Sutcliffe – “a sadistic murderer who loved his job”

The Guardian, 20 May 1981

The Old Bailey trial of Peter Sutcliffe moved into its final stages yesterday with the last witness completing his evidence and both sides presenting their final speeches to the jury.

For the Crown, Sir Michael Havers QC said that Sutcliffe was “a sadistic, calculating, cold-blooded murderer who loves his job.” He had committed crimes which were beyond ordinary comprehension, “but does it mean he must be mad as or just plain evil, plain bad?”

For the defence, Mr James Chadwin QC told the jury that Sutcliffe must receive “justice not vengeance.” He urged them to avoid being overawed by the enormity of the crimes.

Sir Michael began his closing speech by telling the jury of six men and six women that their task was to test the evidence of the doctors against the known facts and against the testimony of Sutcliffe himself. They must decide whether he had told them the truth.

In his first interviews with police “he started with outright lying coupled with some degree of skill.” Even after admitting that he was the Ripper, he had begun his voluntary statement with a lie, by wrongly saying that Wilma McCann was the first woman he attacked when really she was the third.

He had gone on to leave out several other attacks because, as he said, he wanted to save time. Or was it another example of his well-developed instinct for self-preservation? “So the truth comes out inch by inch,” said Sir Michael.

He reminded the jury of Sutcliffe’s attack on a prostitute with a sock of full of stones after being cheated of £10 and laughed at by another prostitute. Was not this a classic example of provocation?

“God hadn’t told him to hate prostitutes or kill them. It was a reaction which, you may think, was not altogether surprising, the reaction of a man who had been fleeced and humiliated. It was the sort of loss of control which you don’t have to be mad for a moment to suffer.”

If the jury did not accept Sutcliffe’s story of the voice of God, they could look at various alternatives. The whole thing might just be a pack of lies, the invention of a cold calculating killer.

“Or is it because he was having a rough time after his marriage? Was his wife also because of her own illness behaving impossibly so that he dreaded going home?” he asked.

Dr Milne – a psychiatrist who gave evidence for the defence – had told the court that he had never doubted a word of what Sutcliffe told him, and yet he had admitted that there were occasions when Sutcliffe had lied and he could have been deceived.

Dr MacCulloch had made his diagnosis after only half an hour and without reading the police interviews. “What sort of an expert is that, who forms a view without knowing all the facts, without knowing very many facts at all? All he knew was what Sutcliffe told him.”

The police had obtained the reluctant admission, death by death, murder by murder, said Sir Michael. “Would it be unfair to derive from these interviews that he is a calculating man, a skillful man, quick to protect himself, ready to mutilate, ready to humiliate, willing to enjoy killing, willing to prolong death, willing in the end to kill any woman?”

Sir Michael impressed upon the jury that when they considered their verdict they should not flinch or be afraid. The jury had to take a commonsense view of a sickening and nauseating case. They simply had to take a broad view, a detached view, of the evidence.

Sir Michael spent much of his summing-up reminding the jury of the detailed medical evidence.

Mr Chadwin began his summing-up for the defence by telling the jury that he was not going to shirk from the enormity of Sutcliffe’s acts. But the jury should concentrate on the state of Sutcliffe’s mind.

He was addressing the jury on behalf of a man who had admitted killing 13 women attempting to kill seven others. Because of his admissions, he (Mr Chadwin) was faced with the burden of having to prove the defence case.

Usually a defence cannon could, he said, point to doubts and end up saying that tha case must he proved beyond all reasonable doubt.

In this case, however, the defence had to persuade the jury that Sutcliffe had a diseased mind which substantially impaired his responsibility for what he did.

Mr Chadwin referred briefly to the chronological order of the events, as he saw them, leading up to the attacks: Sutcliffe’s motor-cycle accident; his experience in Bingley cemetery; the incident in 1969 involving a prostitute.

Mr Chadwin said he accepted that one of the fundamental questions the jury would have to ask was the origin of Sutcliffe’s disease. He said he had to persuade them that Sutcliffe had, at the time of the killings, believed he had been receiving instructions.

Mr Chadwin said the jury might think, on the facts of the case, that it was no more than commonsense to look at the matter and see what could be explained. They should bear in mind that the doctors say the explanation was paranoid schizophrenia.

Mr Chadwin is due to complete his summing-up this morning.

** Nearly 3,000 copies of the German magazine Quick were recalled from newsagents for pulping yesterday as the City of London police began an inquiry into the illegal photograph of the Sutcliffe trial, carried in the latest issue of the magazine.

The Countess of Gowrie, whose husband is Minister of State at the Department of Employment, resigned as the magazine’s London editor. She was questioned about the photograph by Mr Justice Boreham on Monday and said she knew nothing about it.

In Munich the magazine’s assistant editor, Mr Wolfgang Mueller, said he knew it was Illegal to take such a photograph and that he had deliberately not told Lady Gowrie about it, because he did not want to embarrass her. He had not paid a very large sum for the photograph; and the photographer, whom he did not name, was more interested in the sport of getting the picture than financial reward.

“If you had another Interesting case in England like the Ripper, we would probably try the same thing again,” he added.

About 3,000 copies of the magazine were distributed in the UK on Friday by the London-based firm, Seymour Press. The chairman, Mr Jack Dengel, said he was trying to recall all of them. “We want to show that we are making an effort,” he said. “We have had this trouble with foreign magazines before.”

The photographer, distributor and retailers are all liable for prosecution under the Criminal Justice Act. A police spokesman said the offence carried a fine of £50. It was also suggested in court that the magazine might be prosecuted for con-tempt. The judge has banned Lady Gowrie and any other representative from court for the rest of the trial. Security was tightened yesterday with officers searching all journalists as they entered.