilous attack on the finest police force in the country – perhaps the finest in the world. Members of the police service have civil rights as well as anybody else, but it seems that policemen are guilty until proven innocent.” It was wrong to make allegations against policemen without having the evidence to take them to court.