Sutcliffe “laughed as he recalled attacks”

The Guardian, 19 May 1981

Peter Sutcliffe smiled and laughed when he was describing some of his attacks to a psychiatrist and made one of them sound like a joke, an old Bailey jury heard yesterday.

On the eleventh day of the trial the court also heard that a psychiatrist who came across people faking illness “twice a week” had tried and failed to find any evidence that Sutcliffe was pretending to be a paranoid schizophrenic.

Dr Terence Kay, a consultant forensic psychiatrist from Yorkshire, said that he had been struck during his first interview with Sutcliffe by the fact that his outward behaviour often did not match the things which he was saying.

“Sometimes it would be light-hearted. At times he smiled, almost giggled, when discussing quite serious things,” said Dr Kay. Sutcliffe had told him how he attacked a prostitute with a sock full of stones in 1969. “It was told almost as a joke and he laughed.”

When Sutcliffe told of his meeting with Yvonne Pearson, whom he killed in January 1978, the doctor said, “he made it sound rather as if it was amusing him.” He had started laughing when he described how he had sex with another of his victims, Helen Rytka.

Dr Kay told the court that he often saw patients who were feigning mental illness, for example prisoners who wanted to be transferred to hospital or released on parole. This happened about twice a week. He had been warned by prison officers that Sutcliffe was trying to fool the doctors.

During his eight interviews with Sutcliffe, he had constantly changed the subject to stop him preparing answers; avoided using medical words to see if Sutcliffe already knew them; and once conducted the interview at high speed to see if he would make a mistake.

Unlike sexually sadistic killers, Sutcliffe was able to relate to adult women; did not keep pornography or whips or books about Nazism or torture; and killed speedily and often from behind. After the third interview, Dr Kay said, he had diagnosed paranoid schizophrenia, and nothing that he had heard since made him want to change his opinion.

Cross-examining, Sir Michael Havers asked Dr Kay if he had read in a scientific journal an account of an experiment in the United States in which eight ‘pseudo-patients’ had persuaded doctors in 19 different institutions to diagnose them as schizophrenic simply by claiming to hear voices.

Sir Michael said that only the other patients had seen through the act and accused the pseudo-patients of being investigative journalists. Dr Kay said he had read about the experiment and agreed that, ideally, a doctor would find outside corroboration for his diagnosis.

Earlier, Mr Harry Ognall, QC, for the prosecution, had suggested that another psychiatrist, Dr Malcolm MacCulloch, had failed to make inquiries which were fundamental to a proper diagnosis.

He asked Dr MacCulloch what he thought caused Sutcliffe to kill women.

Dr MacCulloch replied: ” I think it was the divine mission.”

Mr Ognall: “Well then, if that account, given by him, if the divine mission is false, then what caused him to kill women?”

Dr MacCulloch: “It is well known that in schizophrenia, killings take place and bizarre killings at that, and it is not possible to offer any logical explanations for the killings because of the nature of schizophrenia.”

Dr MacCulloch said he had not seen the conflicting versions of the killings that Sutcliffe had given in his police statement when he wrote his report.

Asked by Mr Ognall why he had not asked the DPP for permission to see the statements, he replied: “Having seen Sutcliffe three times, I was quite confident of my diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia in relation to the killings.”

Mr Ognall commented that it might have shown common sense to look at the common-sense explanations for the killings offered by Sutcliffe in his police statements. Sutcliffe said that he had killed after being humiliated by a prostitute and that he felt “hatred for her and her kind.”

Mr Ognall: “Is it naive of me to suggest that these statements are capable of affording a perfectly common-sense motive for his killing prostitutes ?”

Dr MacCulloch: “As a psychiatrist I would not agree with you… This illness appears to have started in Bingley Cemetery with the original schizophrenic experience which we have heard about. I do not feel that the average person, having experienced these experiences, would subsequently go on in the way Sutcliffe has now gone.”

Dr MacCulloch accepted that he had placed enormous reliance on what Sutcliffe had told him and that Sutcliffe may have lied or misrepresented events to him. But he had not unreservedly accepted everything he had been told.

Mr Ognall pointed out that Sutcliffe gave as his reason for going to Manchester to kill that “things were hotting up a bit in Leeds and Bradford.” This made “good criminal sense,” but conflicted with the version given to doctors that he went to Manchester because of the divine mission.

Dr MacCulloch said he believed the latter version, because of what Sutcliffe had told him and other psychiatrists. The fact that Sutcliffe had not mentioned his divine mission to the police did not mean that he was not schizophrenic. It might simply mean that he was not of the encapsulated paranoid type.

Mr Ognall pointed out one example where it appeared that Dr MacCulloch had been deceived. Sutcliffe had told the doctor that he had been unconscious for about 12 hours after a motorcycle crash, whereas witnesses had said that he had only been dazed.

This had led Dr MacCulloch to comment in his report. “I suspect there is a link (between the crash and his madness) and that there is some organic impairment.”

Mr Ognall reminded Dr MacCulloch that he had told the court that he knew Sut-cliffe could not be feigning madness because he would not not have been able to stand up to “fine questioning.”

He said: ” I do not seek to play with words. but how could you ‘fine question’ as to whether or not he was lying without knowing what he had said over and over again to other people who were questioning him in detail?”

Dr MacCulloch replied: “You can’t.”

The judge: “If what he has told you is not true, then what of your diagnosis?”

Dr MacCulloch: “It falls.”

Mr Ognall read out Sutcliffe’s statement to police in which he admitted that he knew his last six victims were not prostitutes. He asked Dr MacCulloch: “If his belief at the time he killed and attacked those last six women was that they were not prostitutes, then that is murder?”

Dr MacCulloch: “Yes.”

Mr Ognall said his statement was backed up by the fact that, with his last six victims, his method of attack changed completely. They were random and indiscriminate and did not take place in red-light districts.”

Mr Ognall: “I put it to you… that this shows quite clearly that the thesis of diminished responsibility cannot bear scrutiny.”

Dr MacCulloch: “I do not agree.”

Re-examined by Mr James Chadwin QC, for Sutcliffe, Dr MacCulloch said that when originally asked to attend court, he had expected that he would be giving evidence on behalf of the prosecution.

** The German magazine, Quick, which has published a double-page photograph of Sutcliffe walking from the dock was yesterday banned from court for the rest of the trial.

The judge, Mr Justice Boreham, summoned the magazine’s reporter from the well of the court and questioned her about the photograph after being shown a copy of the magazine by the Attorney General, Sir Michael Havers

The judge told her: “We do not allow people to take pictures in this court, and we do not allow people to abuse this court by publishing them.” It was a disgrace, he said, and there must he no repetition of It.

The Quick photograph was taken from the back of the court and shows Mr Sutcliffe turning to walk down into the cells as the court rose. Those entering the court have had to show a special security pass but have not been searched.

Sir Michael also told the judge that some newspapers had wrongly described the Boothtown area of Halifax as a red-light area. This had caused great anxiety, and estate agents were worried about the effect on property prices. “It is in fact a pleasant residential part of Halifax,” Sir Michael told the judge.