The Home Office has declined to release documents which two men serving lengthy prison sentences claim would help to prove their innocence.
In the case of John Regan, serving 15 years for armed robbery, the document is a statement made by a ‘supergrass’ informer called Michael Gervaise. Supporters of Mr Regan’s cause believe that the statement, like two others previously made by police informers, would bear out Mr Regan’s claim that he is innocent.
But nine months after Mr Gervaise made his statement, it has still not been released to Mr Regan’s family although the Home Office yesterday said that the case was being actively considered.
The second case concerns Paul Cleeland, serving a life sentence for murder, whose case has been surrounded by acrimony and complaint since he was convicted at St Albans in 1973.
Police have held an internal inquiry into the way the case was handled by the police in Hertfordshire. It was conducted by the Assistant Chief Constable of Northamptonshire, Mr E. J. Boothby. It is his report which is now with the Home Office and which, Mr Cleeland believes, can shed light on his conviction.
But the Home Office yesterday repeated its refusal to allow the report to become public. A spokesman said: “There is a general principle of long standing that police reports are confidential and should not be disclosed either wholly or in part to any parties. This has been considered at ministerial level.”
Part of the Boothby report is thought to deal with ballistic evidence. Police said that Mr Cleeland killed his associate, Terry Clarke, by firing a shot-gun at him at close quarters. They produced the gun and called a forensic scientist to support their case.
Mr Cleeland claims that they produced the wrong weapon and that Clarke was actually killed with his own shotgun, which had a sawn-off barrel, and would produce a different type of wound.
The Boothby report is also thought to deal with a confession allegedly made by Cleeland to a man who was in police cells with him when he was first arrested. Mr Cleeland denies talking to the man and claims that another prisoner, Michael Nash, can support his story. But the police said that Nash was not in the cells at the relevant time.
However, Mr Cleeland’s family claims to have received from an anonymous source a hitherto allegedly undisclosed police statement which shows that Nash had been in the cells.
The trial judge was Sir Geoffrey Lane, now the Lord Chief Justice, Lord Lane, and the prosecution barrister was Sir Michael Havers, who is now Attorney-General. The senior officer in the ease, Mr Ronald Harvey, has graduated from his job as head of Hertfordshire CID to become the Chief Inspector of Constabulary’s adviser on crime. He is taking part in the internal inquiry into the hunt for the Yorkshire Ripper.
Mr Bowen Wells, the Conservative MP for Hertford and Stevenage, has been pressing the Home Office over the cases together with his predecessor, Mrs Shirley Williams. He is hoping to raise money to hire a ballistics expert to re-examine the evidence against Mr Cleeland and is also asking the Home Office to allow him or some other individual a sight of the Boothby report.
He said: “The system has done its work ,but the problem is that it can’t be seen to have done so. This is a major defect.”
Despite its unwillingness to release the documents in the two cases in contention, the Home Office has, in fact, been supporting efforts to open up the Police Complaints Board. But so far it has lost the political battle with the police and the Director of Public Prosecutions, who favour confidentiality.
Lord Belstead, Minister of State at the Home Office, is chairing a new working party to consider police complaints and secrecy. An earlier working party, chaired by Lord Plowden, suggested minor changes in the system but its report has been superseded by Home Office research which suggested that the problems were more serious than Lord Plowden’s committee had appreciated.