Commander ‘tipped off detective about corruption inquiry’

The Guardian, 18 June 1982

An allegedly corrupt London detective was secretly tape-recorded as he discussed his past with an underworld informer, a lawyer’s clerk and other officers, an Old Bailey jury heard yesterday.

On the tape, part of which was played in court, the detective questioned the informer about an interview which he had just had with officers from the Countryman inquiry into police corruption.

Detective Chief Inspector Philip Cuthbert is accused with Detective Sergeant John Goldbourn of conspiring to sell bail and to weaken evidence during two robbery inquiries. Both deny the charges.

The court heart that Mr Cuthbert was ‘tipped off’ about the existence of the Countryman inquiry by a senior officer, Commander Hugh Moore. Mr Cuthbert had been afraid that Commander Moore was going to let him be the ‘patsy’ for the inquiry.

He had gone to his immediate superior, Detective Chief Superintedent John Simmonds, to complain. The two men had agreed to meet for a drink to discuss the situation, but unknown to Cuthbert, Mr Simmonds was carrying a concealed tape-recorder and microphone.

During the early part of the conversation, a lawyer’s clerk, Mr Irvin Shine, told the detectives that Countryman was following up allegations. He explained that he heard of the allegations some time previously from a client. Mr Shine said: “I put Phil in the picture straight away.”

On the tape, Cuthbert then explained that he could not tell anyone this: “You know: his client told him something in confidence, and he let me know in confidence. We went to school together.”