One of the psychiatrists who has diagnosed Peter Sutcliffe as a paranoid schizophrenic conceded yesterday that he could have been conned. He agreed that there was a sexual element in six of Sutcliffe’s attacks.
Dr Hugo Milne, consultant forensic psychiatrist at Bradford Hospital, said under cross-examination that he ‘ought perhaps to have been more accurate’ in his report. He also agreed that Sutcliffe had withheld information from him and was in some ways a liar.
During the day-long cross-examination by Mr Harry Ognall QC, for the Crown, the jury also heard that Sutcliffe’s wife, Sonia, believed that she was the second Christ and heard voices during a period in 1972 when she suffered from acute schizophrenia.
Mr Ognall suggested that Sutcliffe had modelled himself on his wife’s illness and had progressively invented symptoms while in custody. At one point Dr Milne replied : “Either he is a consummate actor or I am an inefficient psychiatrist.”
Dr Ognall read part of Dr Milne’s statement which said he considered there were no “underlying sexual components to the attacks”. He then read Sutcliffe’s statement that he pulled the clothes off one victim “to satisfy some sort of sexual revenge on her.” What did Dr Milne mean by ‘underlying sexual component?’
Dr Milne: “In simple terms, although his victims were female and it might be thought to provide the suggestion he might be a sexual killer, I am not of the opinion that he is primarily a sexual killer.”
Mr Ognall then held up a 7 inch screwdriver, which, he said, Sutcliffe had stabbed three times into the vagina of Josephine Whitaker. “That indicates the most fiendish cruelty, deliberately done for sexual satisfaction ?”
Dr Milne: “It may be the most vicious, foul, cruel thing to do, but not necessarily for sexual satisfaction, Mutilation of the genitalia would have to be repetitive and there is no evidence, as far as I know, that this man has attacked any other victims in such a way or carried out any unnatural acts with them during the killings.”
Dr Milne had said he thought the injuries were accidental. He added : “It would seem my evidence is not as accurate as it should be and I withdraw it.”
Dr Milne said the screw-driver attack “might be sexual, but on the other hand it might not.”
Ognall: “What else could it be but sexual?”
Milne: “It may well have been.”
Ognall: “What else could it have been?”
Milne: “I don’t think it could have been anything else other than sexual.”
Ognall: “It looks as though he deceived you on that one?”
Milne: “Yes.”
Ognall: “Why should he do that?”
Milne: “Perhaps he might have been very reluctant to talk about it.”
Ognall: “Why?”
Milne: “Because of what people might think of him.”
Ognall: Because of what people might think of him? He’s admitted 13 killings and seven attempted killings. Because he might be thought the worse if he stabbed one in the vagina? Is that your considered reply?
Milne: “It is. He said he never wanted to be seen as a sexual killer.”
Ognall: “Oh, no. I accept that. Because if he was seen as a sexual killer, Divine Mission goes out of the window. That’s why. Isn’t it?”
Milne: “It could be.”
Ognall: “Could be?”
Mr Ognall then referred to Sutcliffe’s description of how he stabbed Jacqueline Hill in the breast. He asked again: “He does have a sexual element in some of his killings?”
Dr Milne: “In some of his killings, yes. Perhaps I wasn’t as accurate as I should have been in the report.”
Mr Ognall then asked about the murder of Helen Rytka and the fact that Sutcliffe had admitted ejaculating into her after beating her over the head. Dr Milne said there was an obvious sexual component there, but not necessarily an abnormal one. Mr Ognall asked : “Could you think of anything more obscenely abnormal than his behaviour with that girl ? “
Dr Milne: “I entirely agree with you, but I still think that this was a use of sexual behaviour for the entirely wrong reasons—to avoid detection, quieten her, and get away.”
Mr Ognall: “Dr Milne, this morning I urged you, with great respect, to keep your feet on the ground.”
Mr Ognall then referred to the killing of Marguerite Walls, who had been discovered with finger nail scratches around her vagina. He asked : “No underlying sexual component?”
Dr Milne: “Again, you may be right.”
Mr Ognall recited the names of six of Sutcliffe’s victims – Whitaker, Rytka, Jackson, Walls, Hill and Smelt. Dr Milne accepted that there had been sexual components in all of these attacks.
Ognall: “If there’s a sexual component in the attacks, how is that to be reconciled with the Divine Mission simply to put their lives to an end? If the central point of the Divine Mission doesn’t bear close analysis in the eyes of the jury, where then lies your diagnosis of paranoid schizophrenia?”
Milne: “Very simple. Nowhere.”
Ognall (referring to Sutcliffe’s claim that while working as a grave-digger, he heard the voice of God instructing him to kill): “Without the grave, this man is a murderer?”
Milne: “Yes.”
Dr Milne hesitated before going into details about Sonia Sutcliffe’s illness, and asked the judge whether it was fair for him to read from the notes of another doctor. The judge directed him to continue. Dr Milne said that towards the end of 1972, Mrs Sutcliffe had been aggressive and restless. She had suffered “auditory hallucinations and paranoid delusions.”
The picture was typical of acute schizophrenia, he said. She had heard voices talking to her. Later, he agreed with Mr Ognall that “she had delusions that she was the second Christ.”
Dr Milne was asked to comment on evidence which the jury has heard that Sutcliffe told his wife that he planned to convince doctors that he was mad so that he would get “10 years in a loony bin” and also that he had told a prison officer he was quite normal.
Mr Ognall: “He is a man who is provoked by God, the hapless, tormented, helpless victim of God’s will. I mean nothing blasphemous but I ask you to consider this belief in God’s will in the context of when these killings took place.” Ten of the 20 attacks had occurred on a Friday or Saturday night, when Sutcliffe’s wife was working. Three consecutive attacks had occurred on a Wednesday night. Mr Ognall added: “I suggest that this pattern is the badge of a premeditated killer.”
Dr Milne said he thought the most important pattern was the increasing frequency of the attacks, which suggested that he was becoming madder. “Paranoid schizophrenics are extremely cunning, extremely involved in premeditation and determination not to be caught.”
Mr Ognall asked if he could he wrong in his diagnosis.
Dr Milne answered: ” Of course I could be wrong. I don’t think I am wrong.”
He agreed he could have been ‘wilfully misled’ by Sutcliffe. “It has occurred to me since the very first time I saw this man.” The trial continues.