It was at 9.30 in the evening exactly 20 years ago, on August 22 1961, that a neatly-dressed man tapped on the window of the car where Michael Gregsten and his girlfriend, Valerie Storie, were sitting. Six hours later, he had shot Mr Gregsten dead, and raped and shot Miss Storie.
Seven months afterwards, James Hanratty, aged 25, a petty thief, was hanged for the murder, and controversy has raged since. Doubt about Hanratty’s guilt has lingered for 20 years; and yet the flawed procedures which convicted him and provoked the doubt, have survived.
One London solicitor, who specialises in criminal work, said : “We could still hang Hanratty today. The margin for error is still there.”
That margin concerns the ability of witnesses to identify suspects. Five or six years ago, this was a cause celebre. George Davis, George Ince, and Peter Hain were all charged and finally acquitted. The most damning evidence against Hanratty was that of Miss Storie, who identified him as the man who had shot her.
After the Home Office later asked Lord Devlin to examine identification and the law, Hanratty’s supporters tried to re-open the case, saying Miss Storie’s sighting had been too brief and was corroborated only by circumstantial evidence.
They complained that Hanratty was quite unlike the description Miss Storie had originally given to police, and which was reflected in an ldentikit portrait; and that he had appeared on a parade with his hair dyed bright ginger so that, as his barrister put it “he stood out like a carrot in a bunch of bananas.”
Since his trial the original suspect, Peter Alphon, has repeatedly confessed to the murder, then retracted his confessions. Alphon has even named a man who, he alleges, paid him to frighten .Mr Gregsten and his girlfriend, to break up their relationship. The named man declined to discuss the case this week.
Lord Devlin spent two years years gathering evidence for said his report and, in April 1976 he recommended a series of changes In the law which would require the police and the courts to change their practice.
The recommendations were not enacted. The few steps that were taken to allay public concern have fallen well short of what Lord Devlin wanted. Some of the new procedures introduced have been withdrawn.
Justice and other organisations, such as JAIL—Justice Against Identification Laws – report a flurry of cases where identifications have been suspect. Some convictions have been overturned in the Court of Appeal.
One problem is that relationships between police and some black communities have deteriorated so that officers run into an effective boycott when they try to find volunteers for identification parades.
The police have tried to surmount this by adopting unconventional tactics. Solicitors report that many clients have been taken to Underground stations and told to walk up escalators with a crowd of commuters, while the witness stands at the top. The same has been tried on busy city streets.
The Home Office and the police say that, although the new procedures suggest that parades should be conducted at a convenient police station, nothing forbids these parades.
The solicitors complain that the intricate rules about the number of people who should appear on parade, their appearance, the procedure for bringing in witnesses, and all the other details are being ignored. “The rules were drawn up to prevent miscarriages of justice,” said one solicitor.
The intricate demands of the new parade procedure, laid down in Home Office Circular number 109 in 1978, were complemented by new procedures in the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions, announced by the Attorney General in the House of Commons in May 1976.
He told the House: “All (identification) cases of which the director has the conduct will be given the personal consideration of the director himself or his deputy… Such cases will be kept under review in the light of any new developments.”
A spokesman for the director’s office confirmed last week that this had lapsed. Identification cases are now considered at the level of Principal Assistant Director. ” A lot of cases are considered at that level,’ said the spokesman.
At the same time, also in response to the Devlin Report, the then Lord Chief Justice, Lord Widgery, and his senior judges delivered a series of judgments intended to define the future behaviour of the courts.
The judgments fell far short of Lord Devlin’s belief that new rules should be enshrined in law. Even so, one judge described it as “a charter for muggers.” At the same time juries have continued to convict defendants on doubtful identifications.
The fundamental problem was revealed earlier this year in a study by a Home Office psychologist, Clive Hollin, who showed film of street incidents with actors to a selected audience. He found their ability to spot the villain declined as the incident became more violent and involved more people. At their best, only 40 per cent were able to identify correctly.
The problem is worse in practice. Antonio Baisie went to West End Central Police Station with his solicitor last year to attend an identification parade on a malicious wounding charge. His solicitor advised him not to take part when she realised that her bearded, black client was to stand in line with seven men, most of whom were clean shaven and some of whom were not black. The officer agreed to call off the parade, told the solicitor to leave the station, and simply confronted Mr Baisie with the witness, who identified him. Mr Baisie is now serving a 14-year sentence.
Christopher Scales Is serving eight years in Albany Prison on the Isle of Wight. He is contesting his conviction on the grounds that he appeared on a parade after three days without shaving and wearing a jacket which he later discovered belonged to another man involved in the offence.
Lennie Turner is appealing against his conviction for an armed robbery. Eight people told police they saw a gunman during the robbery. They described him variously as of stocky, slim and medium build; fair haired and dark haired; bearded and clean shaven. Mr Turner was later picked out on a parade.
Martin Walker, who runs JAIL under its new title, Criminal Research and Action Group, said: “We’ve been getting an increasing number of cases where the new guidelines are being ignored or watered down.”
The Appeal court recognised this last April, when it quashed the conviction of Peter Lamb for wounding. Lord Justice Lawton said that police had allowed a witness to identify Mr Lamb from a book of ‘mug shots’, a breach of the Home Office rules.