At first sight, Peter Sutcliffe is a baffling mystery. He is a sex killer who does not have sex with his victims; the product of a normal, stable home, who behaves in a grossly abnormal, unstable way; a popular, sociable man who seethes with hatred and violence.
Psychiatrists believe that the night of his arrest yields an important clue. It was as if he were tempting fate, driving through Sheffield’s red-light district with false number plates on his car and a well-known prostitute by his side.
He knew very well that he was driving into an area where every policeman and passer-by would be watching for him and he must have known that his false plates would make him vulnerable if he were stopped, and yet he persisted.
It was the same with Neville Heath, who was hanged for sexually torturing and killing two women in 1946. He became a suspect because he telephoned the police to offer them advice on the inquiry. Peter Kurten, the Dusseldorf child-killer, was caught after he released girl whom he had tried to rape.
In the same way, John Haigh, who killed at least six people and destroyed their bodies in acid, offered to take the friend of one of his victims to the police station, where a woman officer immediately distrusted him and eventually caused his arrest.
It is not that they wanted to be caught. Psychiatrists quarrel with the popular definition of a psychopath as a person who feels no guilt and prefer to say that a psychopath simply doesn’t feel at all and is prepared to do anything, from killing to flirting with arrest, in order to feel alive.
One psychiatrist who has specialised in treating criminal disorders, said: “With most people, if they are given a fright, you get a flight reaction, that is to say they sweat and their heart rate goes up; in general their nervous system reacts. But some experiments have shown that some psychopaths don’t seem to have this flight reaction.’ They have a lack of cerebral arousal and, it is postulated, they might do quite disturbing things in order to get arousal.
“It’s a bit of an exaggeration of the normal. Normal people might go to a fairground and have a ride on a frightening roundabout to get their excitement. Most of us are sufficiently aroused or excited or disturbed by things like that. But some people have no sort of feeling of themselves. They feel their own deadness. They are unmoved by things and look for some way to get their adrenalin going, to feel alive. It’s the excitement of waiting about in the dark streets and knowing that the police are looking for you.”
Colin Wilson, the author, who has specialised in studying multiple killers, has a similar theory: “Christie is an example. His thing was wanting to screw unconscious or dead girls. He described how he felt after one occasion. He said ‘I experienced that quiet, peaceful thrill. I had no regrets.’
“Tension builds up in these people until they are leading an unreal life. It’s like a fever. They are walking around almost with a permanent pain. Murder becomes a form of release, a way of restoring reality.”
If Peter Sutcliffe is like other multiple killers in that he craves excitement, he is unlike many of them in that there is no ostensible explanation for his decision to choose prostitutes or women in general as his victims. His own explanation – that he was on a divine mission – provoked as many questions as it answered.
Jack the Ripper wrote confessional letters addressed from Hell. Heinrich Pormmerenke raped and killed ten women and claimed he was taking divine revenge. Albert Fish, the New York child-killer, who practised sado-masochism and cannibalism, was a religious zealot.
So Peter Sutcliffe’s insistence that he killed on God’s orders is almost a cliche in forensic psychiatry. The particular problem is that it is also an ideal role for a sane criminal to play if he wants to pretend that he is mentally ill. Larry Gostin, the legal director of MIND, has played the role himself. He spent three months in a North Carolina mental hospital in 1973, pretending to be a paranoid schizophrenic so that he could gather information about the hospital for the Justice Department . in Washington. He fooled all the doctors and says that it was easy.
“I was supposed to have committed a rape. All I did was to show no remorse and say that I heard voices and that God had told me to commit the rape. They all believed me. It’s the most satisfactory illness to feign because it’s so classic. The other thing is that psychiatrists, if they make an error, tend to diagnose illness where there is none rather than the reverse.”
The prosecution pointed to all sorts of inconsistencies in Sutcliffe’s story: he had spent two months in custody before he mentioned God to anybody; he had never even hinted at his mission to his friends or family; he had killed women who were not prostitutes, his crime had always been committed in a cool and premeditated way.
But Sutcliffe always had an answer. His mission had been secret and so he had kept it to himself. His ‘respectable’ victims were prostitutes really: he knew because God had told him. He had done all he could to evade capture because his mission was important and had to be completed.
On either interpretation, Sutcliffe appears to be a psychopath, which satisfies the layman’s instinctive feeling that anyone who can kill as Sutcliffe did must be mad. But to the lawyers and the jurors, that was not enough.
If he was lying about his divine mission, he was psychopathic in the sense that he had abnormal inability to find excitement and to satisfy quite ordinary fantasies. He would also be quite cool enough to concoct and sustain his story about a divine mission and even enjoy the thrill of trying to pull it off, and he would be guilty of murder.
But if he was telling the truth about his voices, he was mentally sick in the fullest sense. He would be in the grip of a delusion and, by virtue of his psychopathic personality, likely to go out and act on the delusion and kill with diminished responsibility. The problem for the jury with this view was to square it with the apparent normality of his job, home, background, and day-to-day behaviour.
But many people who have studied killers believe that this is in itself significant. Colin Wilson, for example, in his Encyclopaedia of Murder, wrote: “Belief in the abnormality of the murderer is a part of the delusion of normality on which society is based. The murderer is different from other human beings in degree, not in kind.”
Delusions vary from the commonplace, such as blaming a relative or a neighbour for everything that goes wrong, to the extravagant, where Russian spies are everywhere and the sick person’s thoughts are being broadcast to the world at large. Typically, the delusion is triggered off by an apparently irrelevant event and then reinforced by all sorts of secondary delusions. If you are being followed by Japanese agents, the stairs creak to prove it.
The source of such delusions is lost in psychiatric confusion. It is said they are inherited or provided by social conditions or simply rooted in bio-chemical disturbances. But there is a clear distinction between the form of the illness and its content.
If it proved impossible at the Old Bailey to explain why Sutcliffe should suffer from this form of illness – a voice and a mission – it was easier to offer some explanation as to why the voice should be that of God and why his mission should be to kill prostitutes.
He told doctors that he had been a devout Roman Catholic until he left school. Possibly if he had grown up in an army camp, he would have heard the voice of a military leader, but it is suggested that his upbringing provided the raw material for him to hear the voice of God.
The psychiatrists made much of his affection for his mother, who had an affair with a policeman, and his depression when she died in 1978. They also stressed the intense relationship which he had with his wife, who was said to be naive, self-centred, and domineering.
The psychiatrists were prepared to accept that he had developed an extremely confused view of women, in particular of prostitutes, and that when he became schizophrenic he fastened on this unhappy obsession and translated it into a mission.
They also suggest that at a deeper level, it is possible that he was independently developing a desire to kill women and that his subconscious threw up the idea of a divine mission so that he would be able to explain it to his conscience and so live with it.